Close Icon
Gear IconImportant Reminder:The Foursquare City Guide app officially sunset on December 15, 2024, with the web version following in early 2025. However, your check-in journey doesn’t end here! Join us on Swarm, where new adventures await.
Learn more
Serendipity Eatery

Serendipity Eatery

(Now Closed)
Restaurant, Breakfast Spot, and Lounge$$$$
Downtown Lafayette, Lafayette
Save
Share
Serendipity Eatery
Photos30 Photos
MenuMenu
Breakfast Food 7Not Breakfast 10Beverages 2Desserts 2From the Bar 6
Omelet Food‏
3 eggs served with toast and seasoned red potatoes.
Sub fruit, cottage cheese, or yogurt for potatoes 1.49
Basic Omelet
6.49
Basic 3 egg omelet with your choice of cheese
The Carnivore
9.59
Bacon, Sausage & Ham with your choice of cheese
Tex-Mex
9.69
Onions, jalapenos, taco beef, tomatoes, sour cream, salsa & a 4-blend cheese
choices: Cheese Options
Cheddar, Swiss, Provolone, 4-Blend, Meunster or American
Mushroom Florentine
7.44
Mushrooms & Spinach with your choice of cheese
The Vegetarian
8.19
Spinach, mushrooms, tomatoes, onions, red peppers & your choice of cheese
Build your own:
Start with a Basic Omelet and add your own ingredients. Each veggie addition is $.49.  each meat is .99
choice: Toast Options
Wheat, Ry, e Sourdough, English Muffin or Biscuits
Egg Food
All eggs are cooked your way, served with toast and seasoned red potatoes. Sub fruit, yogurt, or cottage cheese for potatoes 1.49
2 Eggs, Hold the Meat
5.79
The no-meat egg option
2 Eggs with Your Choice of Meat
7.29
Choose Bacon, Sausage or Canadian Bacon
2 Eggs, Carnivore Style
10.94
Served with Bacon, Sausage, AND Canadian Bacon
Special Egg Selections‏
This section is served exactly as described
California Benedict
8.19
A split English Muffin topped with tomato and avocado, 2 poached eggs and Hollandaise. Served with seasoned red potatoes
Eggs Benedict
7.99
A split English Muffin topped with 2 eggs poached, Canadian Bacon, and Hollandaise. Served with seasoned red potatoes
Country Benedict
7.99
A split‏ buttermilk biscuit with 2 poached eggs, sausage patties and sausage gravy. Served with seasoned red potatoes
Carb-y Food
All selections served with butter and syrup. Substitute pure maple syrup for 1.49
Fruitylicious Waffle
4.59
Fruity Pebbles joins with waffle to create *this*
Add:blueberries, chocolate chips, or peaches
1.49
1/2 order French Toast
3.89
Same as above, only half as much delicious Challah
Steel Cut Oatmeal
4.49
Top with your choice (up to 2) of brown sugar, maple syrup, raisins, blueberries, cream, peaches, or cinnamon & sugar
1/2 order Biscuits & Gravy
3.69
1 biscuit, layered with homemade sausage gravy
Straight up Home-style Waffle
3.99
Our own in-house mix, with divots for syrup and everything
2 Buttermilk Pancakes
4.19
Our own pancake mix makes for the most delicious flapjacks!
French Toast
6.19
Thick cut Challah bread makes this the best… sprinkled with powdered sugar
Cruncholicious French Toast
6.79
Bread meets the Cap’n. ‘Nuff said
Biscuits & Gravy
4.39
2 biscuits, topped with homemade sausage gravy
Side Food‏
Make your own meal or add on to one you’ve chosen
1 Pancake
2.89
2 Biscuits
1.99
Sausage Gravy
2.79
Bacon
2.29
2 slices
Canadian Bacon
2.29
2 patties
2 Eggs
1.89
Seasoned Red Potatoes
1.99
Toast
1.99
2 slices choice: sourdough, wheat or rye
Mandarin Oranges
1.99
Yogurt Vanilla
2.49
Sausage
2.29
2 patties
1 Egg
.99
Fruit Cup
2.49
Fresh selections
Kid Breakfast Food
For kids 12 and under.  If you are over 12 keep looking.
1/2 French Toast
3.99
Thick cut Challah bread makes this the bet...sprinkled with powdered sugar
1 Buttermilk Pancake
2.89
1 Egg*, no meat
4.79
1 Egg cooked your way, served with seasoned red pota-toes and 1 slice of toast
Fruitylicious Waffle
4.59
Fruity Pebbles joins with waffle to create *this*
1/2 Order Crunchilicious French Toast
4.29
Challah Bread crusted with Cap’n Crunch for the most awesome French Toast ever!
1/2 order Biscuits & Gravy
3.69
1 biscuit, cut in half, and layered with homemade sausage gravy
1 Egg*, 1 meat
6.29
1 egg cooked your way, served with seasoned red potatoes, 1 slice of toast, and your choice of bacon, sausage, or Canadian Bacon
Starter Food‏
Chili Cheese Fries
5.95
