Close Icon
Gear IconImportant Reminder:The City Guide app will be sunsetting on December 15, 2024, with the web version to follow in early 2025. Please visit our FAQ to learn more or to download our Swarm app.
Learn more
NYMag Grub Street: Secret Suppers
Craftbar is one of NYMag Grub Street: Secret Suppers.

1. Craftbar

900 Broadway (at E 20th St), New York, NY
New American Restaurant · Flatiron District · 154 tips and reviews

RisaRisa: Grub Street off-menu dish: Large-Format Pork. "$76 dish for two ppl, but it could easily feed more. (You can generally order this simply by walking in, but call ahead to guarantee its availability.)"

Locanda Verde is one of NYMag Grub Street: Secret Suppers.

2. Locanda Verde

9.1
377 Greenwich St (at N Moore St), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Tribeca · 508 tips and reviews

RisaRisa: Grub Street off-menu dish: Wood-Fired Guinea Hen. "Every Tuesday, the kitchen gets a dozen guinea hens from Vermont, a number so small that they don't let the general public know about it."

Peels is one of NYMag Grub Street: Secret Suppers.

3. Peels

325 Bowery (at E 2nd St), New York, NY
Breakfast Spot · East Village · 381 tips and reviews

RisaRisa: Grub Street off-menu dish: "Secret" Burger. "Piedmontese beef slathered w homemade pimento cheese then topped with bacon, pickle jalapeño slaw, pickles, and lettuce. On the side: homemade tater tots."

Atera is one of NYMag Grub Street: Secret Suppers.

4. Atera

8.9
77 Worth St (btwn Broadway & Church St), New York, NY
Molecular Gastronomy Restaurant · Tribeca · 45 tips and reviews

RisaRisa: Grub Street off-menu dish: Charcoaled Tempura Leeks With Strained Buttermilk. "People who order the vegetarian tasting are privy to dishes that meat-eaters won't get, like the fried-leek dish."

B&B Winepub is one of NYMag Grub Street: Secret Suppers.

5. B&B Winepub

25 W Houston St (at Mercer St), New York, NY
Gastropub · SoHo · 289 tips and reviews

RisaRisa: Grub Street off-menu dish: Schnitzel. "super-crispy off-menu schnitzel is made with either pork or veal, comes with seasonal vegetables, and gets finished with lemon-caper buerre blanc."

The Brindle Room is one of NYMag Grub Street: Secret Suppers.

6. The Brindle Room

277 E 10th St (btwn 1st Ave & Avenue A), New York, NY
American Restaurant · East Village · 192 tips and reviews

RisaRisa: Grub Street off-menu dish: Pizza. "an off-menu pizza with a super-crispy crust that's built in a cast-iron skillet at an East Village restaurant otherwise known for its comfort-food classics."

Pegu Club is one of NYMag Grub Street: Secret Suppers.

7. Pegu Club

77 W Houston St (at W Broadway), New York, NY
Cocktail Bar · Greenwich Village · 303 tips and reviews

RisaRisa: Grub Street off-menu drink: Kill Devil. "Rhum agricole, green Chartreuse, and bitters. The garnish: a liqueur-filled lime cup that the bartenders set aflame for just a touch of tiki flair."

The Red Cat is one of NYMag Grub Street: Secret Suppers.

8. The Red Cat

227 10th Ave (btwn W 23rd & W 24th St), New York, NY
New American Restaurant · Chelsea · 130 tips and reviews

RisaRisa: Grub Street off-menu dish: Tempura Bacon. "The over-the-top deep-fried bacon dish has been on and off the menu sporadically, though the restaurant assures us it's always available."

Osteria Morini is one of NYMag Grub Street: Secret Suppers.

9. Osteria Morini

218 Lafayette St (btwn Kenmare & Spring St), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · SoHo · 301 tips and reviews

RisaRisa: Grub Street off-menu dish: Brunch Sub. "Brunch diners at Michael White's Soho spot can get a sandwich of guanciale, a fried egg, and taleggio on a house-made bun. On the side: Pecorino potatoes."

Sauce Restaurant is one of NYMag Grub Street: Secret Suppers.

10. Sauce Restaurant

8.0
78 Rivington St (at Allen St), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Lower East Side · 187 tips and reviews

RisaRisa: Grub Street off-menu dish: Amatriciana. "Extra-thick bucatini tossed w mint & pecorino then topped w a dry-cured, 24-hr braised spare rib belly chop. Call ahead—it takes a full day just to cook it."

