See all
726 photos

New York Pizza Suprema

Pizzeria$$$$

Chelsea, New York

Save

9.0^/10

1,318

ratings

Ranked #3 for NY style pizza in New York
Has a stamp of approval from Serious Eats and Gothamist
"Best place for pizza by the slice near Penn Station."(20 Tips)
"Cosy place with amazing pizza, loved Upside down and Hawaiian."(13 Tips)
"The upside down slice was good and cheap... good service also"(10 Tips)
"Def on of the best NY style pizzas in town."(7 Tips)

307 Tips and reviews

Filter:

pizza
penn station
upside
casual
good for a quick meal
good for a late night
lively
upside down slice
good for groups
cheese pies
white pies
gardens
whole pies
cheese
sausage
delis
Sicilian
spinach
city
inexpensive
(15 more)

Sort:

Popular
Recent

JinsAugust 17, 2014
The pepperoni pizza is the best. Each slice is $4 but a while pizza is $25
NJ.comJanuary 13, 2014
The brightly-lit, cafeteria-like dining room and plain-talking, wise-cracking staff make for a quintessential New York experience. Read more
GuidoneNovember 6, 2013
Perfect place to go after a match of the Knicks. Good quality ingredients and tasty pizzas!
Jimmy JordanApril 11, 2014
This is the best pizza and is right by Penn Station. Bring cash if you plan on spending less than $10 otherwise there is a ATM inside.
Adam KubanJuly 31, 2013
Been here 5+ times
Don't leave without trying the "upside-down" slice, which has a rich, savory-sweet sauce and a light crust. And there's just something satisfying about the way the cheese melds with the dough.
Gabby HJuly 12, 2018
Grandmother’s (I think that’s what it’s called) is awesome — not too sweet. Pepperoni is solid. Crisp edge with some chew.
Ahmad SOctober 15, 2017
Big slices, new York style pizza, lots of cheese!
Graham GnallJanuary 26, 2018
Classic NYC regular slice. Also, upside down square slice. If you ever have to withstand penn station in either direction, stop here for strength.
Eric DDecember 12, 2019
Been here 10+ times
Great pizza (coming from a pizza snob!). Best Sicilian slices - slightly sweet sauce ... excellent dough.
HectorNovember 23, 2015
Best crust for a classic NYC pizza slice. Get the plain slice, and for toppings - ask for cold mozzarella.
Eric HoAugust 20, 2016
They serve delicious pizza by the slice! 🍕🍕🍕
William HAugust 20, 2014
Service is a bit surly and $3 is steep for a plain slice, but the pizza is top-notch. Keep it simple, the toppings look better than they taste.
S. NewlandJuly 15, 2013
Friggin' awesome pizza! I don't even like mushrooms, and I loved their mushroom slice. Go there now!
Ride AboveJuly 24, 2013
The flavor of the "Grandma Slice" is incredible. Nice booths and air conditioning. Workers are very efficient.
Leemor YuravlivkerJuly 4, 2019
The hot honey 🍕 is unreal. Don’t 👏 miss 👏 out 👏
Mohit GuptaJuly 8, 2018
The White Pizza aka ricotta and honey is a must.
Josh DantoDecember 1, 2015
Been here 5+ times
Good stuff! Always try to stop on by when I come through Penn Station.
Eric LeebowAugust 6, 2018
Been here 10+ times
Excellent pizza!! Try it, you'll be glad you did.
Natalia SniegurDecember 26, 2016
Cosy place with amazing pizza, loved Upside down and Hawaiian.
Phil KenchJanuary 3, 2015
Great range of slices to choose, 1-2 is plenty for lunch.
Reeya ShahSeptember 30, 2015
Amazing slices, very convenient to penn station, penn plaza, and MSG. Loved the sausage sicilian
Elizabeth LeeOctober 13, 2016
Hands down, the best slice of pizza I have eaten in nyc. Upside down and white pizza!
Chris KonecnyJuly 14, 2018
Pleasantly surprised to eat some of the best pizza I've had
K MApril 11, 2019
I recommend the white pizza or the Sicilian if you’re looking for a thick crust.
Adam LaiacanoFebruary 20, 2016
Been here 5+ times
Quite possibly the best slice shop in NYC. I go every time I'm in the area.
Philip HovAugust 27, 2014
Very good pizza , i'd go with the fresh Mozzarella , BUT the Place isnt cozy... Pretty cold . Turn the A/C of and the music up please!
William DoonanFebruary 6, 2017
New York is known for it's great pizza, but I must say that this is the best I have ever had.
Aaron JohnsMay 18, 2013
A friend sent me here and I can't get enough now. EVERY time I fly in I eat here. It's the best - hands down.
Julian SiDecember 23, 2018
Superb thin crust - Awesome NYC pizza 🍕
Juan DiezMay 2, 2018
Hot honey and ricotta is a must
An OccesSeptember 3, 2015
Been here 5+ times
Awesome selection to choose from and super friendly staff. Supreme Indeed! 🍕🍕
Ronnie RothAugust 31, 2015
Amazing slice! Probably the best in NY
Saranya ManoharanAugust 22, 2014
The mozzarella and basil pizza super thin crust and yummy
Rosie HendersonNovember 22, 2015
Great place for a quick bite. Not the best pizza in the city but pretty good.
DoniaMarch 29, 2019
Been here 5+ times
Hot Honey Slice. Don’t knock it til you try it.
KaraMay 29, 2013
The most authentic and delicious Italian New York pizza. Chicken parmigiana pizza is to die for.
Dan. MastrettaNovember 16, 2013
Been here 5+ times
Pizza this good can change your day, month or life for the better. The plain slice is blissful.
Eric DDecember 30, 2019
Been here 10+ times
Best pizza in the neighborhood. Always a must when I travel in/out of Penn Station.
George RoblesApril 24, 2018
Some of the best Pizza you can find in the city by far!
MischaMay 10, 2016
Best slice ever, you can't go wrong by being simple...order a cheese slice
Social News NetworkMarch 31, 2013
It's some of the best pizza in the city. All you need to get is a slice of cheese, perfect as is.
Jhokania D.March 5, 2023
Been here 25+ times
Margherita + Fig
Sascha GotoDecember 14, 2023
One of New York’s best pizza places
Leigh Anne ZinsmeisterAugust 26, 2014
Grab a classic New York slice if you're near Penn Station!
AhuvaJuly 27, 2017
The sauce is really rich a(almost meaty), go for extra fresh mozzarella or upside down
Alison CarewMay 26, 2018
Chicken parm pizza was awesome!
JillDecember 9, 2013
Chicken Parm Pizza is delicious! Make sure you know what u want to order before they ask or they will yell at you!
Ahmed AljabriAugust 12, 2016
The vegetarian pizza is awesome
Jonathan FlorezJune 24, 2016
White pizza and meat lovers were awesome. True, delicious NY pizza!
Timur RustamovNovember 29, 2018
If you wanna have some nice fat pizza New York style - this is the place to go.

1 2 3 4 5 6 7

726 Photos

New York Pizza Suprema

Related Searches

You might also like

Places people like to go after New York Pizza Suprema

Appears on 1,120 lists

Top places in the area

Is this your business? Claim it now.