Fries topped with nacho cheese and our chili of your choice.
Mozzarella Sticks
4.39
Breaded and deep fried cheese served with marinara
Quesadillas
5.99
Chili (your choice) and cheese filled quesadillas with lettuce, sour cream, guacamole and home-mad salsa
Frie Mac N' Cheese
5.49
Adorable (they are! Don't question it just go with it) mac n' cheese cubes, panko breaded, fried to a crisp and served with southwest ranch dressing
Jalapeno Poppers
7.49
Old school cream cheese stuffed jalapenos served with ranch dressing
Chicken Strips (boneless)
7.29
3 choices: Nekkid, BBQ or Buffalo
Basket O'Rings
4.99
Beer battered onion rings with honey mustard
Pretzel and Beer Cheese...sauce
4.99
One big honkin' pretzel served with our own beer cheese sauce on the side
Liquid Food
Beef Chili
Made in hose with ground beast, a blend of 4 different beans, chiles, inions and spices in a tomato base
Cream of Tomato
Pairs so well wit the grilled cheese, we just had to keep it - Made in house
Chicken Chili
Green chiles, white beans, onions and cluck make up this white chili
Rabbit Food‏
Garden Salad
6.29
Lettuces, onion, tomato, croutons, cucumbers & red bell pepper
Taco Salad
8.99
Taco beef‏ tops chips, with romaine, tomatoes, cheese, green onions, sour cream, jalapenos & black olives. Served with fresh salsa
Cobb Salad
8.99
Fresh lettuces topped with tomato, avocado, bacon, cheese, red onion, red pepper and chicken
Dressings:
French, Ranch, Balsamic Vinaigrette, Vinegar & Oil, Thousand Island, Bleu Cheese, Italian and Honey Mustard
Caesar Salad
6.39
Romaine, Caesar dressing, parmesan cheese, croutons & anchovies
Santa Fe Salad
8.29
Fresh lettuces with black olives, corn, black beans, avocado, red onions, tomatoes, tortilla chips, cilantro, shredded cheese and a chipotle ranch dressing
Soup & Salad
6.99
A cup or a bowl of soup and a lunch sized portion of Garden or Caesar Salad
Add Chicken*
2.99
Add chicken to any salad for
Burger Food
Burgers are cooked to medium well and served with chips.  Sub any other side selection for 1.49
Add cheese to any burger for .99
Add Bacon to any burger for 1.99
Mushroom-Swiss Burger
9.49
Caramelized onions and sautéed mushrooms, all smothered with Swiss Cheese
BBQ Bacon Cheeseburger
10.99
Caramelized onion, cheddar cheese, bacon and sweet BBQ sauce & fixin's
Cheese Options:
Cheddar, Swiss, Provolone, 4-Blend, Muenster & American
The "DEAL"
7.95
2 1/4 pound patties with American cheese and bacon on a bun with lettuce, tomato, pickle and onion
Burger-Burger
7.99
1/3 pound hamburger with your choice of burger topping
Tex-Mex Burger
10.49
Chitpotle mayonnaise, avocado, jalapenos, tomatoes, onions, and cilantro
Upgrade!
Choose 100% grassfed beef burger for any of the beef burger options 1.99
Chili-Cheeseburger
9.29
1/3 pound patty topped with our own beef chili and 4 blend cheese
Cheddar Melt
9.49
A pretzel bun topped with a 1/3 pound beef burger, caramelized onions and our own Mr. Brown beer cheese sauce.  Extra napkins necessary
Non-Beef Burger Food‏
German Burger
9.89
A pretzel bun topped with a 1/3 pound Brat burger, sauerkraut, whole grain mustard and our own Mr. Brown beer cheese sauce
Tuna Sliders
9.99
Ginger ahi tuna sliders, asian slaw and wasabi mayonnaise
Hawaiian Burger
8.49
A turkey burger topped with cheddar cheese, grilled pineapple, lettuce, red onion and chipotle mayonnaise
Veggie Burger
6.79
Chipotle black bean burger, on a bun, with your choice of fixin's
Sandwich-like Food
All served with chips.  Sub any other side selection for 1.49
Cuban Panini
7.49
A toasted hoagie roll with herb mayonnaise, mustard, turkey, ham, Swiss cheese and dill pickles
California Chicken Wrap
9.49
A spinach tortilla filled with lettuce, shredded cheese, avocado, bacon, onion, tomato, chicken and chipotle mayonnaise
Pesto Tuna Wrap
7.69
Pesto tuna salad, lettuce, provolone cheese and kalamata olives in a flour tortilla wrap
(P)BLT
8.39
Braised pork‏ belly, lettuce, tomato and chipotle mayonnaise on a ciabatta bun
Grilled Pork Loin
7.99
A full prok loin chop, pounded out, seasoned, grilled and served on a bun with lettuce, tomato, onion, pickle and whole grain mustard
BBQ Beef Brisket Sandwich
8.29
Slow braised‏ beef brisket.  BBQ'd.  On a bun
Grilled Cheese
