Payne's Restaurant
Restaurant, Coffee Shop, and Ice Cream Parlor$$$$
Gas City
"Delicious twist on the club sandwich"(6 Tips)
"Great new outdoor seating."(2 Tips)
"The soups are handmade from scratch and healthy and delicious."(5 Tips)
"sweet potato"(3 Tips)
32 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- outdoor seating
- fish
- toffee pudding
- good for groups
- soup
- (14 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Benoit CoulmontJune 30, 2014Amazing place! Nice mild flavor, great diversity of foods. Could not make up my mind on what to eat. Hummus - delicious, hot pear salad - a great flavor combination, British chicken curry - a hit.
Jennifer Van ElkAugust 14, 2012This place is amazing. A new favorite of mine. Our service was great, and quick, and the food was SO GOOD. Everyone loved it. Definitely a diamond in the rough.
NuriAugust 18, 2016Amazing frozen custard and authentic fish and chips, a must have if you're passing through! A hidden gem for sure, highly recommend!
Melissa BMarch 20, 2022The fish and chips was yummy! I’d suggest getting a small unless you’re really hungry
- Kenneth PettySeptember 9, 2019The Fish & Chips is the best in the world. The soups are handmade from scratch and healthy and delicious. You must try them out.
Christine KrockOctober 20, 2018The sweet potato and apple soup is a must for me. And a cup of cappuccino
Macy TerryNovember 5, 2014Really good breakfast. Love the atmosphere here. French toast with custard is amazing
Jill TygeOctober 17, 2022This place was great - British food - quiet - quaint atmosphere- truck parking a block away! Definitely go there again! 🍻
Paula PearsonSeptember 24, 2018Server was great!! Fish was very good. Kind of an unusual little place. But well worth going to. Yum!!
Jake BarryNovember 2, 2012Favorite place to eat when in Gas City/Marion. Their custard is to die for and I've never tried anything there that didn't impress me!
Love the effort they have put into this place. It definitely holds its own against the run of the mill.
Good food, nice outdoor area, love the fish n chips and the toffee pudding.- Sarah ArnoldAugust 11, 2013Delicious twist on the club sandwich and spend the extra buck on the cole slaw...sweet and saucy!
John LemanJuly 3, 2015Mimosas, smoothies, or any other thing on the menu. It's simply too good to be true.
Potato,onion, and bacon soup with brie and mozzarella grilled cheese. Delicious.- Alecia C.July 20, 2012Get the sweet potato, apple, and ginger soup with the pepper jack grilled cheese - it's incredible!
Taylor students: Great place to study if you want to get off campus for a while.
Rosemary LAugust 14, 2011Call your order ahead, especially if you're in a hurry or have a larger table. They can be a little slow.- Tim RockstrohMay 21, 2011Great new outdoor seating. Order a Flustard Floozy for a late night pick me up!
Robin GingerichAugust 11, 2010Nice, small, and a little noisy. Will go back, but bring my wife next time.
Slow service, but great coffee so I guess it's worth the wait
Melody FordApril 14, 2019Waited for 30 min. No water. No server. Can’t get into the bathroom. I am out.
97 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Think global. Eat local.
Closed until 11:00 AM (Show more)
- Mon–Fri
- 10:30 AM–10:00 PM
- Sat
- 9:00 AM–10:00 PM
- Sun
- 11:00 AM–10:00 PM
(765) 998-0668
Features
Reservations
Yes
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. Discover & MasterCard)
Wi-Fi
Free
Outdoor Seating
Yes
Parking
Public Lot
Restroom
Yes
See More
You might also like
Places people like to go after Payne's Restaurant
Appears on 7 lists
Created by Kathy T
8 items
Created by Lisa Pincelli
19 itemsCreated by Sam Haus
14 items