Cadaqués Tapas Bar is one of NYMag Grub Street: Secret Suppers.

11. Cadaqués Tapas Bar

188 Grand St (btwn Bedford & Driggs Ave.), Brooklyn, NY
Tapas Restaurant · Williamsburg · 59 tips and reviews

RisaRisa: Grub Street off-menu dish: Suquet. "Catalan seafood stew with shrimp, mussels, market fish, lobster broth, fingerlings, and almonds is worth the inquiry."

Morimoto is one of NYMag Grub Street: Secret Suppers.

12. Morimoto

88 10th Ave (btwn W 15th & W 16th St), New York, NY
Japanese Restaurant · Chelsea · 344 tips and reviews

RisaRisa: Grub Street off-menu dish: Wagyu Beef Bop. "Fried rice and wagyu strip loin in a bowl so hot that it sears the beef at the table."

The Dutch is one of NYMag Grub Street: Secret Suppers.

13. The Dutch

8.6
131 Sullivan St (at Prince St), New York, NY
New American Restaurant · SoHo · 458 tips and reviews

RisaRisa: Grub Street off-menu dish: Spicy Lamb Tacos. "lamb meat topped with radish, cilantro, cabbage, lime, queso fresco, pickled jalapeño, and carrot-tomatillo-garlic-chipotle salsa."

Edi & The Wolf is one of NYMag Grub Street: Secret Suppers.

14. Edi & The Wolf

102 Avenue C (btwn 6th & 7th), New York, NY
Austrian Restaurant · Alphabet City · 160 tips and reviews

RisaRisa: Grub Street off-menu dish: Duck Dinner. "Call ahead, and for $100, 4 people can tuck into an entire roasted duck. Sides include pretzel brioche and braised red cabbage."

Eleven Madison Park is one of NYMag Grub Street: Secret Suppers.

15. Eleven Madison Park

9.1
11 Madison Ave (at E 24th St), New York, NY
Vegan and Vegetarian Restaurant · NoMad · 292 tips and reviews

RisaRisa: Grub Street off-menu dish: Lavender Duck. "The lavender-roasted duck was one of the most famous dishes before the restaurant changed its menu format. You can still call ahead to request the dish."

Via Tribunali is one of NYMag Grub Street: Secret Suppers.

16. Via Tribunali

122 Ludlow St (Delancey), New York, NY
Pizzeria · Lower East Side · 38 tips and reviews

RisaRisa: Grub Street off-menu dish: The Stella. "Nico Calzone — yes, that's his real last name — has this awesome four-point pie. The seasonal toppings change every day. Just ask for it next time you go."

Ardesia is one of NYMag Grub Street: Secret Suppers.

17. Ardesia

8.8
510 W 52nd St (btwn 10th & 11th Ave.), New York, NY
Wine Bar · Hell's Kitchen · 108 tips and reviews

RisaRisa: Grub Street off-menu drink: Faux-Bloody Mary. "There's no vodka served at this westside wine bar. Instead, the staff infuses dry sherry with jalapeño & combines it with pimenton-spiked tomato juice."

No Name Bar is one of NYMag Grub Street: Secret Suppers.

18. No Name Bar

597 Manhattan Ave (btwn Nassau & Driggs Ave), Brooklyn, NY
Bar · Williamsburg · 103 tips and reviews

RisaRisa: Grub Street off-menu dish: An Entire Noodle Counter. "This isn't so much an off-menu dish as it is an entire semisecret restaurant in the basement of a nameless Greenpoint bar."

Corkbuzz is one of NYMag Grub Street: Secret Suppers.

19. Corkbuzz

8.6
13 E 13th St (btwn 5th Ave & University Pl), New York, NY
Wine Bar · Greenwich Village · 130 tips and reviews

RisaRisa: Grub Street off-menu dish: Corn Beignets. "Not only are these fritters--choux pastry beignets, mixed with cornmeal and fresh kernels--unlisted, they aren't even available until 10 p.m."

Telepan is one of NYMag Grub Street: Secret Suppers.

20. Telepan

72 W 69th St (at Columbus Ave), New York, NY
New American Restaurant · Lincoln Square · 86 tips and reviews

RisaRisa: Grub Street off-menu dish: Personal Pizzas. "Bar diners can get individual pizzas if they ask. Toppings change but expect things like veal Parmesan w ricotta; or a cheddar, spinach, & bacon option."