6.19
Your choice of bread filled with a blend of 4 cheeses (Muenster, Swiss, American & Provolone) and grilled to perfection.
Pittsburg Sandwich
7.99
French bread topped with pastrami and provolone cheese, coleslaw, and fries (yes, ON the sandwich)
Veggie Wrap
6.99
Spinach tortilla, provolone cheese, grilled asparagus, lettuce, tomato, onion, avocado and pesto mayo
Pecan Catfish Po'Boy
9.99
Uncle Bunker's pecan crusted catfish, lettuce, tomato, onions, chili-lime Mayo on french bread
Chicken Salad
7.99
Our own house blend of chicken, mayo, onion, and spices make this creamy delight. Served on a croissant.
Buffalo Chicken Sandwich
7.99
A fried‏ chicken breast tossed in buffalo sauce, on a bun with lettuce, tomato and ranch dressing
Miscellaneous Food‏
Chicken Tenders
6.99
5 breaded chicken strips served with kettle chips and your choice of sauce (honey mustard, ketchup, mustard, ranch, BBQ, or honey) . Make it Buffalo add $.60
Failure Pile in a Sadness Bowl
8.69
Mashed potatoes, corn, chicken strips and gravy.  In a bowl.
Side Food
Fries
1.99
Side Salad Garden or Caesar
2.49
Yogurt
2.49
Vanilla
Grilled Asparagus
2.49
Cole Slaw
1.99
Onion Rings
2.99
Mandarin Oranges
1.99
Cottage Cheese
1.99
Broccoli
1.99
Sweet Potato Fries
2.99
For the Kid in You‏
For kids 12 and under.  If you are over 12 keep looking.
All options served with kettle chips. Sub any other side for 1.49
Corn Dog
3.99
A full sized corn dog with your choice of condiments on the side.
Turkey & Cheese Sandwich OR Ham & Cheese Sandwich
4.19
Sliced Turkey OR Ham with your choice of cheese on sourdough, wheat, or rye bread or toast.
Kid Burger
6.99
1/4 pound burger patty with lettuce, tomato, onion and pickle
Chicken Tenders
4.99
3 all‏ white meat breaded chicken breast strips with your choice of Honey, BBQ, Mustard, Buffalo Sauce or Ranch dressing.
1/2 Grilled Cheese
3.99
Half grilled cheese sandwich with american cheese and sourdough
Add a shot of flavor add a shot of flavor to the beverage of your choice. Flavors are listed under italian sodas.49
Coffee
2.19
Coppermoon organic, regular or decaf, unlimited dine-in refills
Iced Tea
1.79
Black tea, regular or sweetened
Milk
White or chocolate (chocolate syrup made here from scratch)
Jones Soda
2.49
Root beer or cream soda. Made with pure cane sugar and served in a can.
Fountain Sodas
2.39
Coke, diet coke, sprite, or  lemonade
Hot Tea
2.49
Choice organic teas, served in a tea caddy, your choice of our generous selection
Juice
Grapefruit, orange, tomato, or apple
Mexican Coke
2.89
Made with sugar and served in a bottle. It makes a difference
Bottled Spring Water
1.39
Ice mountain
Served all day
S'More Pie
5.99
Graham cracker crust, chocolate ganache and toasted marshmallow topped with home-made chocolate sauce
Lemon Blueberry Tartlette
6.49
Fresh blueberries and lemon curd served in a pastry shell
Brownie Cheesecake
6.49
Pineapple Upside-down Cake
5.69
Start your day off by spoiling yourself with a mimosa or bloody mary
Mixed Drinks‏
Mimosas
Orange juice and champagne wonderful with the eggs benedict florentine!
Margaritas
No margarita mix here! All made to taste the way a margarita should. On the rocks or frozen
Bloody Marys
Smirnoff vodka and our own bloody mary mix, topped off with a lime and celery
Irish Coffee
Jameson and kahula combine with coffee to make this warming treat. Topped with whipped cream and green crème de menthe.
Liquors Currently Offered
Glenfiddich Scotch
Kahlua
Bombay Sapphire Gin
Grand Mariner
Maker's Mark
Jose Quervo Tequila
Malibu Rum
Jim Beam Bourbon
Smirnoff Vodka
Bacardi Rum
Patron Tequila
Myer's Dark Rum
Jameson Irish Whiskey
Midori
Disaranno Amaretto
Bailey's Irish Cream
Tanqueray Gin
Courvoisier Cognac
Jack Daniels
Captain Morgan
Grey Goose Vodka
Segrams 7 Whiskey
Grand Mariner Orange Liquor
Crown Royal
Beers‏
We offer a great selection of bottled beers, including lafayette’s own people’s brand!
Miller Lite
Corona
Heineken
People's Beers
Budweiser
Sam Adams Lager
Bud Light
Killian's Red
Goose Island 312
Blue Moon Belgian White
Stella Artois
Pilsner
Angry Orchard Crisp Cider
Mgd
Mound Builder IPA
Coors Light
Mr. Brown Dark Ale
Honey Brown
Farmer's Daughter
Mikes Hard Lemonade
Michelob Ultra

