See all
130 photos

Joey Garlic's

Pizzeria, Italian Restaurant, and American Restaurant$$$$

Newington

Save

Joey Garlic's

9.1^/10

216

ratings

130 Photos

Party Trays for Takeout 2Main Menu 12

Party Trays for Takeout

Starters

Caesar Salad

40.00

Sicilian Orange Salad

45.00

Buffalo Wings

45.00

Tossed Salad

40.00

Garlic Bread

25.00

Eggplant Fries

25.00

Large pizza box

Entrees

Pasta W/ Marinara

40.00

Sausage

23.99

Sausage and Pepper W/ Penne

50.00

Pork Cutlet Parm W/ Penne

60.00

Penne Bolognese

55.00

Chicken Cacciatore W/ Penne

55.00

Tortellini W/ Grilled Chicken

60.00

Broccoli Rabe W/ Sausage Over Penne

60.00

Meatballs

17.99

Penne Ala Vodka

45.00

Eggplant Parm W/ Penne

50.00

Chicken Parm W/ Penne

60.00

Penne Alfredo

50.00

Tortellini

45.00

Chicken Piccata W/ Penne

65.00

Baked Meat and Cheese Penne

60.00

Main Menu

Starters

Tumbleweeds

6.49

Thin slices of sweet onion, soaked in milk and tossed in seasoned flour, flash fried til tender, crisp, sweet and delicious.

Joey's Famous Eggplant Fries

8.99

Crispy, tender sticks of fried eggplant topped with mounds of grated romano cheese and a side of our own pomodoro sauce.

Joey's Calamari

9.99

Fresh calamari, fried to light perfection and served with fried pickled hot peppers and lemon wedges.

Soup of the Day

4.50

Freshly made from scratch every day.

Crispy Fried Ribs

9.99

Crispy and incredibly tender sweet and spicy ribs.

Mussels Nabladon

10.99

Sweet briny mussels, pan roasted with EVOO, garlic, basil, plum tomatoes, wine and chipotle peppers.

Quesidiche

10.99

Our version of a quesadilla. Cheddar, mozzarella, grilled chicken, bacon, spinach and roasted peppers.

Fried Mozzarella

Our housemade version of this italian american classic. Golden brown, crunchy and gooey. Served with a side of pomodoro sauce. $8.99

Meatball Sliders

8.99

Housemade meatballs topped with provolone cheese, peppers and pomodoro sauce.

Old Fashioned Garlic Bread

4.99

Italian bread topped with garlic, herbs, EVOO, butter, cheddar and mozz. Toasted until crunchy and gooey.

Joey's Wings

9.99

Choose from 3 styles, classic buffalo, Italian or sweet Asian.

Cauliflower Buffalo Wings

9.99

A vegetarian delight! feel like buffalo wings? Try these. Served with celery sticks and creamy gorgonzola dressing.

Sweet Potato Wedges

5.99

Thick planks of sweet potatoes fried to perfection. Served with our delicious bacon slather sauce.

Greens

Served with joey's warm, housemade focaccia bread. Add the following to any of the greens: grilled chicken $3.50, steak $6, shrimp $5.

Buffalo Chicken Wedge Salad

12.99

Lettuce, red onion, tomato, carrots, bacon and creamy gorgonzola topped with crunchy chicken tenders tossed in a spicy buffalo sauce.

Warm Goat Cheese Salad

11.99

A larger version of our house salad, topped with warm goat cheese, toasted pistachios and a drizzle of clover honey. Dressed with a light raspberry walnut vinaigrette.

Wedge Salad with Bacon

9.49

Crispy wedge of iceberg lettuce, red onion, tomato and crispy bacon. Topped with creamy gorgonzola dressing.

Sicilian Orange Salad

11.49

Mixed greens, sweet orange slices, kalamata olives, capers, red peppers, onions and gorgonzola tossed in EVOO and balsamic vinaigrette and served on fresh baked warm flatbread.

Albin's Carne Asada Salad

13.99

Romaine and spring mix topped with red peppers, red onions, grape tomatoes, thinly sliced steak, bacon, crunchy corn tortillas and a dollop of guacamole. Drizzled with chipotle aioli and a honey lime dressing.

