Close Icon
Gear IconImportant Notice:We have made the tough decision to say goodbye to the Foursquare City Guide mobile app, effective December 15, 2024, with the web version to follow in early 2025. Visit our FAQ for more information or to download our Swarm app.
Learn more
Plenty

Plenty

(Now Closed)
Café$$$$
Upper East Side, New York
Save
Share
Plenty
Photos31 Photos
MenuMenu
Main 12Cakes 4Thanksgiving 3Holiday 6
Breakfast​
All Day Breakfast
7.50
Served any style served w/ toasted 7 grain bread & mixed greens
Plenty's Very Own Granola w/ Yogurt
7.00
Cheesy Egg Breakfast Sandwich
7.50
Scrambled​ eggs, vermont cheddar on a brioche roll w/ mixed greens
Pastry Basket
10.50
A sampling of plenty's freshly baked goodies
Cold Sandwiches​
Add avocado 1.50/ add cheddar cheese 1.50
Smoked Turkey
8.50
With avocado mayo, lettuce & tomato on baguette
Tuna Salad Sandwich
8.95
Dill, lettuce & tomato on baguette
Black Forest Ham & Brie
7.95
With whole grain mustard & cornichons on baguette
Turkey Meatloaf
10.50
Plenty's​ special sauce, lettuce, tomato & pickles
Grilled Chicken Breast
8.50
With tomato, watercress, & chipotle aioli on ciabatta roll
Veggie Sandwich
9.50
Avocado,​ vermont sharp cheddar, sweet potato, tomato & chipotle mayo on 7 grain bread.
Tomato & Mozzarella
8.95
Balsamic vinaigrette & baguette
Curried Chicken Salad
8.95
Raisins, cashews & mixed greens on a ciabatta roll
House Made Roast Beef
8.95
With caramelized onions, horseradish aioli on baguette
Hot Sandwich​
Hot Meatball Hero
11.50
Your choice of beef or turkey meatballs w/ house made tomato sauce & melted mozzarella cheese on a warm hero
Hot Eggplant Parmesan
11.50
With house made tomato sauce & melted mozzarella cheese on a warm hero
Salads​
House Salad
8.00
Mixed greens, tomato, cucumber w/ vinaigrette
Chopped Chicken Salad
10.50
Grilled chicken breast, cucumber, feta, tomatoes, chick peas, croutons, w/ balsamic vinaigrette
Caesar Salad
9.50
Romaine lettuce, house made croutons, parmesan cheese, w/ caesar dressing
Greek Salad
9.50
Feta cheese, cucumber, tomato, red onion, black olives w/ red wine vinaigrette
Grilled Chicken Salad
10.50
Grilled chicken breast, mixed greens, tomato, cucumber, w/ vinaigrette
Chinese Chicken Salad
10.50
Grilled chicken breast w/ wonton crisps, snap peas, w/ miso sesame dressing
Chicken Caesar Salad
10.50
Grilled chicken breast, romaine lettuce, house made croutons, parmesan cheese, w/ caesar dressing
Hot From Our Kitchen for Lunch and Dinner​
Warm Meatball Plate
13.50
Your choice of beef, turkey, or veggie meatballs served w/ mixed greens & toasted country bread
Lasagna
A choice of bolognese, veggie or low Carb serve w/ mix greens
Eggplant Parmesan Plate
13.50
Served w/ mixed green
Soup of the Day
5.75
Ask about today's daily special
Drinks​
Hot
Add additional shot 1.00
Iced
Coffee
1.90 - 2.25
Cappuccino
3.50 - 4.50
Macchiato
2.00 - 3.00
Hot Chocolate
3.50 - 4.00
Iced Coffee
2.35 - 2.85
Tall Glass of Milk
1.75
House Made Iced Tea
2.50 - 3.50
Half & Half
3.25 - 4.00
Latte
3.50 - 4.50
Cafe Au Lait
2.25 - 2.60
Espresso
1.75 - 2.75
Hot Tea
1.50 - 2.25
Iced Cappuccino
3.75 - 4.75
Iced Latte
4.00 - 4.75
Soy Milk
2.50
House Made Lemonade
3.25 - 4.00
Fresh Squeezed Juice
3.50
Bakery​
Our selection will change often depending on the season & the kitchen. Please check the cases to see today's selections & prices.
Specialty cakes & birthday cakes are made to order.
Vanilla
Red Velvet
Banana
Boston Cream Pie
Cheesecake
Chocolate
Carrot
Coconut
Tiramisu Cake
Classic Cakes​
