Close Icon
Gear IconImportant Notice:We have made the tough decision to say goodbye to the Foursquare City Guide mobile app, effective December 15, 2024, with the web version to follow in early 2025. Visit our FAQ for more information or to download our Swarm app.
Learn more
Big Belf's Big List of NYC Pizza

Big Belf's Big List of NYC Pizza

Creator Avatar
Created by James B • Updated On: May 25, 2014
La Montanara by Forcella is one of Big Belf's Big List of NYC Pizza.

1. La Montanara by Forcella

168 Ludlow St (btwn Stanton & E Houston St.), New York, NY
Pizzeria · Lower East Side · 8 tips and reviews
Totonno's Pizzeria Napolitano is one of Big Belf's Big List of NYC Pizza.

2. Totonno's Pizzeria Napolitano

8.0
1524 Neptune Ave (W 15th & W 16th St.), Brooklyn, NY
Pizzeria · Coney Island · 108 tips and reviews
Lucali is one of Big Belf's Big List of NYC Pizza.

3. Lucali

9.2
575 Henry St (btwn Carroll St & 1st Pl), Brooklyn, NY
Pizzeria · Carroll Gardens · 251 tips and reviews
Don Antonio is one of Big Belf's Big List of NYC Pizza.

4. Don Antonio

8.8
309 W 50th St (at 8th Avenue), New York, NY
Pizzeria · Hell's Kitchen · 376 tips and reviews
Sottocasa Pizzeria is one of Big Belf's Big List of NYC Pizza.

5. Sottocasa Pizzeria

9.0
298 Atlantic Ave (btwn Smith & Hoyt St.), Brooklyn, NY
Pizzeria · Boerum Hill · 117 tips and reviews
Nicoletta is one of Big Belf's Big List of NYC Pizza.

6. Nicoletta

160 2nd Ave (at E 10th St), New York, NY
Pizzeria · East Village · 88 tips and reviews
Motorino is one of Big Belf's Big List of NYC Pizza.

7. Motorino

8.5
349 E 12th St (at 1st Ave), New York, NY
Pizzeria · East Village · 317 tips and reviews
Ribalta is one of Big Belf's Big List of NYC Pizza.

8. Ribalta

8.3
48 E 12th St (btwn University Pl & Broadway), New York, NY
Pizzeria · Greenwich Village · 107 tips and reviews
Kesté Pizza & Vino is one of Big Belf's Big List of NYC Pizza.

9. Kesté Pizza & Vino

271 Bleecker St (at Morton St), New York, NY
Pizzeria · West Village · 275 tips and reviews
Paulie Gee's is one of Big Belf's Big List of NYC Pizza.

10. Paulie Gee's

9.3
60 Greenpoint Ave (btwn Franklin & West St), Brooklyn, NY
Pizzeria · Greenpoint · 401 tips and reviews
Co. is one of Big Belf's Big List of NYC Pizza.

11. Co.

230 9th Ave (at W 24th St), New York, NY
Pizzeria · Chelsea · 139 tips and reviews
Forcella is one of Big Belf's Big List of NYC Pizza.

12. Forcella

334 Bowery (btwn Bond & Great Jones), New York, NY
Pizzeria · NoHo · 75 tips and reviews

13. Franny's

348 Flatbush Ave (btwn Sterling Pl & 8th Ave), Brooklyn, NY
Pizzeria · North Slope · 221 tips and reviews

Travel ChannelTravel Channel: Don’t miss the amazing pizzas, pastas and house-cured meats at Franny’s. The eggs and spicy pickles and the prosciutto are not to be missed. – Adam Richman, Man v. Food Read more.

L&B Spumoni Gardens is one of Big Belf's Big List of NYC Pizza.

14. L&B Spumoni Gardens

9.1
2725 86th St (at W 10th St), Brooklyn, NY
Pizzeria · Gravesend · 432 tips and reviews

Travel ChannelTravel Channel: The Square is a singular, impressive, culinary achievement. And a kick-ass slice of pie. – Adam Richman, Man v. Food

Patrizia's Pizza and Pasta is one of Big Belf's Big List of NYC Pizza.

15. Patrizia's Pizza and Pasta

8.5
35 Broadway (Btwn Dunham and Wythe), Brooklyn, NY
Pizzeria · Williamsburg · 71 tips and reviews
Di Fara Pizza is one of Big Belf's Big List of NYC Pizza.

16. Di Fara Pizza

8.5
1424 Avenue J (at E 15th St), Brooklyn, NY
Pizzeria · Midwood · 351 tips and reviews
Grimaldi's Pizzeria is one of Big Belf's Big List of NYC Pizza.

17. Grimaldi's Pizzeria

7.8
1 Front St (at Cadman Plaza W), Brooklyn, NY
Pizzeria · DUMBO · 592 tips and reviews
Roberta's Pizza is one of Big Belf's Big List of NYC Pizza.

18. Roberta's Pizza

9.3
261 Moore St (at Bogart St), Brooklyn, NY
Pizzeria · East Williamsburg · 864 tips and reviews
Nonna's L.E.S. Pizzeria is one of Big Belf's Big List of NYC Pizza.

19. Nonna's L.E.S. Pizzeria

105 Clinton St (btwn Delancey & Rivington), New York, NY
Pizzeria · Lower East Side · 52 tips and reviews
Rizzo's Fine Pizza is one of Big Belf's Big List of NYC Pizza.

20. Rizzo's Fine Pizza

17 Clinton St (Houston St. and Stanton St.), New York, NY
Pizzeria · Lower East Side · 49 tips and reviews
Bleecker Street Pizza is one of Big Belf's Big List of NYC Pizza.

21. Bleecker Street Pizza

8.3
69 7th Ave S (at Bleecker St), New York, NY
Pizzeria · West Village · 180 tips and reviews
Muzzarella Pizza is one of Big Belf's Big List of NYC Pizza.

22. Muzzarella Pizza

221 Avenue A (btwn E 13th & 14th Sts), New York, NY
Pizzeria · East Village · 30 tips and reviews
Best Pizza is one of Big Belf's Big List of NYC Pizza.

23. Best Pizza

9.0
33 Havemeyer St (btwn N 7th & N 8th St.), Brooklyn, NY
Pizzeria · Williamsburg · 200 tips and reviews