Roasted Beet Salad

10.99

Deliciously sweet roasted beets, sliced and tossed with orange slices, red onion, toasted pistachios, arugula and shavings of pecorino romano.

Caesar Salad

8.99

A classic american salad. Romaine, red onion, gorgonzola chunks and crunchy croutons, topped with grated cheese.

Meatball Salad

10.99

Romaine and spring mix topped with red peppers, red onions, fennel, grape tomatoes, kalamata olives, and capers tossed in balsamic vinaigrette. Topped with 3 meatballs with marinara sauce.

Joey's House Salad

6.29

A mix of tender field greens, romaine, cucumbers, black olives, carrots, tomatoes, peppers and onions. choice of dressing. italian, ranch, balsamic basil, creamy gorgonzola, creamy italian, parmesan, peppercorn, honey mustard.

Fresh Ground Burgers

Incredibly juicy half pound burgers, ground fresh every morning. Choose from a ton of free toppings: lettuce - mayo - sauteed onions - gorgonzola dressing chipotle BBQ sauce - tomato - bacon slather sauce buffalo sauce - horseradish mayo - ranch - fried egg red onion - sauteed mushrooms - sauteed peppers.

1/2 Lb Burger with Fries

9.99

American, cheddar, mozz or provolone.

Old School Grinders

Eggplant Parm

10.99

Hand-breaded eggplant cutlets layered with sautéed peppers, topped with pomodoro sauce and plenty of mozzarella.

Chicken Parm

10.99

Hand-breaded, chicken breast topped with sautéed spinach, pomodoro sauce and mozzarella.

Italian Meatball

10.99

Hand-shaped beef and pork meatballs slow simmered in our basil marinara sauce, covered with sautéed peppers and shredded mozz.

The Ragu Combo

11.49

Locally made sausage mixed with our hand-shaped meatballs, sautéed peppers and mozzarella.

Sausage

10.99

Locally made sausage simmered in our own pomodoro sauce, loaded with sautéed peppers, and heaps of cheese.

Joey's Reuben Grinder

10.99

Our own version of a classic. Corned beef, pastrami, house made polish sauerkraut, lots of Swiss cheese, Russian dressing and mustard aioli... We toast it until it's brown and melted. Served with pickle slices.

Philly Cheese

11.49

Fourteen inch grinder roll loaded with slices of shaved ribeye, onions, peppers, mushrooms and topped with melted american cheese.

Pork Cutlet Parm

11.49

Pork cutlets piled high and topped with sauce, mozz and your choice of thick slices of roasted peppers or garlicky broccoli rabe.

Pasta

Served with your choice of penne, linguini or fettucini. All pasta dishes come with soup or a house salad. Dressings: Italian, ranch, balsamic basil, gorgonzola, creamy Italian or parmesan peppercorn.

Pasta Aglio E Olio

11.59

Extra virgin olive oil, roasted garlic, grated romano cheese, red pepper flakes and a hint of anchovy, all topped with toasted focaccia crumbs.

Fettuccini Alfredo

15.49

An old south end recipe. Cream, ricotta, butter, grated romano cheese.

Mussels Amalfi

16.99

A mountain of briny mussels, fresh chopped tomato, garlic, herbs, capers, white wine, lemon and grated cheese over your choice of pasta.

Spinach Patch Penne

16.49

Penne, tossed with grilled chicken, fresh sautéed spinach, roasted red peppers, garlic, EVOO, grated romano and topped with toasted pine nuts.

Tortellini Romano

14.99

Cheese tortellini tossed in a romano cream sauce with tomato and fire roasted peppers.

Fettucini Alla Carbonara

15.99

Bacon, sausage, prosciutto, grated cheese and egg all go into our version of this timeless classic. We make it the traditional way - without a cream sauce!

Crazy Alfredo

16.99

Cream, butter, ricotta, chicken, sausage, salami, cayenne, roasted pepper and romano cheese.

Pasta Marinara

10.99

A classic marinara. EVOO, garlic, fresh basil and plenty of grated romano cheese.

Old School Lasagna

16.99

Noodles, creamy ricotta, homemade meat sauce, shredded mozzarella and fresh herbs. Baked until it's savory and melty.

