Burger & Lobster
(Now Closed)Burger Joint and Seafood Restaurant$$$$
Flatiron District, New York
269 Tips and reviews
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Kev SkinnyJanuary 10, 2015Very happy with this place. 20.00 per meal is a home run. Burger was very good...but..I must say. Lobster roll is the way to go. Potentially more lobster in it than u will get ordering the lobster.
TomApril 2, 2015Simple menu. 3 items, $20 each. Can't go wrong here, but I prefer the lobster roll and burger. Cheese and bacon is a free add on for the burger. The space is huge & service is friendly.
Caroline SchulweisMay 9, 2015Pro tip: Rather than getting the $60 special for two that includes 2 burgers half a lobster, order 2 lobsters and split a burger! Just won't come with dessert. Loved both dishes!- Djaniella D.February 1, 2016Nice, spacious restaurant! I'd recommend bringing a friend/partner & going splitsies with the burger, lobster, & lobster roll. Each comes with fries & a small salad - you'll leave full & satisfied!
Jason AndersonDecember 6, 2015Very good food. If you want to sample both get the Burger & Half Lobster combo. Give you a chance to eat both. But will be difficult to finish it. Very filling! I'll definitely be returning here!
Paige CAugust 3, 2018My family and I had a really great experience here. First of all, the lobster was perfectly cooked. I recommend the 2 pounder. Everyone said their burgers were delicious too. A very fun place!
Tim LeeJuly 3, 2017Delicious. Excellent for groups - including kids! Get the burger & lobster combo. Cheese and bacon on the burger, garlic in your butter. Stay away from the burger and lobster roll appetizers.
Danielle SangJune 7, 2015I went to the one in London and loved the burger. I tried the steamed Lobster and it was delicious! Great value for the price. Lobster rolls aren't my thing but they are very good here.
The best damn value in the city. $20 gets me a grilled or steamed lobster (get grilled) w/ lemon butter, fries, and a salad. If you are with peeps, 100% get a table burger to share (they cut it too!)
Percy HolmesJanuary 15, 2017My experience and dinner at Burger and Lobster was superb. I ordered the "Beast" which I highly recommend. To say that I recommend this place would be an understatement. Go now and enjoy!
- Eric ODecember 30, 2015This place has an amazing grand feeling when you walk in; huge tanks, long bar, lots of space and walk room. Be prepared to make a tough decision; do you want a burger or lobster. Or both 😸
Bin YangMay 19, 2015Can you believe that the Brits came up with this concert? The $20 lobster roll is fresh and largely satisfying, gives Luke's a run for their money that's for sure. Craft beers too? Sign me up!
Elizabeth BursteinDecember 18, 2017Delicious - got the one pound lobster with lemon butter cream, fries, and the burger bites for appetizers. Party bowl drink was delicious too
Najla AlNovember 10, 2016If you love lobster roll, then you're in the right place. I really loved it. Very recommended.
Michael Fox-RabinovitzOctober 10, 2015Loved the place, lobster was large, well done and the lemon garlic sauce is very good. The cheesecake mousse is excellent, highly recommend. Just beware it comes with nuts on top.
Sabrina MerchantFebruary 19, 2016This place is like a factory, but its amazing! Everything we had was great. Be sure to share so you can have a bit of lobster and burger!
Yasmina MikouJune 19, 2015You cannot go wrong. Good food, good price. I ll recommand the lobster roll it is delicious and way easier to eat than the whole lobster! If still hungry try the cheesecake mousse, yummy 😋
Heather HApril 10, 20163 choices lobster, burger, lobster roll. All come with salad and fries, which are awesome! Great deal. Good for groups. Not good for vegetarians.
Tara DograAugust 20, 2017Very good value for money. A whole burger and lobster for $33 is ridiculously cheap. Excellent service from the staff. Highly recommended.
Elaine HuiOctober 14, 2016I had the 7 Samurai lobster roll which was ok. I think next time I'll go for The Classic. I was worried about leaving hungry, but the portion size was perfect!
KEMarch 2, 2017menu now has a few lobster, burger & lobster roll options including combos for the indecisive! giant space, good for groups, excellent service. bibs & lobster tools provided :) +chocolate mousse!
Nak BratMarch 29, 2015Burger California style, with bacon. Perfection in lettuce. Enjoyed with a Moscow mule and a 6 point draft after. Great place.. Will be back.
DevontaOctober 1, 2015Lobster Roll (Excellent), Salad (Amazing), Fries (OK). They only serve 3 things: burgers, lobster rolls and whole lobsters. 20 dollars
Julie MorseMay 12, 2016There's only 3 options: beef burger, lobster and lobster sandwich. All for $20. Absolutely amazing! 100% recommended. You might have to wait 20min for a table, but it's worth it
Everything is the same price, and if you get the burger you're being ripped off. I've yet to have their lobster roll but the lobster was great! Special lemon butter is the best.
I've only tried the lobster platter and the lobster roll, and the roll wins, hands down. Perfect buttery roll, not too much sauce, big chunks of lobster - it's perfection.
