- The pizza at Tony’s Pizza Napoletana is a can't miss
- pizza
- new yorker
- cal italia
- good for dates
- meatballs
- (15 more)
- Popular
- Recent
- Erin SilkDecember 3, 2014Try the meatball gigante - you won't be disappointed. Enough for 4 to share.
- Parag ShahApril 11, 2011Check out the Cal Italia , one of the most popular items on Yelp, pizza w/fig preserve doesn't sound appetizing but it's somehow mind-blowingly excellent
- Sit at the bar. There's not usually a wait for the seats and you can watch the bartenders concoct some pretty nifty drinks.
- Sarah CallApril 29, 2010Get your name on the list and while you're waiting, take a quick trip to Therapy (the store) on Grant. When you're back at Tony's, order the Scarola con Pancetta or Original Tomato Pie.
- Mother of god get the New Yorker. Meat lovers rejoice!
- Jack HoltAugust 28, 2013Good ingredients, service and ambience. But you won't get crust that's crispy to the point.
- Jeff LevinsohnApril 19, 2010order one of the award-winning margherita pizzas (only 73 made daily). avoid the lines, get it to go, and eat it on a bench in wash sq park just across the street. incredible.
- Ilya MironchykMarch 8, 2020Food is delicious but you gotta wait in line super long. Be ready to wait for one and a half hours at least
- Bruno GielJanuary 21, 2015Margarita pizza is awesome! But they have too many choices for an itialian pizzeria
- Fairly new on their menu: Pizza future, featuring Anchor Steam yeast and Sierra Nevada mozzarella and white cheddar. Gotta love it. Read more
- Top favorites are the New Yorker and the Buratta.
- The Jersey's Original Tomato Pie is our favorite pizza despite NYC and Rome trips to best it!
- Steve CortezAugust 18, 2013Find a nice day. get a calzone and a Coke, and sit on a bench in Washington Square.
- Knut StenmarkJuly 6, 2014My daughter returned from Tony's, crawling up Lombard hill. She got her chicken, but no consolation. That's what I call "Respect the craft"
- Jose Antonio Lopez ArquelladasDecember 17, 2011Totalmente recomendable!. Totally recommended. Try the meatballs, the tomato it's 100% Mediterranean.
- Deny KhoungJuly 13, 2013Try the Prosciutto Wrapped Asparagus - Amazing! That's a fried quail egg on top.
- Famous for the pizzas but the chorizo mussels are beyond amazing. Save room for the giant meatball too.
- Viki LinJuly 4, 2010This place is fantastic. Especially the drink "sweet revenge", delicious. Tony's truffle shaving pizza is absolutely fabulous! A definite must try!!
- Caren ChangSeptember 30, 2014Best spaghetti and meatballs ever. Order takeout to avoid waiting hours
- Make sure to branch out and at least try one new style when you go there. . .you never know, you might just like it!
- Mary S.April 13, 2013Oh. My. Gosh. Those meatballs are the greatest thing my tastebuds have experienced in YEARS.
- OldMan VictorApril 14, 2012Get the Barcelona under the California style 900 degree. Well balanced and pops with flavor!
- Won Sun ParqueAugust 22, 2014Come 20 min. Before they open at 12pm and the line will be much more manageable.
- Bullfrog & BaumJanuary 23, 2013Try the Cal Italia - gold medal winner of Food Network Pizza Champions Challenge.