Close Icon
Gear IconImportant Reminder:The City Guide app will be sunsetting on December 15, 2024, with the web version to follow in early 2025. Please visit our FAQ to learn more or to download our Swarm app.
Learn more
Where is the Best Old Fashioned in NYC?

Where is the Best Old Fashioned in NYC?

Creator Avatar
Created by Matt Szenics • Updated On: May 9, 2013
The Vault at Pfaff's is one of Where is the Best Old Fashioned in NYC?.

1. The Vault at Pfaff's

643 Broadway (Bleecker St.), New York, NY
Cocktail Bar · Greenwich Village · 24 tips and reviews

Matt S.Matt Szenics: Snatch the two red velvet chairs in the corner. Best spot.

JIMMY is one of Where is the Best Old Fashioned in NYC?.

2. JIMMY

8.5
15 Thompson St. (at Grand St), New York, NY
Cocktail Bar · SoHo · 158 tips and reviews

Matt S.Matt Szenics: Cinnamon infused old fashioned. Now that's a winner.

Pouring Ribbons is one of Where is the Best Old Fashioned in NYC?.

3. Pouring Ribbons

225 Avenue B Fl 2 (btwn 13th & 14th St), New York, NY
Cocktail Bar · Alphabet City · 180 tips and reviews
Death & Co. is one of Where is the Best Old Fashioned in NYC?.

4. Death & Co.

8.8
433 E 6th St (btwn 1st Ave & Ave A), New York, NY
Speakeasy · East Village · 395 tips and reviews
Weather Up is one of Where is the Best Old Fashioned in NYC?.

5. Weather Up

8.9
159 Duane St (btwn Hudson St. & W Broadway), New York, NY
Cocktail Bar · Tribeca · 82 tips and reviews
The Daily is one of Where is the Best Old Fashioned in NYC?.

6. The Daily

210 Elizabeth St (btwn Prince & Spring St), New York, NY
Cocktail Bar · NoLita · 66 tips and reviews
B Flat is one of Where is the Best Old Fashioned in NYC?.

7. B Flat

277 Church St (btwn Franklin & White St), New York, NY
Cocktail Bar · Tribeca · 93 tips and reviews
Silver Lining is one of Where is the Best Old Fashioned in NYC?.

8. Silver Lining

75 Murray St (Basement), New York, NY
Cocktail Bar · Tribeca · 49 tips and reviews
Milk & Honey is one of Where is the Best Old Fashioned in NYC?.

9. Milk & Honey

30 E 23rd St, New York, NY
Speakeasy · Flatiron District · 144 tips and reviews
Mulberry Project is one of Where is the Best Old Fashioned in NYC?.

10. Mulberry Project

149 Mulberry St (btwn Grand & Hester St), New York, NY
Speakeasy · Little Italy · 225 tips and reviews
Bathtub Gin is one of Where is the Best Old Fashioned in NYC?.

11. Bathtub Gin

8.7
132 9th Ave (btwn W 18th & W 19th St), New York, NY
Speakeasy · Chelsea · 308 tips and reviews
Orient Express is one of Where is the Best Old Fashioned in NYC?.

12. Orient Express

8.2
325 W 11th St (btwn Greenwich & Washington St), New York, NY
Cocktail Bar · West Village · 71 tips and reviews
The Summit Bar & Cafe is one of Where is the Best Old Fashioned in NYC?.

13. The Summit Bar & Cafe

8.6
133 Avenue C (btwn E 8th & E 9th St), New York, NY
Cocktail Bar · Alphabet City · 204 tips and reviews
Rye House is one of Where is the Best Old Fashioned in NYC?.

14. Rye House

11 W 17th St (btwn 5th & 6th Ave), New York, NY
Whisky Bar · Union Square · 231 tips and reviews
The Raines Law Room is one of Where is the Best Old Fashioned in NYC?.

15. The Raines Law Room

9.2
48 W 17th St (btwn 5th & 6th Ave), New York, NY
Speakeasy · Union Square · 335 tips and reviews
Jbird Cocktails is one of Where is the Best Old Fashioned in NYC?.

16. Jbird Cocktails

339 E 75th St (btwn 1st & 2nd Ave.), New York, NY
Cocktail Bar · Upper East Side · 71 tips and reviews

Matt S.Matt Szenics: Get the Honey-Nut Old Fashioned before you try anything else. Then, try everything else.

Pegu Club is one of Where is the Best Old Fashioned in NYC?.

17. Pegu Club

77 W Houston St (at W Broadway), New York, NY
Cocktail Bar · Greenwich Village · 303 tips and reviews