Amsterdam Burger Company
(Now Closed)Burger Joint$$$$
Upper West Side, New York
35 Tips and reviews
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Douglas EllimanJuly 17, 2014Best of the best with pasture-raised humane beef from Grow and Behold. We love their juices (orange jalapeno & mint lemonade) and drive right into their finger licking, enormous and juicy burgers.
Meghan LapidesDecember 14, 2014The burgers are amazing. The wait is less amazing. The garlic caper sauce is worth it, so are the fries. Just wait or take out. The delivery is super fast!
Rishe GMay 20, 2014The wait tends to be long and they won't seat you until the entire party arrives, but the food is worth it. Try the Australian sticky date pudding!
Kosher FoodiesJanuary 6, 2014the breakfast burger has a runny fried egg and crispy beef bacon; delicious!
- Kosher FoodiesJanuary 6, 2014the peanut butter mousse is the best dessert! and we would know, because we ordered all of them...
Even though they don't have it on the menu, they now have a veggie burger that is both decently priced and large!
Bobby TawilOctober 19, 2014Food was INSANE!!!! Had the Breakfast Burger which I managed to devour, even with all the appetizers we ordered, (and a pulled beef sandwich too)
Shlomo IsaacsonApril 29, 2014I was told to check this place out and I love it I can't wait to go back
The beef bacon was super crispy and tasty. So good.
Start off with beef nachos then any of the burgers will do!
Leo MedinaNovember 25, 2015Lots of young orthodox jews on dates. No real drinks but excellent burgers.- Their yam fritters are a delicious choice for vegetarians and meat-eaters alike.
Breakfast burger w caramelized onions? Yes, yes ill have that.
Overpriced burgers in a space with all the charm of a high school cafeteria. Food is tasty but not as good as they think it is. Not worth the (always 2x-as-long-as-they-say) wait.
Craig GoldsteinFebruary 3, 2013Don't ask for them to cut your burger in half for your children. The "manager" refuses to cut it for you. Cut your own damn burger!
Kate D.January 26, 2013Would probably go back if the burgers were about 3 dollars cheaper.. 12 bucks for a plain hamburger, nothing special? Pass.
Michael Fox-RabinovitzDecember 29, 2015Very mediocre burger, breakfast variety is quite meh. Not bad, just nothing worth making a trip for.
Cyn LoOctober 31, 2014¡Delicioso sabor! Con champiñones mas! Y de postre el apple cake exquisito. Muy lleno procura reservar y el servicio bueno pero si hay gente esperando te acarrerean y t llevan la cuenta sin q la pidas
68 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Amsterdam Burger Company
654 Amsterdam Ave (at W 92nd St)
New York, NY 10025
United States
New York, NY 10025
United States
The Amsterdam Burger Company serves delicious, expertly grilled burgers in a restaurant with a unique charm.
Permanently closed (Show more)
- Mon–Thu
- 12:30 PM–10:30 PM
- Sun
- Noon–10:30 PM
(212) 362-0700
Features
Reservations
No
Credit Cards
Yes
Outdoor Seating
Yes
Food & Drink
Menus
Dinner
See More
You might also like
Places people like to go after Amsterdam Burger Company
- 7.7
"Great beer list, tons of stuff on draft. Definitely not as scuzzy as many dive bars I've been to. Food is actually pretty good too. Don't miss the hot dogs, shashuka and the mussels"
Tiffany Langston - 5.5
""BBQ Chicken Special" rocks! Sunday - Tuesday you get a chicken (rosemary or BBQ + 1 side for $11.99. Wednesday - Friday it goes for $13.99. Challa!"
David Yarus
Appears on 61 lists
Created by Amanda Kopman
51 items • 11 followersCreated by Bobby Nooromid
197 items • 6 followers
Created by Paul Martin
199 items • 8 followers