See all
1,109 photos

Prince Street Pizza

Pizzeria$$$$

NoLita, New York

Save

Prince Street Pizza

9.1^/10

1,934

ratings

Ranked #7 for pizza in New York
"The Spicy Spring is probably the best square slice in the city!"(22 Tips)
"Vodka slice or Soho square - Prince St has the right doughy..."(15 Tips)
"Spicy pepperoni square slice all the way!"(9 Tips)
"Go for a square pizza slice, for sure one of the best in town!"(12 Tips)

354 Tips and reviews

Filter:

pizza
spicy spring
good for a quick meal
soho square
casual
lively
quick dinner
pepperoni
good for a late night
good for singles
Sicilian
great value
tours
city
vodka
grandma slices
crowded
crispy food
lines
inexpensive
(15 more)

Sort:

Popular
Recent

First We FeastAugust 3, 2014
If you've got some room left after a Sicilian slice, order a grandma square slice—it's thin, crisp, and topped with more of that milky white mozz. Read more
sam josephSeptember 1, 2015
Best square pizza in the city. Lots of pepperonis.
JessieJuly 10, 2018
Pepperoni square. The crust is worth the line.
Brenna DigginsJanuary 13, 2018
If you like thick crust pizza this is literally the best you will ever have
Andrew CerdaNovember 29, 2012
Don't get trapped between the door, trash can, and brick wall. It's a tight squeeze, even before you gobble up a few slices of their pizza deliciousness.
Stuart CoatesMay 15, 2015
The margherita pizza has been refined here for decades, leaving me longing for another New York slice.
Kimmie OhhNovember 24, 2019
Get their pepperoni slice & the arancini.
allisonJuly 16, 2016
Hot square! Are you famous enough to get your photo on the wall? 🍕🍕🍕
Brian StraussAugust 8, 2023
Spicy pepperoni square slice all the way!
Rachel PortSeptember 30, 2016
I loooove the pepperoni here, so crunchy on the edges.
Christina ChinJune 13, 2015
Its true, pepp square is pretty awesome. Crisp to perfection and the dough is fluffy and chewy
JillianDecember 29, 2015
For the love of god, go pepperoni square
Gideon OlshanskyJune 29, 2018
Lives up to the hype. Worth the wait.
Jimmy LuOctober 24, 2018
Got the classic cheese. Loved the classic cheese!
Juan Pablo LunaMay 13, 2016
Square Pepperoni Pizza. Awesome!
Harry RaymondFebruary 1, 2016
Spicy pepperoni square pizza is top-notch.
Clara WuAugust 13, 2015
Been here 10+ times
best pizza in Manhattan. sorry Grimaldi, joes, artichoke, etc.
Steff HindMarch 7, 2015
Little hole in the walk pizza place serving pizza by the slice. Also offer rice balls and calzone
Mike TaffetApril 18, 2013
Just grab the first slice that catches your eye. No need to worry about how good it is...(spoilers: IT'S DELICIOUS)
Katerina AnnaNovember 29, 2014
Been here 5+ times
GREAT place, excellent pizza! Have a slice of each, tried all of them, they are amazing!
Cass CJanuary 4, 2017
Get a few pepperoni squares and a stack of napkins to wipe up the grease
Bryant BalatbatNovember 8, 2016
Been here 5+ times
Spicy spring street pizza. Forget everything else.
Geoffroy BablonApril 28, 2014
Been here 5+ times
On a warm day when the doors are fully open, sit at the long bar facing the street and watch the strange crowd go by.
Laura MartinezOctober 9, 2020
Spicy pepperoni can be a touch too spicy for me, but everything else about this pizza is flawless
Sean LudwigSeptember 9, 2015
Excellent place for a very quick slice. Fantastic pepperoni square pizza
Jonny BJanuary 23, 2016
Pepperoni all the way! Truly amazing.
DanMay 8, 2016
Been here 5+ times
Square Pepperoni slice is great!
MischaSeptember 17, 2015
Excellent slices, and pieces. No funky toppings or unnecessary veggies, just honest simple pizza.
Hannah LaHoodNovember 24, 2014
Been here 10+ times
Probably my favorite place to grab a slice. the pepperoni square is a must!
Kevin GrantSeptember 20, 2016
Been here 5+ times
Pepperoni Squares are delish - but don't ignore the Sicilian, it's also a treat!
HashtagNYUApril 6, 2016
Thick, gooey, square-ish slices... and OMG the pepperonis! This will become your favorite.
Emily K.November 3, 2016
Always the square slice with pepperoni.
Graham GnallJanuary 26, 2018
Pepperoni (spicy spring). Top slices in NYC
Jordan DaileyApril 15, 2016
Been here 5+ times
Pepperoni Sicilian is the move.
Greg ZulkieDecember 2, 2016
The staff might be grumpy, but the pizza is super good. Beware: sometimes they run out and close up early for the night.
HashtagNYUMarch 21, 2016
Only a short walk from 194 Mercer, Prince Street Pizza's Soho Square pizza is a MUST-TRY! Read more
Eugene KimbergMay 8, 2016
The essence of NYC pizza. Grab yourself a slice of margherita and do not bother with other kinds.
Nina YiamsamathaFebruary 8, 2015
Pay homage to the photo of James Gandolfini, apparently taken 3 days before he died
Kathy LiuJuly 6, 2018
Delicious pepperoni pizza. Only con: nowhere to sit, and too hot to stand around eating
Lauren RomaoJune 17, 2017
There's alot of competition in the pizza game of NYC and this takes the cake. Perfecto!
Tyson GachMay 12, 2019
👌🏼 Spicy Spring square slice
LisaJanuary 15, 2019
Pepperoni pizza!! Yum!!
Joseph EylesJanuary 17, 2019
The pepperoni corner square is the best
Elizabeth BursteinJuly 24, 2017
Bring napkins because the pepperoni gets super oily !
Max KahnMay 22, 2017
Pepponi slice. If theirs is a 10, and I think it is, no other slice I've ever had is more than a 6.
Owen HerterichAugust 28, 2016
Amazing pepperoni squares.
OndrejOctober 25, 2015
Tried both regular and square slices - the square one was so delicious.
ᴡ CallahanOctober 6, 2015
Obv get pepperoni square slice. Greasy as heck but delightful
Malcolm ChangJune 24, 2016
Get the Spicy Sicilian square
CarolApril 4, 2024
Long line for good ol’ plain nyc pizza. At one point they announced cash only & told you when you made it to the register. I’m sure many people were pissed when they had to leave and lose their spot

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8

1,109 Photos

Prince Street Pizza

Related Searches

You might also like

Places people like to go after Prince Street Pizza

Appears on 2,789 lists

Is this your business? Claim it now.