The Meatball Shop
(Now Closed)Italian Restaurant and American Restaurant$$$$
Upper West Side, New York
See what your friends are saying about The Meatball Shop.
By creating an account you are able to follow friends and experts you trust and see the places they’ve recommended.
orSign up with email
84 Tips and reviews
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Sophie SmithApril 13, 2015One of the best meals I've had whilst in New York. Try the specials, and don't think twice about doggy bagging some of your main to make room for an ice cream sandwich - so good!
Upvote1Downvote
Richard RevillaDecember 3, 2016It's all about the balls. Brunch is a very good option with their daily special balls. You can actually move in this location as there is space.Upvote1Downvote
Liz DellAugust 16, 2014So happy they've joined the UWS!! Get the "everything but the kitchen sink" salad. You can't go wrong. Recommend with either chicken balls and pesto or spicy pork balls with mushroom 👍👍👍👍Upvote2Downvote
You can't go wrong with any of the staples on this menu, but be bold & try the daily specials! Don't forget dessert where you can pick two different cookies for your ice cream sandwich.UpvoteDownvote
KevskiAugust 19, 2017Amazing service, they are just adorable in there! Oh and yeah, the food is a killer too. Benedict brunch ftwUpvote1Downvote
Matthew SpectorJanuary 10, 2015A pretty great and spacious outpost of the phenomenal meatball chain - definitely go for the "kitchen sink" plate.Upvote1Downvote
Nik DawsonMay 7, 2016This has been one of my favourite spots for a relaxed dinner. The kitchen sink is so good and so is the hero sub. The icecream sandwiches are amazing.UpvoteDownvote
Paige CDecember 25, 2016Always check the specials, really good choices. And don't miss their ice cream sandwiches for dessert!
UpvoteDownvote
Michael KimJuly 16, 2014My staple: naked chicken balls w parmesan cream sauce over spaghetti. Add the family jewels. Get a green mkt side and make sure to save room for the ice cream sandwich!! We out chea!!!Upvote1Downvote
HectorMarch 20, 2016Like everyone says, leave room for the ice cream sandwiches. Classic meatball with tomato sauce is the way to go. Skip the drinks here.Upvote1Downvote- AngieJanuary 28, 2016Chicken meatballs with Parmesan cream sauce over rigatoni was awesome being that I love creamy, cheesy anything. Their service was friendly and efficient!UpvoteDownvote
Deborah RoseApril 14, 2017Risotto with asparagus and parsley, and chicken meatballs with Parmesan cream sauce. Am in food heaven.
UpvoteDownvote
PhanessaMay 10, 2015If you are like me and want you meatballs covered in parm like snow capped mountains, just ask and they will bring you the freshly grated cheese on the side.UpvoteDownvote
Trae FApril 21, 2017Fun place with yummy meatballs. Can't wait to work my way through the menu trying all the possible combinations.UpvoteDownvote
Ailie ChangMay 6, 2015Spicy meatball with spicy sauce on top of spaghetti and a side of mashed potatoes. Wish the portions were bigger because it's so delicious.UpvoteDownvote- Martin OngFebruary 1, 2015Have to try the brown sugar ice cream sandwich. It's heavenly.
Upvote1Downvote 
Maarten FuchsJuly 29, 2017Just awesome! I loved the special meatball with mushroom gravy sauce. I'd recommend taking 2 sides if you are a big eater.UpvoteDownvote
Christian YesidJuly 14, 2014If the Cuban of buffalo balls are in special GET THEM! Also request Tommy as a server, super nice and handsome too.
UpvoteDownvote
Matt ZoufalyMarch 23, 2015Amazing meat balls. Highly recommend for a nice (and not too pricey) night out!
UpvoteDownvote
Carlos VillaviejaMay 26, 2015Meatballs with spaguetti and the sink salad with spice meatballs and tomato. Mashed potatoes are good too. Service is very good.UpvoteDownvote
Jillian NicholsJanuary 24, 2015A bit busy, but just go to George Keeley for a beer while waiting for your table. It's worth it.
UpvoteDownvote
Katie CongletonAugust 24, 2015The meatballs are really just vehicles for the delicious sauces so mix and match to try everything - you won't be disappointed!UpvoteDownvote
Andrew FafoutakisSeptember 8, 2014Awesome, fresh food, and get yourself a proper Moscow Mule served in a copper cup.