Shrimp Scampi

18.99

Linguini tossed in a briny mix of shrimp, garlic, fresh herbs, EVOO, capers, lemon, wine and chopped tomato.

Penne Ala Vodka

15.49

Our version of a classic. Tomato, heavy cream, prosciutto, red pepper flakes and vodka.

Broccoli Rabe and Sausage

15.49

Pasta with sauteed broccoli rabe and sausage tossed in EVOO, roasted garlic, grated romano cheese and red pepper flakes.

Pasta Bolognese

16.49

This famous northern italian meat sauce contains beef, pork, garlic, onions, white wine, basil and a touch of cream. It's all simmered until rich and thick. Your choice of pasta, served with a dollop of ricotta cheese.

Linguini Clam Sauce

18.99

A classic italian dish! Have it red or white.

Nonna's Old Country Dishes

Served with your choice of penne, linguini or fettucini. All nonna's dishes come with soup or a house salad. Dressings: Italian, ranch, balsamic basil, gorgonzola, creamy Italian, parmesan peppercorn, honey mustard.

Chicken Marsala

16.49

Thin chicken cutlets sautéed with shallots, prosciutto, mushrooms, marsala wine butter and parsley.

Pork Cutlet Parm

15.99

Lightly breaded tender slices of pork topped with pomodoro sauce and lots of mozzarella.

Anthony's Pork Al Capo

16.49

A humungous pork cutlet, breaded, sautéed and topped with a spicy tomato sauce of capers, sliced hot peppers, mushrooms and kalamata olives.

Chicken Piccata

16.49

Perfectly browned egg battered chicken breast, bathed in a sauce of lemon, white wine vinegar, garlic, artichokes, capers and butter, topped with herbs and served with your choice of pasta.

Eggplant Parm

15.49

Tender slices of breaded eggplant, browned and topped with pomodoro sauce and mozzarella.

Chicken Parm

16.49

Lightly breaded tender chicken breasts topped with pomodoro sauce, garlic, and mozzarella.

Chicken Cacciatore

16.49

Chunks of all white chicken breast, sweet red peppers, crimini mushrooms, garlic, basil, white wine and tomato all served over your choice of pasta.

Brick Oven Pizza Pies and Calzones

Gluten free dough is available for any of our small pizzas. Add $4. Toppings: pepperoni - sausage - sun dried tomato - pesto - spinach - onions - olives - cheddar - mushrooms - meatballs - eggplant - prosciutto - pineapple - artichokes - ricotta - hamburger - roasted red peppers - sliced or diced tomato - hot cherry peppers - broccoli - anchovies - caramelized onions - bacon - green peppers. Small - 1/2 Topping: $1; Whole Topping: $1.50. Large - 1/2 Topping: $1.50; Whole Topping: $2.50.

Mozzarella Pie

10.59

Traditional cheese pizza. Mozzarella, ground plum tomato sauce and grated romano.

Fresh Mozzarella Pie

13.99

Fresh mozz, ground plum tomato sauce, oregano, fresh basil, EVOO and grated romano.

Gluten Free Pie

14.59

Traditional cheese and red sauce pizza with gluten free dough.

Brick Oven Calzone

10.59

Stuffed with ricotta, mozzarella and your choice of fillings.

Specialty Pies

Tomato Sauce Pizza - No Mozz

8.99

Plum tomato sauce, EVOO, fresh basil and grated romano cheese.

Broccoli Rabe and Sausage

13.99

White pie with mozz, broccoli rabe, sausage, garlic, romano, EVOO and a touch of hot cherry peppers.

New England Clam Pizza

14.99

White pie with lots of garlic, oregano, basil, romano, EVOO, clams and mozz.

Mark's Masterpiece

13.99

White pie with fresh mozz, sliced tomato, bacon, EVOO and fresh basil.

Pizza Bianca

12.99

White pie, mozz, ricotta, romano, garlic, EVOO and fresh basil.

Hawaiian Pineapple Pizza

12.99

Red sauce, bacon, pineapple, roasted red peppers, romano and mozz.

Pizza a La Margherita

13.99

Hand-crushed tomatoes, fresh mozz, romano, EVOO and fresh basil.