Nitehawk Cinema is one of NYMag Grub Street: Secret Suppers.

21. Nitehawk Cinema

9.5
136 Metropolitan Ave (btwn Berry St & Wythe Ave), Brooklyn, NY
Movie Theater · Williamsburg · 301 tips and reviews

RisaRisa: Grub Street off-menu drink: Barrel-Aged Martinez. "an off-menu Martinez (a combination of gin, sweet vermouth, and Maraschino liqueur) that's been barrel-aged for six weeks.

Maialino is one of NYMag Grub Street: Secret Suppers.

22. Maialino

2 Lexington Ave (at Gramercy Park N), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Gramercy Park · 460 tips and reviews

RisaRisa: Grub Street off-menu dish: Gluten-Free Pasta. "Chef Nick Anderer's kitchen always has a few gluten-free pastas available and can pair any of them with whatever sauces their customers might want."

The Standard Grill is one of NYMag Grub Street: Secret Suppers.

23. The Standard Grill

8.5
848 Washington St (at W 13th St), New York, NY
American Restaurant · Meatpacking District · 381 tips and reviews

RisaRisa: Grub Street off-menu drink: El Gringo Cocktail. "The Standard Grill's El Gringo is a combination of tequila, tarragon-infused triple sec, muddled jalapeño, housemade sour mix, and smoked sea salt."

The Daily is one of NYMag Grub Street: Secret Suppers.

24. The Daily

210 Elizabeth St (btwn Prince & Spring St), New York, NY
Cocktail Bar · NoLita · 66 tips and reviews

RisaRisa: Grub Street off-menu dish: Pig's Head Banh Mi. "This take on the Vietnamese sandwich used to be available only at brunch at Public, but now it's at the adjacent cocktail bar during the evening."

Lowcountry is one of NYMag Grub Street: Secret Suppers.

25. Lowcountry

142 W 10th St (Between Waverly and Greenwich), New York, NY
Southern Food Restaurant · West Village · 43 tips and reviews

RisaRisa: Grub Street off-menu dish: Cornmeal-Crusted Oysters. "This Southern staple was excised in favor of pimento-cheese-baked oysters. But fans of the original can still request it."

dell'anima is one of NYMag Grub Street: Secret Suppers.

26. dell'anima

38 8th Ave (at Jane St), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · West Village · 167 tips and reviews

RisaRisa: Grub Street off-menu dish: Ricotta Tortellini. "There's plenty of pasta on the menu, but one that's always available is this rich combo of creamy ricotta & seasonal produce such as beets or eggplant."

Marble Lane at Dream Downtown is one of NYMag Grub Street: Secret Suppers.

27. Marble Lane at Dream Downtown

355 W 16th St (btwn 8th & 9th Ave.), New York, NY
New American Restaurant · Chelsea · 28 tips and reviews

RisaRisa: Grub Street off-menu dish: Sweet-Potato Fries With Harissa Aioli. "Several off-menu options--steamed buns, lobster dumplings, & even desserts--but our favorite is still the crispy sweet-potato fries."

Hill Country Barbecue Market is one of NYMag Grub Street: Secret Suppers.

28. Hill Country Barbecue Market

8.6
30 W 26th St (btwn Broadway & 6th Ave), New York, NY
BBQ Joint · NoMad · 489 tips and reviews

RisaRisa: Grub Street off-menu dish: Chili Mac. "Red chili & macaroni and cheese are both regularly available, but upon request, the restaurant is more than willing to combine them into a single gonzo mash-up."

Recette is one of NYMag Grub Street: Secret Suppers.

29. Recette

328 W 12th St (Greenwich St.), New York, NY
French Restaurant · West Village · 92 tips and reviews

RisaRisa: Grub Street off-menu dish: Foie-and-Langoustine Wellington. "Instead of beef Wellington, the staff swaps in langoustine & fatty goose liver into a tiny puff pastry shell w a Japanese red curry sauce."

Rosemary's is one of NYMag Grub Street: Secret Suppers.

30. Rosemary's

9.0
18 Greenwich Ave (at W 10th St), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · West Village · 384 tips and reviews

RisaRisa: Grub Street off-menu dish: Linguine alla Herbe. "They've still got at least one secret dish: a plate of linguine and ricotta finished with a garden's worth of herbs from the trattoria's rooftop."