Justin VinluanNovember 18, 2015I wanted to have all three mains, but today it was lobster roll. It was gud. The bread was perfectly buttered & grilled. I added the lemon garlic butter and used it like I used to use ranch dressing.
Ember BakerNovember 19, 2018Got the original burger and the original lobster roll and it split them both in half for two people. Perfect amount of food.
- Can't decide? Can't go wrong with the lobster roll. Would also recommend pairing up and getting one of each. It's not too much food.
Error404 Hack2learnAugust 5, 2015Just amazing! Never seen a lobster this size! Just insane and a little bit scary. Well get the burger and grilled lobster 😊
Krystal GarnerMarch 22, 2015The lobster roll is to die for!! The flatiron is also a great dinner cocktail. The waitstaff is very entertaining! 730-830 is a the busy time so avoid lol.
ShahadSeptember 12, 2017They only have lobster and burger and both are good, lobster rolls with bread is very good and lobster bites are ok and light. Little bit pricy though ..
Eric HoJune 4, 2017Get the burger and lobster combo. Very good. Follow my food journey on Instagram @EricHoRaw
SaeedApril 26, 2018small lobster rolls but soooo fresh and tasty 😋👌🏻👍🏻, go for original lobster roll which comes with fries and salad
Mark O'NeillJanuary 8, 2015Whole lobster for $20 in Manhattan seems like a steal. The steamed then grilled option is solid. Also, draft cocktail situation is solid. Catch this place while you can.
David ZhangJanuary 7, 2017Get the lobster or the lobster roll. The burger is solid too but you can do better elsewhere for $20
- Lily FOctober 28, 2015It's a lot of food for price but it's worth it! Service was so wonderful and the burger is delicious and cooked perfectly. Fries were on point too.
Raphael LangenscheidtOctober 10, 2015Good burger and great lobster. It boggles my mind that you can't have both though. Still, $20 per meal is almost cheap enough to just other each individually. Vibe was a bit like a chain restaurant.
CrystalDecember 28, 2018The food and service were impeccable. Our server, Alton helped ensure that our entire party, children and adults had a wonderful experience.
Fanyi PanJuly 21, 2016I ve always been loving burger and lobster in London . Though I think here might be not as good but still saves my crave for lobster tool and grill lobster !!
You won't be disappointed with anything that they serve. Even the Sides of friends and Salad are delicious!
Linda ChowMarch 25, 2016Choose from grilled or steamed lobster, lobster roll, or burger. All $20 with fries and salad. Grilled lobster and lobster roll were lovely!
Erica GayleApril 23, 2015Everything is great. The waiters are all awesome! Loved Zach and Ben! The Flatiron beverage is super tasty!! Nom
Caroline MunichApril 29, 2019Lobster Lobster Lobster Lobster Lobster Lobster Lobster Lobster Lobster Lobster Lobster Lobster
Nandi AndersonSeptember 22, 2015Burger, Lobster, or Lobster Roll. And a salad and fries. The food comes out QUICK! And it's delicious!
emily chenApril 10, 2015the lobster roll is new englander approved! much better than luke's (and all those lil nyc joints) and portions much more generous. comes with perfect fries and salad!
RyanMarch 1, 2015Just as good as the London locations. Be sure to ask for the garlic butter sauce for your fries.
Tyler BoudreauxJanuary 29, 2016Very clean, if party of 4 sit in comfy hightop seats near bar. Get grilled lobster. Phenomenal flavor.
Rachel IvyApril 2, 2015This place was pretty great, nice and big too. Burgers are juicy and the lobster rolls aren't too mayo-y.
961 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Burger & Lobster - Flatiron is a British-born restaurant located at 39 W 19th St in New York. Our menu offers a wide range of burgers, oysters, whole lobster or lobster rolls with chips and salad for set price in a big space with a happy hour. We also have a selection of cocktails available.
Permanently closed (Show more)
- Mon–Sun
- Noon–10:00 PM
(646) 833-7532
Features
Reservations
No
Credit Cards
Yes
Outdoor Seating
No
Wheelchair Accessible
Yes
Music
No
Parking
Street
Restroom
Yes
Food & Drink
Drinks
Beer, Full Bar, Cocktails
See More
You might also like
Places people like to go after Burger & Lobster
- 8.9
"Huge donuts that are soft and oh so delicious. My favorites are lemon poppy seed and cafe au lait"
Michele - 9.2
"Try the Oyster Mushrooms, Pancetta, Poached Egg - Perfect Friday night with D!"
Julie Zucker - 8.9
"Love the brown rice medley, all natural BBQ sauce, red lentils, friendly staff & layout of store."
Demetria Harvin
Appears on 1,144 lists
Best Burgers in New Jersey, New York & Beyond
Created by Ben Chapman
28 items • 235 followers
Ultimate Summertime Lobster Rolls
Created by Foursquare Swarm
89 items • 248 followers
NYC's Most Mouthwatering Burgers
Created by Foursquare Swarm
20 items • 407 followers