The House Special Sandwich, the Toggenburg Sandwich (with sauer kraut and extra house sauce on the side) and the Big Bird Salad are all soooooo gooooood. Get a flavored/specialty iced tea to pair. :)
Pretty much everything is good. I'm a black coffee kind of guy so I don't get a lot of the blended drinks but the ones I've had are always delicious. And the staff is awesome.
I wish I could comment on a tip, Ben is definitely right about the acaipomegranateblueberry pineapple smoothie. Worked at this shop for a year and a half, always suggested that smoothie.
Try falafel for breakfast! Something unusual for Rolla (and the USA for that matter), but perfectly normal in the Middle East. Way to push the envelop Ben and Jennifer!
This place is fantastic! The owners Jen and Ben are great people who really know how to make a cup of coffee! Try their lunch menu, the BLT wrap is out of this world.