Joey Garlic's
Pizzeria, Italian Restaurant, and American Restaurant$$$$
Newington
"I love the spinach patch pizza or eggplant fries!"(8 Tips)
"Great food!! Great prices!! Huge portions go starving!!!"(7 Tips)
"Best pizza in ct hands down!!"(15 Tips)
"The pasta bolognese is to die for and if you eat the whole bowl..."(2 Tips)
62 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- eggplant fries
- big portions
- good for groups
- good for dates
- lively
- (15 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Patrick Jr's MamaMarch 17, 2014Calamari was rubbery pizza was excellent cheese burger n fries great clams also great- over all it was a wonderful experience great food very friendly waitress. Just the calamari could have been betta
Sasha NaomiApril 30, 2016Philly Cheesesteak is amazing!!!! Filling and so flavorful! It's definitely a new favorite! Always more than enough food
Minerva RiveraFebruary 20, 2024Order 4 appetizers. Wings, 2 calamari, onions all in which were fresh, crispy and delicious. Had an espresso martini along with entree crazy Alfredo.
- Carina AlencarFebruary 23, 2014Really Nice light sauce for the mussels over linguine! Also enjoyed the eggplant fries and for dessert you have to try the Italian donuts!
Wayne HarrimanMarch 17, 2016Rib appetizer is to die for, as is the Reuben sub! Come hungry, the portions are ginormous!
Micki ThomasSeptember 9, 2014Chicken parm was good. HUGE portions of everything. Had the ribs for an appetizer and was worth it also. Will come back when I visit the area!
Morgan BurkeJanuary 9, 2015My favorite place to get shrimp scampi. A little pricy but so worth it. You'll have left overs for days. Try the milk shakes too!!
Antonio Torres Jr.August 5, 2016everything is good at this place, especially the portions of food... awesome place :-)
Jan KehrliDecember 31, 2015I love this place. Great waitstaff, super generous portions. Subs/hoagies are HUGE, ziti serves 4, pizza has great crust.
Tom RobertsJanuary 12, 2013I promise you, you will not leave hungry! One meal can possibly feed 2 to 3 people. (Depending) if you are Italian or have friends who are its like going to Nonna's house.
Roshni PecoraJuly 25, 2016Eggplant fries were delicious. Hefty portions. Fairly quick service. Recommend for anyone
- Stephanie DanekJune 6, 2012Every birthday or get together my parents and I are most likely to choose joey Garlics. I love the spinach patch pizza or eggplant fries!
Sweet potato wedges are the best sweet potato fries ever. Also their sauce is amazing. Just like my Grandmother's homemade sauce.- Andrea BotticelloMay 27, 2016The pasta bolognese is to die for and if you eat the whole bowl you may just die lol
Donnie DemarcoSeptember 23, 2014I can't remember. But I ate two entrees from there and they were AWESOME!
Samantha VelezJanuary 26, 2014The food is consistently good here. The portions are huge. Great prices and the environment is relaxed.
If you go out to eat you and don't like chicken then you shouldn't order food with chicken in it. The key is the chicken is usually in the title. Like bbq chicken pizza is going to have chicken
Good was delicious! And the portions are so large, I have enough left for dinner
Sherrie AMay 4, 2013Omg the meatball sliders are so good and I never order meatballs in a restaurant!
Michelle MaroonJune 13, 2011Share a meal the portions are huge! You will be taking home leftovers yum
Come during Lauren's shift if you sit at the bar. Best bartender ever!!
The philly cheesesteak is awesome with extra cheese!!
Maybe better pizza than frank pepe's. wait.... NO. But pretty damn good.
130 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Joey's Garlic offers great food at reasonable prices. Nobody does pizza better than Joey's Garlic!
Open until 9:00 PM (Show more)
- Mon–Thu, Sun
- 11:30 AM–9:00 PM
- Fri–Sat
- 11:30 AM–10:00 PM
(860) 372-4620
Features
Reservations
No
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. Discover & Visa)
Outdoor Seating
No
Food & Drink
Menus
Brunch, Lunch, Dinner, Happy Hour
Drinks
Wine, Full Bar, Cocktails
See More
You might also like
Places people like to go after Joey Garlic's
- 8.9
"Good fresh food. Pretty good lunch buffet. Great clam chowder!!"
Julia - 7.3
"The deli will usually let you sample the first slice of whatever you are buying before continuing the cutting so you can authorize thickness settings, and have a delish little treat!"
Brian Bugnacki - 7.5
"Really good salad kit selection!"
Stacey Hoffman
Appears on 22 lists
Created by Kathleen Anderson
136 items • 5 followersCreated by Erica F
12 items • 3 followersCreated by Jon Wilson
122 items • 8 followers