Blue Heaven
Breakfast Spot and Caribbean Restaurant$$$$
Key West
"Start with Lobster Benedict finish with key lime pie!!"(33 Tips)
"Key lime pie was one of the best I've ever had."(78 Tips)
"Lobster grilled cheese sandwich was divine. 2 words - Banana Heaven."(10 Tips)
"BLT Benedict was amazing as was the lobster omlete."(9 Tips)
404 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- key lime pie
- breakfast food
- brunch food
- pancakes
- blt benedict
- (15 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Jeremy CruzJuly 8, 2016$10 for a slice of key lime pie! But it was one tasty slice. Didn't like the price, but I recommend the pie.
ChristinaAugust 10, 2013The lobster eggs Benedict is a must try. Ask for Greg! He is the greatest, happiest server ever.
AmyApril 2, 2013Had some yummy Lobster tail, the beans are amazing. Took my kids they treated them like rockstars!
Monica VAugust 26, 2016Market price - ask first. Unless money is no object, it will be a pricey meal so be prepared. But really good food! Bloody Marys underwhelmed though.
Nikki SchulzAugust 29, 2014See Jen at the bar!! Great screwdriver-maker! And the live music is awesome!
Michael RowbothamJune 25, 2011They dont start lunch til 1:30. Our fish, jerk chix, and cheese sandwiches were very good. Great live music. A fantastic place for lunch!
Joe MartinezOctober 20, 2012The blueberries in the pancakes are grape sized and so juicy they squirt, so wear a bib when you eat them.
HeresJay KesslingerFebruary 21, 2011The food is good, but the prices have gotten too high over the last few years. Go for the atmosphere and the key lime pie -- probably *THE BEST* on the island!
Alex TomasikNovember 25, 2014Great setting. Tons of roosters hens and chicks wandering around. Ping pong. Banyan tree. Bar.
KirstieAugust 25, 2011Great Bloody Mary. Best key lime pie I've had and Banana Heaven is absolute perfection. So so so good.
Foodie MagoozleApril 11, 2012Shrimp&Grits and Lobster Benedict!!! Amazing! Oh, and delicious mimosas. Can't wait to go back.
Stephan PertschyJanuary 8, 2014Breakfast is awsome: take the special Key Lime Pie and try the Cappucino
Kat NewboldNovember 3, 2012Had a wonderful meal here!! The yellowtail snapper was amazing!! Great monitors also!!!'
Pam FleischerJanuary 24, 2013Fresh grouper, green beans, corn bread, live music at atmosphere worth however long it takes.
Mattias WacDecember 22, 2017Not really worth overall praise echoed in most comments unfortunately. Different dishes served with exactly the same ingredients...Nah, something had happened here - to list as no1 in Seafood; a joke
Michelle RJune 5, 2017RUDE. Went here alone for brunch. They asked me to sit at the bar so they could keep tables open for parties of 2. Seriously?!?! Unbelievable. I'm banished to the bar for being single? F this place.
You cannot visit KW without a stop here. Breakfast and crowd is great.
RoxannDecember 31, 2013Awesome outdoor patio bar and dining area. Saucy Jen is an awesome bartender!!!
Brendan LewisMay 20, 2014Everyone should have the Lobster Eggs Benedict at least once in their life.
HeatherJuly 29, 2012Snapper was to die for!!!! Michele was amazing :) love this place and def coming back! Wow.
JenSeptember 15, 2011My favorite place to eat on the island. Food, service and ambiance are always great! Closed during September :(
Armando VillarrealJune 6, 2011Put your name on the list, see the gift shop, play some ping pong, grab a drink. Enjoy the evening. Sundays are quiet.
iKangarooJanuary 4, 2011Fun atmosphere. We had the shrimp & lobster melts which were both very good and significantly different. I preferred the shrimp but not by much.
TV Food MapsAugust 26, 2014Check out Blue Heaven as seen on Food Wars , Man vs Food Nation , Rachael Ray - $40 a Day Read more
Stacie HApril 10, 2011Lobster benedict with bacon and tomato amazing! Banana bread great! Slightly forgetful server....but it is key west
Thomas NeubergerJanuary 13, 2012Such a great vibe. Came for lunch, came back for dinner. The rum drinks are great.
Sharon ElderSeptember 18, 2011One of my favorite places for breakfast when in Key West! The banana bread is fantastic!
Emily LJanuary 5, 2017Expect a wait. Went at 7:30pm on a Tuesday and there was an hour and 15 minutes wait. Returned at 9:15 and the wait was only 15 minutes.
1,791 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Blue Heaven is a real Key West favorite serving breakfast, lunch, and fine dining in the evenings, known for Caribbean flavors, live music, and funky setting.
Open until 10:30 PM (Show more)
- Mon–Sun
- 8:00 AM–10:30 PM
(305) 296-8666
Features
Reservations
Yes
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. Discover & Visa)
Wi-Fi
No
Outdoor Seating
Yes
Food & Drink
Menus
Breakfast, Brunch, Lunch, Dinner, Dessert
Drinks
Beer, Wine, Full Bar, Cocktails
See More
You might also like
Places people like to go after Blue Heaven
- 9.1
"So much information about Ernest Hemingway and His families all in one place. Beautiful home that is very well preserved. Also a wedding venue."
Debbie W - 8.4
"Get here early in the morning! Although, the line went relatively quick!"
Molly Smith - 8.6
"Great low-key vibe, nice bartenders, rum punch, popcorn!"
Kara G.
Upcoming Events
- Rockstead
10:00 AM on April 24, 2025
Powered by
Appears on 770 lists
Created by Foursquare Swarm
50 items • 221 followers
America's 50 Best Eggs Benedict Dishes
Created by Foursquare Swarm
50 items • 161 followers
Best Places to Check out in United States Pt 6
Created by Wanna See It All
199 items • 200 followers