1. Maysville

17 W 26th St (at Broadway), New York, NY
New American Restaurant · NoMad · 247 tips and reviews

The Tastes that Make the CityThe Tastes that Make the City: The old fashioned is the best bourbon cocktail in NYC, making our list of "The Tastes That Make the City: NYC Edition." Read more.

2. Milk Truck Grilled Cheese

11 Fulton St (at Front St), New York, NY
Food Truck · Financial District · 41 tips and reviews

The Tastes that Make the CityThe Tastes that Make the City: The three cheese grilled cheese is the best grilled cheese sandwich in NYC, making our list of "The Tastes That Make the City: NYC Edition." Read more.

3. Beecher's Handmade Cheese

900 Broadway (at E 20th St), New York, NY
Cheese Store · Flatiron District · 214 tips and reviews

The Tastes that Make the CityThe Tastes that Make the City: The "world's best" mac & cheese is the best mac & cheese in NYC, making our list of "The Tastes That Make the City: NYC Edition." Read more.

4. Gramercy Tavern

9.3
42 E 20th St (btwn Broadway & Park Ave), New York, NY
American Restaurant · Flatiron District · 446 tips and reviews

The Tastes that Make the CityThe Tastes that Make the City: The cheeseburger is the best off-menu item in NYC, making our list of "The Tastes That Make the City: NYC Edition." Read more.

5. The City Bakery

3 W 18th St (btwn 5th & 6th Ave), New York, NY
Bakery · Union Square · 657 tips and reviews

The Tastes that Make the CityThe Tastes that Make the City: The pretzel croissants are the best croissants in NYC, making our list of "The Tastes That Make the City: NYC Edition." Read more.

6. ABC Kitchen

9.2
35 E 18th St (btwn Broadway & Park Ave S), New York, NY
New American Restaurant · Flatiron District · 720 tips and reviews

The Tastes that Make the CityThe Tastes that Make the City: The crab toast is the best toast in NYC, making our list of "The Tastes That Make the City: NYC Edition." Read more.