See all
110 photos

Noodle Pudding

Italian Restaurant$$$$

Brooklyn Heights, Brooklyn

Save

Noodle Pudding

8.6^/10

334

ratings

Ranked #6 for gnocchi in Brooklyn
"Amazing gnocchi and squash blossoms when in bloom"(6 Tips)
"Try the Risotto With Rock Shrimp And Corn"(2 Tips)
"When they are running the risotto with rock shrimp and corn, GET IT."(2 Tips)
"The gnocchi is heaven, as is the lasagna."(19 Tips)

90 Tips and reviews

Filter:

good for dates
risotto
daily specials
pork belly
good for groups
casual
Chicken Milanese
braised short ribs
liver
polenta
great value
eggplant parmigiana
salads
meats
dinner
asparagus
cash only
crowded
good for special occasions
mushrooms
(15 more)

Sort:

Popular
Recent

Dominique BrittenMarch 1, 2015
Lovely atmosphere, great service and even better food.
Kaja KrólikowskaOctober 13, 2017
Overpriced, not high quality food. No receipts provided - only piece of paper like on attached photo. While paying and leaving the tip - the waiter did complain that the tip is not enough. Dissaponted
Jennifer HarrellAugust 21, 2013
A must for any local and traveler alike. This place brings tears to my eyes.
Anthony DeRicoMay 17, 2010
Been here 5+ times
Staff is great. atmosphere jovial. food delicious. Try the daily specials - seafood is fresh everyday. Lasagna Bolognese is unbeatable.
JennyJennyMarch 2, 2014
Been here 10+ times
If you're a true calamari lover, ask for extra tentacles.
Lia RobinsonJune 9, 2015
Been here 25+ times
15$ house wine
Peter SteinbergOctober 8, 2014
The simple steak over greens is perfection.
Daniel L.September 18, 2011
Cash Only - gnocchi is great, steaks are cooked perfect, and seafood is super fresh. Wine is $$$$ and service is poor.
Billy HenehanFebruary 27, 2013
Been here 10+ times
If the pork belly is on the menu, order the pork belly.
Amanda AlbergoMay 19, 2013
After a 45min wait for a table, we waited another 45 minutes for our meal. Service was unfriendly and worst of all, the Gnoochi and calamari were tasteless. Cash only. Fail all around.
Dave BrownOctober 23, 2010
Hands down the best meal you'll have in Brooklyn. Can't go wrong with anything on the menu.
bradleyNovember 30, 2012
Been here 50+ times
Enjoy food at the bar. They treat you so well here!
Natalia MarmolejoJuly 17, 2015
If there is tuna on the menu, get it.
ARMarch 17, 2013
Octopus appetizer was beyond amazing.
Maru RegalziSeptember 21, 2015
The tiramisu is awesome!
Kathy TuznikJuly 25, 2015
Cash only. But worth it.
MidgeMadge DFebruary 19, 2010
Words can not express. The specials are always amazing. The taglietelle, the montauk bass, and it's cheeeeap
Yang SJuly 20, 2013
Order the calf's liver. It's delicious.
AliJuly 27, 2012
Try the Risotto With Rock Shrimp And Corn
Payman BahmaniAugust 16, 2010
If you happen to have Anthony as your server, tell him I sent you. Then hand him the menus and go with his recommendations.
Abby G.May 9, 2022
leave room for dessert
Christian BrucculeriSeptember 12, 2020
Cash only place mistaking mediocrity for old school charm. River deli is 10x better
JeremyApril 16, 2012
Great food + atmosphere. CASH ONLY -_-
JennyJennyDecember 18, 2010
Been here 10+ times
My favorite Italian restaurant. The calamari is always perfectly cooked.
Brent CaswellAugust 30, 2015
Quite good in the location.
John SAugust 13, 2014
A special occasion kind of place
Lea CeasrineFebruary 2, 2017
You won't go broke over carbs!
Greg HApril 11, 2018
Calf liver !
Sam MorrillMay 27, 2011
Been here 10+ times
The menu here would be perfect if it weren't printed in comic sans.
Daniel KriegerJuly 16, 2011
Food was pretty good but my lasagna was cold in the middle and service was a bit too rushed, had to order a few things a few times :)
M GDecember 18, 2013
Cash only.
Michael CavallaroSeptember 18, 2010
Get the gnocchi!!! So light...amazing
Mehmet Fatih YıldızFebruary 7, 2011
Don't forget to bring cash. They don't accept cards.
Rahul GandhiJuly 13, 2010
food is amazing, but service is WAY TOO fast to enjoy a sit down meal.
Courtney ReimerSeptember 9, 2009
The greatness is marred slightly by the cash only policy, which wouldn't matter if there was an ATM nearby...
sara selbert savovFebruary 20, 2010
Get the dover scallops and avocado salad
Brady ForrestDecember 28, 2010
Have the endive salad
Amy CorriganFebruary 25, 2010
Well-loved eatery in Bklyn Heights.
gillian kostApril 17, 2010
Horrendously crowded for fri night dinner.
Tim IsganitisDecember 3, 2009
Buffalo Mozzarella appetizer, Lasagna entree, and Chocolate Mousse Cake w/ Hazelnut Gelato dessert can't be beat!

1 2

110 Photos

Noodle Pudding

Related Searches

You might also like

Places people like to go after Noodle Pudding

Appears on 386 lists

Top places in the area

Is this your business? Claim it now.