See all
351 photos

One if by Land, Two if by Sea

American Restaurant$$$$

West Village, New York

Save

7.8^/10

375

ratings

Ranked #1 for romantic places in the West Village
The experts at The Corcoran Group and New York Habitat recommend this place
"The De-Constructed Beef Wellington and Cosmopolitan are the best!"(13 Tips)
"Love the fact they have a live pianist."(5 Tips)
"historic 18th-century carriage house in West Village"(5 Tips)
"This upscale restaurant is perfect for a classy, romantic night out."(41 Tips)

106 Tips and reviews

Filter:

romantic
beef wellington
carriage house
fireplaces
desserts
tasting menu
quiet
music
gardens
foie gras
bar
pretzel bread
corn ice cream
dinner
caramel corn
brunch food
comfortable seats
ice cream sundaes
healthy food
trendy
(15 more)

Sort:

Popular
Recent

S LApril 7, 2013
Romantic, classy restaurant. Excellent food, excellent service.
Mindy YangAugust 7, 2011
Super romantic. Go there for special occasions (proposal, anniversaries...) Get the duck. The wellington is good, but I personally think it's a bit overrated.
Ve KwanFebruary 16, 2014
Love this venue! VERY romantic! Love the fact they have a live pianist. Love their wine menu... The food was amazing!! And their service was so attentive! High recommended!!
Spoon UniversityOctober 20, 2016
The restaurant was actually Aaron Burr’s carriage house, although rumor has it that Burr is not alone. It’s estimated that the establishment is haunted by 20 ghosts. Read more
Chris MaddernAugust 19, 2015
Been here 5+ times
Get. The. Beef. Wellington.
Matt DunaMarch 5, 2013
Excellent place to eat. Lobster Bisque is fantastic!
Eduardo HolguinJanuary 21, 2014
Chef tasting is the best thing ever made. Also, our waitress looked like Kristen Wiig
Chris KieffDecember 15, 2009
This is THE most romantic restaurant in NYC- bar none! I proposed to my wife here 15 years ago and it worked! Try it yourself.
Sergery SalMarch 9, 2015
Nothing special about entrée but def should check out the chocolate mousse with raspberry ice cream - delicious
Levent AkgermanNovember 8, 2016
Romantic spot for selective taste buds
Kaitlyn PezikMay 30, 2015
super pricy, but somewhere you have to try
Benjamin CoatsMay 19, 2016
It's an average meal at a very much above average price.
Nikki B 🦂June 19, 2016
No lie, this place is haunted. Drinks are poppin though. Ghosts come out at night !!!
Greg BodenairFebruary 7, 2012
Try the Tagliatelle With Venison - Course #1 amazing
Meaghan NolanJune 6, 2013
Beautiful atmosphere. Last call is ~10:30 on a midweek night.
Greg BodenairFebruary 7, 2012
Try the Braised Short Ribs - Second course...amazingly tender
Damien Basile 😈February 15, 2010
So romantic! Grab a glass of your favorite cocktail and cozy up with someone late at night on a couch by the fire.
Serena TMay 19, 2011
this is the best restaurant I've been to in the city and perhaps EVER.
DeepikaJuly 22, 2011
Ambience: Very good.Food: Very okay (vegetarian) Nothing compared to Per Se; Daniel and Jean George's.Service: Good.Title: Hyped. Nothing oozed romance; not the most romantic restaurant of NYC.
Nastassja PorrasApril 16, 2022
The food is wonderful ☺️
Joy BautistaJune 19, 2011
The De-Constructed Beef Wellington and Cosmopolitan are the best!
Andreas WuchnerApril 17, 2012
What a fantastic place to have dinner in New York.
Corinne KangMay 23, 2013
Overrated. Don't eat the cioppino - very fishy & mussels not fresh. Hv the pork belly for starter instead. For mains, don't hv the cod - very rubbery. Lobsters were out so din get to try what I wanted
Morgan PolotanMarch 21, 2015
Romantic date spot.
Brad KavinDecember 29, 2015
Tasting menu on Valentine's Day
Behind The BurnerMarch 23, 2010
A super romantic restaurant with interesting menu choices...like pigeon. Great with pomegranate!
Ibrahim MalickSeptember 14, 2013
With my birthday girl Pramilla Malick
David RohrsheimJuly 26, 2011
Ask for the table with booth seating under the staircase
Amy BermanMay 14, 2014
Awesome jazz brunch
Ian PettyDecember 31, 2011
Atmosphere was great, corresponding to all other reviews, but David was our server; very cold. Food was decent but a good server makes the dinner an event. Disappointed.
David RosenbergFebruary 7, 2010
Ok. So, this is one of the most romantic restaurants in nyc. Ask to sit near the garden but upstairs ain't bad. plus the piano bar is nice.
Paige HoffsteinAugust 21, 2010
Go before labor day and try the extended restaurant week menu! It's fab!
Linnie DJanuary 31, 2012
Efrain aims for great service and delivers.
MaggieApril 14, 2010
3 for 3 on the pre-fixed menu. If you like lavender, get the custard!
Local BigwigJanuary 30, 2011
The Beef Wellington is to die for!
Ari FuchsJuly 25, 2011
Ask for the pretzel bread.
D FJuly 14, 2010
Amazing food, great ambiance. Highly recommend!
Mary Martini D'AriesDecember 14, 2010
romantic restaurant! get the beef wellington
Ryan GomezDecember 13, 2011
Beef Wellington or Tasting Menu
amNewYorkNovember 21, 2011
HauntedNYC: Rumored to be haunted by Aaron Burr and his daughter, Theodosia, runaway slaves, and a female spirit who protects the restaurant by causing rude, "nasty" people to fight.
Nick DrandakisJanuary 24, 2017
terrible value for money, me thinks
Alex LeoMarch 28, 2011
Gnocchi + Wellington + champagne = perfect
Simran JaisingJanuary 27, 2013
pretzel bread. FTW
LuciNovember 9, 2014
It's over price, too expensive for what you get.... I don't recommend this place
Erik ShaniFebruary 24, 2014
Nothing special at all. The decor is nice. Food is OK at best and the service is sub par by any standard
Matt KoulermosFebruary 14, 2011
Duck breast with trifles was incredible - server was kind of a dick
jane chungFebruary 3, 2012
Get the hake
Ozlem GulJuly 8, 2010
You have to try the Beef Wellington
KarinaApril 15, 2012
just so romantic :)
Katerina SmirnovaDecember 26, 2014
Terrible service, never gonna come again, so disappointed , food also was so-so, didn't like even desserts

1 2 3

351 Photos

One if by Land, Two if by Sea

Related Searches

You might also like

Places people like to go after One if by Land, Two if by Sea

Appears on 882 lists

Top places in the area

Is this your business? Claim it now.