Prince Street Pizza
Pizzeria$$$$
NoLita, New York
"The Spicy Spring is probably the best square slice in the city!"(22 Tips)
"Vodka slice or Soho square - Prince St has the right doughy..."(15 Tips)
"Spicy pepperoni square slice all the way!"(9 Tips)
"Go for a square pizza slice, for sure one of the best in town!"(12 Tips)
354 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- pizza
- spicy spring
- good for a quick meal
- soho square
- casual
- (15 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Connie XiaoFebruary 9, 2017A fresh-out-the-oven square slice of pepperoni pizza at Prince Street = the pizza of my dreams 🤤🍕❤️
SolJanuary 2, 2019Pepperoni slice is the best Sicilian you can get, better when fresh so eat it right away.- aJuly 1, 2016Very good pizza spot in the area, maybe one of the best in Manhattan. Regular slice is good, but square pepperoni was my fave.
Louis BitskoJune 28, 2016The square pepperoni is unmatched for pizza in the area. None of the fancy stuff. Classic Great
If you want a whole pie you can order delivery or pickup through an app, if you visit, grab a slice or two of the spicy spring squares.
Georgia LuddeckeMay 14, 2017The pepperoni square is out of this world. Favorite pizza in Manhattan! 🍕
AmateurConciergeJune 21, 2019Very solid slice. Not the best on the island but top 3-5 downtown. The lines are annoying but whatever. Get a square slice with Pepperoni and shut up. The whole neighborhood is sceney what u expect
Amy ParkOctober 23, 2017My favorite non traditional pizza in NYC. MUST TRY. prepare yourself for grease dripping hands.
The vodka sauce slice is great, but before you start eating, make sure to blot some of the oil off the top of it. You'll need three napkins. You'll feel less like death afterward.
Sam GilDecember 15, 2017Sicilian regular slice had amazing tomato sauce, the pepperoni was perfect..except the pepperonis - bit over cooked style. Great slices though.
Karen SterlingMarch 7, 2016Omg!!!! The pepperoni pizza square made my tastebuds crazy for more!! Oh yum!!!
jiresellNovember 28, 2015So good. Get the Sicilian style with pepperoni. One of the best by the slice shops in Manhattan!
Tabitha JohnsonDecember 20, 2016Go at an off hour, the line is not as long. The Spicy Spring is delicious!
Maxwell FoxmanJune 20, 2017Delicious pizza. Don't expect more than one or two types of slices (margarita, pepperoni) but they are very tasty!
DelilahMarch 27, 2014Best pizza I've had in NYC. High quality ingredients and delicious combination of ingredients. My fave is Mercer Margherita!
Alex RavenelJuly 25, 2015The square slices, especially with pepperoni, are among the best in the city.
I'm not an *expert* in pizza (yet), but the pepperoni square is one of the best slices in the city. Order two.
My new favorite pizza place. Have to order the pepperoni square!
AdrienApril 15, 2016Order any of the square pizza, seat at one of the front table and watch the great Prince street in action
The buttery-crusted Sicilian slice is among the best you'll find in the entire city.- Best pizza by the slice in NYC. Square pepperoni 🍕👌🏼
Paul HuangMay 16, 2018The pepperoni pizza here is what you come here for. They don't place the pepperonis on the pizza, they DUMP them on!
Sarah BJuly 4, 2014My favorite pizza in NY!!! Square Pepperoni YUM YUM YUM YUM!!! Delicious! Will definitely come back! 5 stars
Greg AndersonFebruary 7, 2016Best pizza in NYC hands down. Get the pepperoni Sicilian slice and savor all the goodness that ensues
Even if it weren't square, the square pepperoni slice would probably be incredible. But there's something about that square... It comes out of the oven hot, give it a minute.
Kevin SNovember 22, 2017Regular sicilian. And also the spicy pepperoni. Come here after lunch. It's a wait if you try to lunch here.
Angie AldanaFebruary 11, 2018The best pizza slice in NYC in my opinion! Sometimes long lines but deff worth it! ❤️
Melissa frankDecember 22, 2014Sicilian Pizza is delicious. Perfectly cooked and the sauce has a hint of sweetness. Open late too!
FionaOctober 18, 2014Order a margherita slice, have it warmed in the oven, and enjoy immediately. A perfect slice every time, grandma or regular!
Mike O'SullivanSeptember 28, 2015Hands down the best pizza in the city. Get a square pepperoni slice, you won't be disappointed
Duncan HowsleyAugust 25, 2014Exceptionally good pizza. Get the pizza squares. Their marinara sauce is out of this world.
AlyssaJanuary 3, 2016The square pizza is out of this world, definitely on par with other great NY slices
Jeremy MooreNovember 10, 2017Spicy square slices - obviously. I like it more well done, and they're happy to oblige.
1,109 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Prince Street Pizza
27 Prince St (btwn Mott & Elizabeth St)
New York, NY 10012
United States
New York, NY 10012
United States
Located in the heart of SoHo and featuring a traditional exposed brick décor and seating for twelve, the restaurant will offer curb side pick up allowing customers to drive or bike up to the storefront and have their order brought out to them.
Open until 3:00 AM (Show more)
- Mon–Tue, Thu–Sun
- 10:00 AM–3:00 AM
- Wed
- 10:00 AM–Midnight
(212) 966-4100
Features
Reservations
No
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. American Express)
Outdoor Seating
No
Food & Drink
Menus
Lunch, Dinner
See More
You might also like
- 9.0
"The pizza is amazing and specially the meatball sub is divine. All the guys working there are great."
Tomke Krohne - 8.3
"Best Pizza I Have EVER Had! White with fresh moz and basil, delicious!"
ᴡ Tracey - 9.1
"Amazing pizza slice, excellent for late night pizza. Place is always packed but the line goes fast. Go for the regular cheese slice, it's simply perfect!"
Zsuzsanna Miklósi
Places people like to go after Prince Street Pizza
Appears on 2,789 lists
The 25 Best Pizza Places in NYC
Created by Foursquare Swarm
25 items • 397 followers
Created by Allison D.
199 items • 88 followers
Created by D
161 items • 213 followers