Have you tried the Swingle? It's a key lime pie—tart lime curd, buttery graham cracker crust, and all—frozen and enrobed in high-end dark chocolate, then shoved on a popsicle stick. Read more.
Everyone is going to tell you to get Soler's pupusas. But trust me, get their savory (not sweet) chicken tamales. Those will rock your world. And drown it with a glass of their horchata. Read more.