All of our cakes are four layer cakes. An inscription on your cake is always free. A variety of decorations are available. Price is dependent upon design.
Golden Vanilla Cake w/ Vanilla Buttercream Frosting
Golden vanilla creme cake w/ vanilla buttercream filling & frosting
Fudgy Chocolate Cake w/ Chocolate Buttercream Frosting
Rich chocolate cake w/ fudgy chocolate buttercream frosting
Carrot Cake
Moist carrot cake w/ walnuts & whipped cream cheese frosting
Red Velvet
Moist & light red velvet cake w/ whipped cream cheese frosting
Peanut Butter Cake
Peanut butter cake w/ buttercream peanut butter filling & dark chocolate frosting
Chocolate & Raspberry
Rich chocolate cake w/ raspberry filling & dark chocolate ganache frosting
Chocolate Cake w/ Salted Caramel
Chocolate cake w/ salted caramel filling & dark chocolate ganache frosting
Strawberry Shortcake
Golden vanilla cake w/ fresh strawberries & real whipped cream (an additional fee applies)
Cheesecake
60.00
Light & creamy cheesecake w/ a homemade graham cracker crust topped w/ fresh strawberries & strawberry coulis 10-12 serves
Golden Vanilla Cake w/ Chocolate Buttercream Frosting
Golden vanilla creme cake w/ chocolate buttercream filling & frosting
Fudgy Chocolate Cake w/ Vanilla Buttercream Frosting
Rich chocolate cake w/ vanilla buttercream filling & vanilla buttercream frosting
Coconut Cake
Vanilla​ creme cake w/ coconut buttercream filling & coconut frosting (also available w/ lemon curd filling)
Luscious Lemon Cake
Tart & sweet lemon cake w/ lemon curd filling & lemon buttercream frosting
Devil's Food Chocolate & Caramel
Moist chocolate cake w/ caramel buttercream frosting
Banana Cake
With whipped nutella frosting
German Chocolate Cake
Moist chocolate cake w/ coconut pecan filling & topping
Flour Less Chocolate Cake
55.00
Gluten​ free - rich & chocolatey 10 serves
Create Your Own Cake​
Create Your Own Cake
Fondant Cakes​
These cakes can be any flavor you would like.
Custom Fondant Cakes
250.00 - 350.00
Priced according to design.
Fondant Cakes
55.00 - 105.00
With simple designs polka dots, stars, flowers
Cake Sizes and Pricing​
Price includes basic inscription
8" Round
48.00
Serves 8-10
12" Round or 10" Square
140.00
Serves 25-35
Half Sheet
175.00
Serves 40-60
6" Round
36.00
Serves 6
10" Round
78.00
Serves 15-25
14" Round or 12" Square
155.00
Serves 30-50
Full Sheet
375.00
Serves 80-120
Classic Cakes​
All of our cakes are three-layer cakes.
An inscription on your cake is always free.
A variety of decoration packages are available
Vanilla on Vanilla
Golden vanilla creme cake w/ vanilla buttercream
Chocolate on Chocolate
Rich chocolate cake w/ fudgy chocolate frosting
Coconut
Vanilla creme cake w/ coconut buttercream & coconut frosting
Peanut Butter
Peanut butter cake w/ peanut butter buttercream, & chocolate frosting
German Chocolate
Chocolate cake w/ coconut-pecan filling raspberry - vanilla creme cake w/ raspberry buttercream & lemon curd filling
Salted Caramel
Chocolate​ cake w/ salted caramel & dark chocolate ganache
Chocolate on Vanilla
Golden​ vanilla creme cake w/ whipped chocolate fudge
Carrot Cake
Carrot cake w/ walnuts & cream cheese frosting
Red Velvet
Red​ velvet cake w/ cream cheese frosting
Devil's Food Chocolate & Caramel
Devil's food chocolate cake w/ light caramel buttercream frosting
Banana Cake
Banana cake w/ whipped nutella frosting
Strawberry Shortcake
Golden vanilla cake w/ fresh strawberries & whipped cream.
Fondant Cakes​
These cakes can be any flavor you would like (except strawberry shortcake)
Simple Designs