Problem with this menu?

Related Searches

  • serendipity eatery lafayette •
  • serendipity eatery lafayette photos •
  • serendipity eatery lafayette location •
  • serendipity eatery lafayette address •
  • serendipity eatery lafayette •
  • serendipity an eclectic eatery lafayette •
  • serendipity - an eclectic eatery lafayette •
  • serendipity eatery lafayette •
  • serendipity eatery downtown lafayette lafayette

Foursquare © 2025  Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA

Compass icon
Serendipity Eatery
731 Main St (at 8th St)
Lafayette, IN 47901
United States
Get directions
Information icon
We offer a variety of menu item that are sure to please everyone. From home made soups to fresh seafood and hand cut steaks.
Clock icon
Permanently closed (Show more)
  • Tue–Wed
    • 11:00 AM–2:00 PM
  • Thu–Fri
    • 11:00 AM–2:00 PM
    • 5:00 PM–9:00 PM
  • Sat
    • 9:00 AM–2:00 PM
    • 5:00 PM–9:00 PM
  • Sun
    • 9:00 AM–2:00 PM
Phone icon
(765) 423-1011
World Wide Web icon
Twitter icon
@serendipityeat
Features
Reservations
Yes
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. Discover & Visa)
Wi-Fi
Free
Outdoor Seating
No
Food & Drink
Menus
Breakfast, Brunch, Lunch, Dinner
See More

You might also like

Appears on 1 list

United States » Indiana » Tippecanoe County » Lafayette » Downtown Lafayette