Important Notice:We have made the tough decision to say goodbye to the Foursquare City Guide mobile app, effective December 15, 2024, with the web version to follow in early 2025. Visit our FAQ for more information or to download our Swarm app.Blue Heaven
Breakfast Spot and Caribbean Restaurant$$$$
Key West
"Start with Lobster Benedict finish with key lime pie!!"(33 Tips)
"Best key lime pie I've had and Banana Heaven is absolute perfection."(78 Tips)
"Lobster grilled cheese sandwich was divine. 2 words - Banana Heaven."(10 Tips)
"BLT Benedict was amazing as was the lobster omlete."(9 Tips)
404 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- key lime pie
- breakfast food
- brunch food
- pancakes
- blt benedict
- (15 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Heather FranceNovember 8, 2018Fabulous yellow fin and the pasta is amazing!! Must have their version of banana foster!
Travel ChannelAugust 3, 2011“Even Vanilla Ice loved the Key Lime Pie at Blue Heaven.” --Adam Richman, Man v Food Nation
Alli BrinkmanSeptember 4, 2012Lobster eggs Benedict is amazing! The pancakes are great too! Get a bloody Mary while you wait for a table :)
Tina GuiomarAugust 8, 2012A must try place for breakfast/brunch. The lobster Benedict is to die for, with a key lime hollandaise sauce.
Michael ConstantineJanuary 13, 2016I thought the shrimp and grits was okay. I've had better elsewhere. What was delicious however, was the banana bread I had on the side. They also brought us blankets because we were chilly! Very sweet
ChatChowTV Giovanny GutierrezAugust 17, 2013Get the "Bacon Lobster Tomato Benedict w/ Key Lime Hollandaise.
Brooke FletcherMarch 17, 2013Best breakfast ever! Avocado omelette w sausage is amazing! Must go here if you're in Key West.
Scott DunhamApril 26, 2014Plan to wait. A true destination in KW. We lived the lobster Eggs Benedict.
Anastasia KDecember 16, 2015Scallops and shrimp are out of this world! The secret is in the sauce ;)
Dylan GorntoJuly 15, 2023The banana bread was good and the lobster omelette was amazing. Great atmosphere
Sean KilleenMarch 28, 2016Can't go wrong with the bacon/lobster Benedict (though personally I'd skip the tomato)
Meaghan PooleMarch 14, 2013The food and atmosphere are amazing--just watch out for the chickens! Also, you can't leave before trying the key lime pie!- Dee EvansNovember 2, 2019The yellow submarine was incredible. The grouper was so juicy. Would recommend
Janie LaneMay 14, 2014Lobster Eggs Benedict and drinks with Elizabeth, Bethany and my hubby Pete ! Life is good!
Chelsea EcklerMarch 4, 2011Neil is amazing. Father of my children? Knows what he is talking about when it comes to food and liquor! Lobster Benny is to die for! Wish I ate here everyday
Rebecca LeonApril 19, 2013The carrot curry soup is so friggin delicious.... or if you do breakfast the shrimp and grits are awesome.
Carl JonesMay 14, 2016The unique atmosphere, fab breakfast and having the odd Rooster walking around!
Awesome Key Lime Pie. Best in Key West. The meringue puts it over the top.
David GraciaFebruary 13, 2015Great food and fun. Be prepared to wait. Have the lobster eggs Benedict.
Excellent breakfast shrimp and grits, omelets. Nice location
Kate FurmanFebruary 8, 2016They specialize in benedicts, but their pancakes aren't bad either, especially the blueberry pancake.
ElbioApril 13, 2013Be nice to the bartender while you wait. It may get you a couple of free drinks. Or maybe that's just us! Ha!
Haley HirschMarch 15, 2016Caribbean Shrimp entree was amazing and I highly recommend saving room for dessert!
Neerav DudhwalaAugust 17, 2013Wait is long but food is worth it. Top it off great service even though they are bombarded at all times. A+
Christina BerryJune 11, 2021The food is good but not as good as the hype we read about in our research. We waited for an hour to be seated but ordering, being served, and eating took less time. Service was so-so.
- Rebecca NOTOctober 18, 2010While everyone here is amazing and friendly, ask for Cliff.....he works large parties with grace too! And the Banana Rum dessert is to die for.
MariaFebruary 13, 2023We came here for breakfast. It was good! But not a 1-2 hour wait good? Not sure we understand the hype. The shrimp and grits were good… not great. The French creperie across the street is 100x better!
Heathor Kerr BalazyFebruary 18, 2014Have a bloody goose and some of the best Key Lime pie, soo worth the wait!
Laura BakerMarch 27, 2011The yellowtail dinner was amazing. Try the scallops as an appetizer ...so good! Oh and enjoy a mojito while you wait....it's a long one!
ChristinaAugust 10, 2013The lobster eggs Benedict is a must try. Ask for Greg! He is the greatest, happiest server ever.
Regina SadykovaJanuary 14, 2016Lemon pie 👍👍👍 don't take chicken sandwich though. Choose eggs Benedict instead
1,779 Photos
Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Blue Heaven is a real Key West favorite serving breakfast, lunch, and fine dining in the evenings, known for Caribbean flavors, live music, and funky setting.
Open until 10:30 PM (Show more)
- Mon–Sun
- 8:00 AM–10:30 PM
(305) 296-8666
Features
Reservations
Yes
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. Discover & Visa)
Wi-Fi
No
Outdoor Seating
Yes
Food & Drink
Menus
Breakfast, Brunch, Lunch, Dinner, Dessert
Drinks
Beer, Wine, Full Bar, Cocktails
See More
You might also like
Appears on 770 lists
Created by Foursquare City Guide
50 items • 221 followers
America's 50 Best Eggs Benedict Dishes
Created by Foursquare City Guide
50 items • 161 followers
Best Places to Check out in United States Pt 6
Created by Wanna See It All
199 items • 200 followers