Burger & Lobster
(Now Closed)Burger Joint and Seafood Restaurant$$$$
Flatiron District, New York
269 Tips and reviews
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
RyanMarch 1, 2015Just as good as the London locations. Be sure to ask for the garlic butter sauce for your fries.
Brian WatsonJanuary 29, 2015From London to NYC! You should come here. Everything is $20. Get the lobster roll, order a side of butter, and dip your fries in that joint.
The lobster roll here is such a great deal. $20 for a huge lobster roll, fries, and a salad. Why ever go to Luke's ever again?
Dan FetznerJune 28, 2015One of the better lobster rolls I've had, and I'm a man who enjoys his lobster rolls. The bread makes all the difference. Well worth the $20 price tag.
DanitaMarch 13, 2015You had me at lobster. As if that wasn't enough, the drinks are pretty great, too. Go for the "Harvey Nic." Presumably named after the famed Harvey Nichols department store across the pond.- Tamara GreenMay 7, 2015The burger & lobster was great and our waitress was wonderful my son loved his lobster dish 👍🏾
VivJanuary 19, 2015More lobster and better value than the London outposts. Check out downstairs for where they keep the lobsters!
Javier G HRNovember 9, 2015WOW!! Loved this place! Just 3 options: lobster, lobster roll and hamburger!!
- Grace KwanJuly 31, 2016Not the best lobster you've ever had, but certainly the best deal for a whole steamed lobster! Butter makes everything better. If you get a burger here, I'll judge you.
Rory ParnessOctober 23, 2015Legit lobster roll, salad (small) and fries for only $20. It gets packed so get there early or be prepared to wait.
EricApril 28, 2017Get The Original lobster roll, can't go wrong with how good it totally is. A great combination of everything.
Alice faultcoreOctober 6, 2015Wonderful place, burger is amazing and they cut it if you are not alone and want to try all meals in the menu
RonniSeptember 27, 2016The original lobster roll was delicious. Great meal and we were seated so quickly!
Katelyn CaillouetFebruary 21, 2015Only serve 3 dinner items - lobster, lobster rolls, & burgers. The lobster roll was amazing!
Mischa LumiereFebruary 20, 2015Enormous! Lobster was solid especially at $20. How can you beat that?! Great value for the area. I'd come again.
Kim GillJanuary 31, 2016The food was delicious. My only problem was I still felt hungry. Order 2 meals if you can.
Sagy MirandaJanuary 3, 2015No menu, only 3 dishes: lobster roll, cold lobster and burger. Everything 20. 😱 try the burger.
JillianDecember 22, 2015The burger is insanely delicious. Limited menu is so appreciated in this case. Playlist is fiyure as well. I.e. old school Britney
Fernando FigueroaMarch 18, 2015One of the best burgers I have ever had! Cheddar and American cheese plus bacon, and the bun is really good.
Dan ChengFebruary 28, 2016Simple and excellent. They do what they do best! Food, atmosphere, and service were spot on.
Kiwi WangOctober 4, 2016So happy when they came from London! Delicious and such a great deal. Burger is actually delicious too haha- drew tarvinJuly 12, 2015When you only have a few things on the menu, you better do them well. They do, the burger is the best of the three.
Betty StuddmuffinetteDecember 22, 2015The lobster is such a good deal. Definitely get the lemon garlic butter! So yum!
Ari NicoleAugust 16, 2018Wash all the tasty Burgers & Lobsters down with their signature Sangria. It has tequila & peach schnapps 😍😍
Cee SyMarch 26, 2018Nice ambience. Burger could have been juicier. Lobster a bit more tender. Considering the price pt.
Emily RoyJune 24, 2015Absolutely delicious! Go with a friend and split a burger and a lobster roll, they'll even cut it for you!
Corley StoneJune 26, 2015The lobster roll is pretty decent. Get one and have your friend get a burger and then split! Worth it.
Janice KarbachinskiyApril 27, 2016Skip the cocktails, they have a great beer selection. Food is wonderful
Gabriel HayesFebruary 3, 2015Bartenders are very good. Can make cocktails off the menu. Order a Dark & Stormy, which was delicious
Baz ColemanMarch 19, 2015This place is bomb. $20 for lobster, a lobster roll or a burger. Watch out for the drink prices though.
The lobster roll here might just edge out my previous favorite from Luke’s Lobster—and it’s appreciably larger as well.
Brenda ParisNovember 14, 2016What isn't good? Menu is simple and succulent. If you love lobsters and burgers...enjoy!
Leanne ZJune 9, 2017Solid food, good service, large space and good for getting a table even without a reservation.
Frank E. RodriguezJuly 31, 2016The Lobster and the burger and the best combination in the tree only option the server
Rami MassoudJuly 22, 2016Love the concept, two item for menu makes deciding easy. Good burger, but nothing special about it other than the bun. Great fries too.
Foxxy BOctober 11, 2015Relatively large and good quality lobster roll for the $20. Large chain-esque space, with steely but swift service.
The GorodMarch 4, 2015This place is surely a huge hit for lobster lovers and those, who appreciate the ultimate rich taste of their burger.- Carla OrtizJanuary 23, 2018Go for the happy hour at the bar for $5 burger and lobster bites and drinks.
You can switch your salad for more fries or switch your fries for more salad
- There's a new menu (Oct 2016). There's a lobster/ burger burger
Channon FordSeptember 28, 2016Original lobster roll is filling. Burger was tasty. Fun atmosphere. 25 min wait on a regular tuesday night.
Best (and cheapest) lobster is the city. They're served clean and perfectly steamed.
960 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Burger & Lobster - Flatiron is a British-born restaurant located at 39 W 19th St in New York. Our menu offers a wide range of burgers, oysters, whole lobster or lobster rolls with chips and salad for set price in a big space with a happy hour. We also have a selection of cocktails available.
Permanently closed (Show more)
- Mon–Sun
- Noon–10:00 PM
(646) 833-7532
Features
Reservations
No
Credit Cards
Yes
Outdoor Seating
No
Wheelchair Accessible
Yes
Music
No
Parking
Street
Restroom
Yes
Food & Drink
Drinks
Beer, Full Bar, Cocktails
See More
You might also like
Places people like to go after Burger & Lobster
Appears on 1,144 lists
Ultimate Summertime Lobster Rolls
Created by Foursquare Swarm
89 items • 248 followers
NYC's Most Mouthwatering Burgers
Created by Foursquare Swarm
20 items • 407 followers
Where You and Your Crew Can Dine On the Cheap
Created by Foursquare Insiders
12 items • 261 followers