Burger & Lobster
(Now Closed)Burger Joint and Seafood Restaurant$$$$
Flatiron District, New York
269 Tips and reviews
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Jill CJuly 3, 2016The lobster here is so good and the lemon butter sauce is outtathisworld. Worth the wait if there is one.
Just go with the lobster roll - great value for what you get not to mention very tasty!
Oleksii PanteleichukApril 30, 2017Excellent lobsters (ans sizes!), excellent burgers! Highly Recommended!- Ali ColangeloMarch 5, 2016The lobster roll is where it's at. As good as any I've had in New England!
elizabeth museFebruary 13, 2015Grilled lobster comes with French fries and side salad! Pretty good but not a ton of food
VivianSeptember 22, 2021Trivia on Tuesdays! Good food and drink deals, winning team gets money off their tab
Audrey KrassnitzerMarch 18, 2015Great concept: 3 items only, burger lobster lobster roll. $20 does the trick. Great service.
Leatrice JonesJanuary 2, 2017Everything is great here. It would be nice if they added a veggie burger to the menu.- Chad HornerSeptember 16, 2017they've recently expanded their menu (more burger and lobster roll options). not as simple a decision as it used to be
Marcus J.December 8, 2015Great food and drinks and inexpensive. What more could you as for?? I'll wait...
Elizabeth MaiuoloApril 13, 2016The lobster roll was amazing!! Right size. Buttery! ❤️ fries/burger standard
Patricio MJuly 19, 2015Trendy, tasty, tight sitting (for the antisocial in me), and perky servers :-)
The three menu items are all good! Love the simplicity of decision-making!
Erin CrawfordDecember 21, 20153 options: burger, whole lobster or lobster roll! All $20 All delicious
Michael DempseyJanuary 22, 2015Everything is $20. Lobster roll is great, 1.5 pound lobster is best value.
Mohammad Al-absaiSeptember 10, 2015A great restaurant with only three items all of them are super tasty!
Foursquare InsidersOctober 7, 2015"Burger or lobster. Two choices. Both $20. Done." - Alexa Mehraban, @EatingNYC Read more
Afro lynneAugust 16, 2016Overwhelming, be prepared for a long wait with everything! Good deals though if you are patient enough.
Kevin O'NeillJuly 30, 2017I mean the concept is good. But then you kinda realize theyre clinging to the novelty of it and you wish you went to somewhere else for a solid burger.
This is my new go-to restaurant. Who doesn't love$20 lobster?
Samantha JoApril 28, 2017Keep it simple. Grilled lobster... eat the fries while they're hot and save the salad for last.
Rodrigo SalazarApril 24, 2016like that its a limited menu (hence the name) but they do these things VERY well
Sue LeeJune 14, 2015I honestly don't know how anyone could not love this place. Go before it starts getting really popular.
Chris GampatJanuary 17, 2020Very good overall. Don’t have the lobster and beef together. Do them separate.
Robert AccetturaAugust 1, 2016You're most likely getting the Lobster. I'd suggest getting it grilled. For a flat rate it's pretty good.
960 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Burger & Lobster - Flatiron is a British-born restaurant located at 39 W 19th St in New York. Our menu offers a wide range of burgers, oysters, whole lobster or lobster rolls with chips and salad for set price in a big space with a happy hour. We also have a selection of cocktails available.
Permanently closed (Show more)
- Mon–Sun
- Noon–10:00 PM
(646) 833-7532
Features
Reservations
No
Credit Cards
Yes
Outdoor Seating
No
Wheelchair Accessible
Yes
Music
No
Parking
Street
Restroom
Yes
Food & Drink
Drinks
Beer, Full Bar, Cocktails
See More
You might also like
Places people like to go after Burger & Lobster
Appears on 1,144 lists
Ultimate Summertime Lobster Rolls
Created by Foursquare Swarm
89 items • 248 followers
NYC's Most Mouthwatering Burgers
Created by Foursquare Swarm
20 items • 407 followers
Where You and Your Crew Can Dine On the Cheap
Created by Foursquare Insiders
12 items • 261 followers