Tiered Cakes
Fondant Cakes
Custom Fondant Cakes
Anything other than our simple design
Create Your Own Cake​
Create Your Own Cake
The morning of tor the guests who arrive early...
Old Fashioned Crumb Cake
37.00
Serves​ 10
Cornmeal Cake
42.00
Blueberry, cranberry orange, strawberry, lemon. Serves 10.
Cinnamon Sugar Donut Muffins
1.75 each
Loaf Cakes
30.00
Banana bread, pound cake, lemon cake. Serves 10.
Pecan Streusel Coffee Cake
42.00
Serves 10-12
Muffins
2.50
Desserts​
Minimum 6 per flavor
Apple Pie
34.00
Serves 8
Pumpkin Pie
24.00
Serves 8
Chocolate Cream Pie
32.00
Serves 8
Cheesecake
45.00
With​ graham cracker crust serves 12
Golden Vanilla Cake
40.00
With fudgy frosting. Serves 12-15
Moist Red Velvet Cake
43.00
With whipped cream cheese frosting serves 12-15
Mini Cookies
18 per dozen
Our delicious cookies made smaller chocolate chip, oatmeal raisin, peanut butter, kitchen sink
Homemade Rugelach
18 per dozen
Apricot, raspberry, cinnamon sugar, or nutella (or a combination of all)
Cupcakes
3.00
Chocolate, vanilla, red velvet, pumpkin, & carrot
Pecan Pie
30.00
Serves​ 8
Berry Pie
35.00
Serves 8
Banana Cream Pie
32.00
Serves 8
Double Chocolate Layer Cake
40.00
Serves 12-15
Classic Carrot Cake
43.00
With whipped cream cheese frosting serves 12-15
Corn Bread
22.00
Serves 10
Homemade Oreos
24 per dozen
With whipped vanilla filling or peanut butter filling
Powdered Sugar Pecan Balls
10.20 per dozen
For the Morning​
Scones
2.50
Cranberry & white chocolate, apricot & ginger, blueberry, pear & walnut
Loaves
32.00
Banana walnut, zucchini, lemon pound, pumpkin spice
Crumb Cake
37.00
With cinnamon & brown sugar crumb topping
Corn Bread
22.00
Serve 10
Muffins
2.50
Blueberry,​ corn, mixed berry, pumpkin spice, banana chocolate chip, chocolate chip, cinnamon sugar donut
Coffee Cake
42.00
With pecan streusel topping
Cornmeal Cake
42.00
Moist​ cornmeal cake w/ blueberry, cranberry orange or strawberry
Pies​
Serve 8
Pecan Pie
30.00
Maple Walnut Pie
38.00
Chocolate Cream Pie
32.00
Key Lime Pie
32.00
Apple Pie
35.00
Chocolate Pecan Pie
32.00
Pumpkin Pie
25.00
Banana Cream Pie
32.00
Cakes​
Serve 12-15
Coconut Snowflake Layer Cake
42.00
Cheesecake w/ Graham Cracker Crust
45.00
Golden Vanilla Cake
40.00
With fudgy frosting
Moist Red Velvet Cake
43.00
With whipped cream cheese frosting
Pumpkin Spice Cake
42.00
With maple cream cheese frosting
German Chocolate Cake
43.00
Dark chocolate cake layers w/ a gooey filling of caramel, pecans & coconut.
Double Chocolate Layer Cake
40.00
Classic Carrot Cake
43.00
With​ whipped cream cheese frosting
Hannukah Donuts​
Sugar Donuts
21 per dozen
Jelly Donuts
24 per dozen
Cinnamon Sugar Donuts
21 per dozen
Cookies​
Assorted Mini Cookie & Brownie Platter
28.00 - 50.00
Chocolate chip, peanut butter, oatmeal raisin, chocolate brownies, butterscotch brownies w/ walnuts
Peanut Brittle
9.00
Homemade Oreos
24 per dozen
Plenty's Own Spiced Nuts
9.00

Problem with this menu?
Compass icon
Plenty
1457 3rd Ave (btwn 82nd & 83rd St.)
New York, NY 10028
United States
Get directions
Phone icon
(212) 628-2110
World Wide Web icon
Twitter icon
@plentycafenyc
Features
Reservations
No
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. Discover & Visa)
Outdoor Seating
No
Food & Drink
Menus
Brunch, Lunch
See More

You might also like

Places people like to go after Plenty

Appears on 47 lists

See all
United States » New York » New York » Upper East Side

Is this your business? Claim it now.

Make sure your information is up to date. Plus use our free tools to find new customers.