Mayahuel
(Now Closed)Cocktail Bar, Mexican Restaurant, and Lounge$$$$
East Village, New York
Has a stamp of approval from Village Voice and Men's Health Mag
260 Tips and reviews
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
manyaJuly 2, 2010The chilaquiles, tamales and tuna ceviche at Mayahuel are quite tasty. They also have a wonderfully delicious cocktail menu. Definitely worth a stop either for dinner, cocktails or both.
Justin BJuly 28, 2013Great selection of tequilas and mezcals. These people know their stuff. Try the Fortaleza Reposado... Such a beautiful tequila.
Victoria U.February 26, 2015Great selection of tequila. Cozy and romantic- great for dates and date night or groups.
Come for the cocktails, stay for the chilaquiles. They're a traditional Mexican hangover dish, often served at weddings if the party is still going at sunrise. Get them and preempt your hangover.
Astrid BarrerasMarch 22, 2014Great selection of cocktails! Be sure to order the Palomitas for the table- Spicy deliciousness!
Julian SDecember 5, 2014Probably better to grab a table, you won't get the full bar experience sitting at the bar. Pretty authentic tasting food.
Huge selection of tequilas and I suggest the Change Agent if you're not a huge mezcal fan. This place brings back tequila's good name.
Kathleen CorlessSeptember 14, 2015Awesome cocktails, anything with mezcal rocks, ask to sit upstairs for more atmosphere- the best array of mezcal-based cocktails in New York. over fifty to choose from!
Jarret WeinrichAugust 11, 2012Never thought I could do a whole night of tequila and not vomit. Way to go Mayahuel! Great cocktails and food. Try the croquetas.
Ilona LalovaAugust 29, 2015Excellent excellent cocktails! Try everything from Some Like it Hot section.
Best tequila drinks in the East Village. Order one or two and nurse them for hours. Pass on the food, though -- I've been disappointed more than once.
Micah MoreauFebruary 18, 2017Nicole is the bomb. Churros are tasty AF. Quality Anejo's are reasonably priced.
Pueblo Viejo TequilaDecember 21, 2016Reflect your inner self in a cocktail mixed with Pueblo Viejo. Ask the bartender of Mayahuel to make a Tequila Sunrise for you.
KMarch 16, 2015Cute Mexican tiles/decor. If you like tequila/mescal, plenty of drinks to choose from. Cozy/not too loud.
Adrianne BenzionApril 27, 2013Amazing tequila cocktails. Try the one with elderflower ladies! Pretty and tasty!
M RNovember 18, 2010Slight detour if you like spicy, blackberry cobbler if you're looking for sweet. Pork belly and ribs are good choices, ribs are pretty spicy! Recommend the flights
The Daily MealJune 17, 2011Mayahuel offers an extensive list of tequilas, mezcals, and cocktails like The Pale Rider made with fino Sherry, jalapeño tequila, sugarcane, and lime. Read more
Even if you don't like tequila, you'll love the cocktails here. My personal favorite: FB cup - refreshing, not too sweet, and a bit of a kick.
Roy MillerAugust 11, 2014Ron's Dodge Charger excellent smoky/spicy drink with a subtle pineapple sweetness and salt on the rim.
If you like spicy, go off menu for the "Any Color You Like"
Ian SullivanMarch 5, 2013The "Hit and Miss" cocktail is actually a full on hit - one of the best I've ever had.
Amelie POctober 26, 2014I had the HIt or Miss coctel with jalapeno infused tequila and it was really good.
Jeremy Scott FosterDecember 14, 2014From the same creators of Death & Co. The tequila and mezcal drinks are amazing.
This place is a hidden gem if you are into tequila & mezcal based cocktails.
Perhaps some of the finest cocktails crafted in NYC. The fish tacos aren't too shabby either.
KatieMarch 26, 2012unbelievable drink menu and delicious chicken mole tamales. everything was delicious. the staff is not very friendly, though.
Veena RAugust 30, 2011Tiny well kept secret place. Love the cocktails and deco. Great date spot. Friend owns the building upstairs.
Meg FarmerOctober 25, 2016Total date spot. Cute, cozy, but make sure your date is into tequila or it's a waste. 🍸
Rob PrattDecember 8, 2016Cocktails are good, esp for Mezcal lovers, but the upstairs seating is uncomfortable. If you can't sit at the bar, better to head elsewhere.
Luke MeyerNovember 26, 2011Everything here is phenomenal. Favorite spicy drink is the Hit or Miss. Favorite no-spice drink is the Old Man Miller Swizzle.
Shanon LevenherzOctober 31, 2011Amazing tequila cocktails! If you're a fan of said beverage, I highly recommend stopping by.
- The Oaxaca Old-Fashioned is a modern classic and rightly so. Reposado tequila, mezcal, agave nectar, and Angostura bitters.
- Anna ChauMarch 19, 2012La Vida Rose. Also try the house-made jalapeno-infused tequila. Maybe not a whole shot at first... it's pretty damn good, people.
Village VoiceOctober 25, 2012Critics' Pick winner of The Village Voice Best of NYC 2012 Best Tequila Splurge!
Hillary LindemanNovember 27, 2013Awesome cocktails! Anything is a win on the "Some like it hot" menu.
Cindy WongMay 4, 2014Staff is friendly and willing to recommend mocktail drink versions for those who can't drink
Elizabeth O'LearyMay 1, 2011Holy moly get the chilaquiles. Unbelievable flavor and killer kick. Service is great here too. Can't wait to come back- Village VoiceAugust 31, 2010One of our 10 best Manhattan bars-It helped rescue tequila from the realm of frat boys and body shots. And for this, we pay tribute to it.
EyalNovember 9, 2011Sherry and Tequila is a combo I didn't think would work that well, bit Stone Raft and West of East India Cocktail are delicious.
301 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Permanently closed (Show more)
- Mon–Sun
- 6:00 PM–2:00 AM
(212) 253-5888
Features
Reservations
No
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. Discover & Visa)
Wi-Fi
No
Outdoor Seating
No
Food & Drink
Drinks
Beer, Wine, Full Bar, Cocktails
See More
You might also like
- 8.9
"Great DJ on Sat night. Crowded, but really fun vibe. Hidden gem"
Streeter - 8.8
"Great new addition to the neighborhood. Trendy cocktails and decent wine. Try the deviled egg appetizer"
Jeff Solomon - 9.1
"All the cocktails but especially the Tea Ceremony, Tiramisu, Caprese, and Arroz de Azzafran!"
Tayson Hoang
Places people like to go after Mayahuel
- 8.9
"Favorite stop when visiting NYC, great drink selections and atmosphere."
Eva Villarreal - 8.9
"Love this spot. Great introduction to Amaros by very knowledgeable bartenders. Get here early, as Soave is limited."
Candice DSouza - 8.2
"The smoky sweet flavor of the Mezcal Mule pairs wonderfully with near-everything that comes through the tiny hatch to Crif Dogs. Enjoy!"
Senator John Blutarski
Appears on 1,300 lists
Created by Kathryn Yu
74 items • 407 followers
Created by Daniela Cuevas
201 items • 292 followers
Created by Noah Weiss
36 items • 210 followers