27 Tips and reviews
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Get the banana bread, zucchini bread, cinnamon roll or crumb cake. Skip the croissants (go to Francois Payard or Maison Keyser nearby for those). Service is slow at Plenty, but it's usually worth it.
Juliet ObodoOctober 8, 2012They serve breakfast all day! The pastries are superb. I recommend the cheesy egg sandwich sub it for a biscuit and add ham. Thank me later!
JennAugust 26, 2012Serves breakfast all day, and the pastries look delicious (the egg/cheese breakfast sandwich was solid). I will note the atmosphere is a little sparse for a full on work/study hangout.
Cute new cafe/bakery with delicious sandwiches and pastries, all made in house. Dinner options too (meatballs!). And don't miss their signature "kitchen sink" cookies!
Mel DogOctober 9, 2011Fantastic new addition to the neighborhood. Amazing Illy coffee drinks with delicious desserts, pastries, and sandwiches. Get the meatball hero.
Jan SichermannJune 30, 2012Sit by the window, eat one of their fantastic sandwiches, and watch the world go by!
Nathan ChurchSeptember 8, 2014Excellent made-from-scratch food, Illy Espresso, friendly staff and management.
Beka CMarch 9, 2013Best homemade muffins (zucchini muffin to die for) and cakes I've had in the city !
Maria DaddioFebruary 19, 2012Delish!!! I want to taste everything. Fresh and tempting homemade baked goods. Coffee and tea.
- Kerry CheeseboroOctober 19, 2011Great cookies/pastries, excellent coffee, and can't wait to try their sandwiches and meatballs!
Must try their Giant Oreo cookie and the Chubby Chocolate chip.
Don't get a latte or cappuccino. They re-steam their milk! Ew. Bacteria city.
Have been eating here a few times a week since summer. Their red velvet cake was to die for and lately became very bland and bad. Disappointed :/
31 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
(212) 628-2110
Features
Reservations
No
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. Discover & Visa)
Outdoor Seating
No
Food & Drink
Menus
Brunch, Lunch
See More
You might also like
- 9.2
"If you’re looking to start your day decadently, order the Lumberjack: a bacon, egg, and cheese on a maple cruller donut. So good. So rich."
Kaitlin - 9.1
"Best coffee with sandwiches just wow..."
Hanna Evans
- 8.9
"Cash only! Super cozy space with tasty food at affordable prices. Coffee is delicious!!"
LaDawn Penigar-Mitchell
Places people like to go after Plenty
- 9.5
"You have to reserve at least a couple of whole day for met, it is unbelievably large and each piece is amazing!"
Ayşe Nur Ayyıldız - 7.4
"Love this Eli's ,stop at least twice a week on way home-superb selection of well,everything -love the cheeses. Often go to 91st as well (closer to home)"
Nikki Beauchamp - 9.7
"Great park to walk and bike. Enjoyable. Always something going on. Kayak, merry go round, zoo, concerts, playground"
Angi W
Appears on 47 lists
Created by Matt Borst
90 items • 34 followersCreated by Lindsey M
200 items • 150 followers
Created by Annika K. Martin
23 items • 24 followers