Buffalo Chicken Pizza

13.99

Spicy buffalo sauce, chopped fresh tomatoes, roasted peppers, mozz, Romano, cheddar and chunks of chicken.

The Meat Pie

14.99

Red pie with pepperoni, sausage, bacon, meatball, mozz and romano.

The Sausage and Pepper Bronx

14.99

Fresh mozz, ground plum tomato sauce, fresh basil, oregano, EVOO, romano, sausage and roasted peppers.

Vodka Tomato Pie

13.99

Our crispy thin crust pizza with homemade vodka sauce, chicken, fresh mozzarella, diced tomatoes and topped with fresh basil.

Pizza a La Carbonara

14.99

White pie with sausage, prosciutto, bacon, caramelized onions, EVOO, topped with romano and oregano.

Clam Casino Pie

14.99

Hand-crushed tomato, chopped clams, garlic, bacon, roasted red peppers, EVOO, romano and mozz.

Spinach Patch

13.99

White pie with fresh sautéed spinach, roasted red peppers, fresh garlic, EVOO, romano, mozz and toasted pine nuts.

Javy's Favorite

14.99

White pie with hand-crushed tomatoes, sausage, romano, pesto and mozz.

Gary & Mary's Garden S

13.99

Red sauce, onions, peppers, mushrooms, spinach, eggplant, broccoli, garlic, romano cheese, EVOO and mozz.

The Kitchen Sink

14.99

Red sauce, onions, peppers, mushrooms, meatballs, pepperoni, sausage, bacon, romano, garlic and mozz.

Bbq Chicken Pizza

13.99

BBQ sauce, chicken, bacon, caramelized onions, diced tomato and romano topped with mozz and cheddar.

The Veggie Bronx

14.99

Fresh mozz, ground plum tomato sauce, fresh basil, oregano, EVOO, romano, spinach and breaded eggplant.

Hot Honey Salami Bronx

15.99

Our crispy thin crust, fresh mozzarella pie. Topped with salami, hot peppers and honey.

Milkshakes & Italian Sodas

Milkshake, Italian and old fashioned soda flavors: banana - blueberry - caramel - mint chocolate - cherry - chocolate - cinnamon - coconut - coffee - creamsicle - funny bone - hazelnut - kiwi - lemon - lime - mango - mocha - passion fruit - peach - pomegranate - raspberry - strawberry - toasted almond mocha - vanilla - mint - vanilla root beer - watermelon. Flavors only available in milkshake: oreo - peanut butter - snickers.

Old Fashioned Hand Dipped Milkshake

5.50

Rootbeer Float

4.00

Old Fashioned Soda

2.75

Club soda mixed with your choice of flavors.

Italian Soda

2.75

Club soda, cream and your choice of flavor.

Beverages

Fountain Sodas

2.79

Cola - diet cola - orange - root beer birch beer - ginger ale - 7 up. Free refills on fountain sodas.

Iced Tea and Lemonade

2.79

Iced tea (unsweetened) - pink lemonade raspberry iced tea. Free refills on iced tea and lemonade.

Hot Beverages

2.00

Coffee - tea - hot chocolate.

Fruit Juices

2.79

Apple juice - orange juice.

Kid's Menu

Kids meals include milk, fountain soda, apple or orange juice. 12 and under only, no exceptions please.

Hamburger Or Cheeseburger with Fries

5.99

Chicken Tenders with Fries

5.99

Grilled Chicken with Fries

5.99

Penne with Alfredo Cream Sauce

5.99

Giant Slice of Cheese Or Pepperoni Pizza with Fries

5.99

Pasta with Butter Or Sauce

5.99

Choose meatball or sausage.

Chicken Parm with Pasta

5.99

Fried Dough

5.99

Sides

French Fries

4.00

Sausage

4.50

Meatballs

4.50

Broccoli Rabe

5.99

Disclaimer: Always check with the business for pricing and availability of menu items. SinglePlatform is not responsible for menu or pricing changes, but the information is believed to be accurate when posted. Listing of a menu does not mean that there is any affiliation, endorsement or sponsorship between SinglePlatform and the listed business.

Problem with this menu?