Check out the Cal Italia , one of the most popular items on Yelp, pizza w/fig preserve doesn't sound appetizing but it's somehow mind-blowingly excellent
Get your name on the list and while you're waiting, take a quick trip to Therapy (the store) on Grant. When you're back at Tony's, order the Scarola con Pancetta or Original Tomato Pie.
order one of the award-winning margherita pizzas (only 73 made daily). avoid the lines, get it to go, and eat it on a bench in wash sq park just across the street. incredible.