UpvoteDownvote
BenFebruary 9, 2015Meatballs, Jell-O shots, icecream, and a selection of wine and beer. Eclectic, but a great atmosphere.UpvoteDownvote
Lindsey HoganMarch 18, 2015Great homemade tasting meatballs. Nice to be at a place that doesn't offer fries as the standard side. Good for kids too.UpvoteDownvote
Barb LeungMarch 20, 2016If someone in your party has a birthday when you're dining, let your server know and you might get a treat on the house. ;-)Upvote1Downvote
Meatballs are really good, but recommend having a side (mashed potatoes or sauteed spinach) with it to be more filling.UpvoteDownvote
johanna marielMarch 27, 2017new Hell's Kitchen location is soooo beautiful inside-anything balls go here, my fave are the vegetable balls;)UpvoteDownvote
Vivian RamirezFebruary 13, 2017Tried and true. This place always delivers on food, drinks, and fantastic service. A staple for sure.UpvoteDownvote
Great spot for good meatballs, but they surprise you with incredible ice creams sandwichesUpvoteDownvote
Henry BottjerJuly 25, 2014I went for takeout. They suggest to wait at bar or outside, they will "find you" but din't believe it when they are busy. Wait about 5-10mins then go check.
UpvoteDownvote
LES is the OG but it's always great here. Super friendly and unique for the UWS.UpvoteDownvote
Shirley LiuDecember 8, 2014Def get the beef meatball with classic tomato spaghetti and an ice cream cookie sandwichUpvoteDownvote
Kelsey SmithJuly 13, 2015Service was super fast!! Waitress was very friendly. The food was delicious!
UpvoteDownvote
I go double spicy-- spicy pork balls with spicy meat sauce over greens. A beer with that doesn't hurt.Upvote1Downvote
DavidNovember 20, 2016Food was good. Not sure I liked it enough to give it a heart? Was a tad salty. Great staff - make that fantastic staff. A little too noisy.UpvoteDownvote
Alex FishJuly 20, 2015Chicken meatballs in the Parmesan cream sauce, yes! Save room for dessert too!UpvoteDownvote- Miraculous AssemblyJuly 13, 2015They have fast service here! And great food! I would say BALLS, but that wouldn't sound right haha.UpvoteDownvote
Jeiran HasanMarch 30, 2015Ice cream sandwiches are a must try!!! Meatballs are delicious as wellUpvoteDownvote- Jeffrey GlueckApril 24, 2016Can sub out the Farro in the kitchen sink for broccoli and go PaleoUpvoteDownvote
Park Yong ShikDecember 21, 2016The special was delicious and also the chocolate cookie 🍪 😋UpvoteDownvote
Raul ReyesNovember 11, 2016the biggest problem, not to know what to get, everything is great!UpvoteDownvote- Nice brunch selection, good floats, and of course the meatballsUpvoteDownvote
- Greg CalApril 29, 2015Surprised with how good the meatballs were. Great for a big hearty mealUpvoteDownvote
Chris EvansJune 23, 2015The spicy pork sandwich is dope, and their cold brew White Russian is damn strong.UpvoteDownvote
183 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
The Meatball Shop
447 Amsterdam Ave (btwn 81st & 82nd Sts)
New York, NY 10024
United States
New York, NY 10024
United States
WE MAKE BALLS! Follow us on Instagram/Twitter @meatballers
Permanently closed (Show more)
- Mon–Thu, Sun
- 11:30 AM–Midnight
- Fri–Sat
- 11:30 AM–2:00 AM
(212) 422-1752
View menu on http://themeatballshop.com/page/food
Features
Reservations
Yes
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. Discover & Visa)
Outdoor Seating
Yes
Wheelchair Accessible
Yes
Music
Yes
Dining Options
Bar Service, Take-out
Parking
Street
Restroom
Yes
Food & Drink
Menus
Dessert
Drinks
Beer, Wine, Full Bar, Cocktails
See More
You might also like
Places people like to go after The Meatball Shop
- 9.2
"Love it. Awesome space for an event. Dancing under the giant whale was fun. Truly a fun place to go, sound sons time with nature. Kids will absolutely love the interactive space."
Lisa - 9.2
"Best theater ever ! Seats are comfy, staff is friendly, will go back for sure !"
Alexandra Tritz - 9.7
"Beautiful park. Clean and well groomed. Loved all those squirrels! Just lovely!"
Esra PRG
Appears on 150 lists
Created by Luciana Bahr
248 items • 4 followers
Created by Gaia R
123 items • 4 followers
Created by TC
196 items • 13 followers
