Planning a trip to Chicago?

Foursquare can help you find the best places to go to.

My Pie Pizza & Li'l Guys Sandwiches

My Pie Pizza & Li'l Guys Sandwiches

Pizzeria and Sandwich Spot$$$$
Bucktown, Chicago
Save
Share
My Pie Pizza & Li'l Guys Sandwiches
8.8/10
57
ratings
Photos47 Photos
MenuMenu
Little Guy's Sandwiches Menu 24Vegan Menu 3Little Guy's Catering Menu 6Main Menu 12
Soup
Always Homemade! Call to inquire which 2 soups are available. These soups are served in the following order: Chicken Noodle, Tomato-Basil, Portabella Posole, New England Clam Chowder, French Onion, Baked Potato, Chili, Cream of Mushroom, Minestrone, Broccoli, Corn Chowder
Soup of the Day
3.45
Shrimp & Sweet Potato Chowder*
3.95
Available every Friday! A Li'l Guys original! Classic shrimp chowder with real chunks of shrimp in a creamy broth with sweet potatoes & cayenne pepper, bacon & sherry
Grand Daddys
The Turkonator
9.25
Turkey breast with LTO, and homemade honey-mustard sandwiched on French bread
Damen Avenue Club*
10.95
Turkey breast, bacon, munster, LTO, and mayo on French bread
Corned Beef-a-Liscious
10.75
Home-cured & cooked corned beef brisket with LTO, 1000 Island on French
The Franco-Italian
9.75
Genoa salami with provolone on French bread w/ spicy giardiniera, balsamic vinaigrette, lettuce, tomato & red onions
Beefaholic
9.25
Homecooked roast beef with Dijon, lettuce, tomato, and red onion on French bread
Chicken Focaccia
9.75
Chicken breast with a pesto-mayo, mozzarella, LTO on tomato focaccia
Egg Salad-a-Rama
8.50
Light & fluffy egg salad on Hawaiian bread with LTO
Veg-O-Rama
8.50
Cucumbers, lettuce, tomatoes, roasted red peppers, onions, kalamata olives, feta cheese & hummus on wheat bread
Pesto Turkey*
9.95
Turkey breast, LTO, provolone, pesto-mayo served on tomato-focaccia
The Perfect Corner
10.75
Home-cured & cooked corned beef brisket on rye w/ Dijon
An American Ham
9.25
Kretschmar's hickory-smoked ham, with American cheese, lettuce, tomato, red onions, & Hellmann's mayo on Hawaiian bread
The Porker
9.75
Kretschmar's ham, Genoa salami & pepperoni with provolone, lettuce, tomato, red onions, & balsamic vinaigrette on French bread
Beef & Swiss
9.95
Slow-roasted bottom round with horseradish sauce, Swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato, and red onions on French bread
Chuckie's Delight*
9.25
Solid white albacore tuna with Hellmann's Mayo on multi-grain wheat with lettuce and tomato, Sorry Charlie!
Chicken Salad-a-Rama
8.50
Our slow-roasted chicken breast with Granny Smith apples, celey, walnuts, LTO and Hellmann's mayo on Hawaiian bread
Baked Sandwiches
Baked Turkonator
9.95
With Swiss cheese
Ultimate Homemade Reuben*
11.95
Only on Fridays & Saturdays. The first sandwich made with homemade-from-scratch, baked-to-order bread. That's right! We bake the bread when you place your order with the best homemade corned beef, Bavarian sauerkraut, & Swiss cheese. 1000 Island on the side
Tkrb*
9.95
Turkey & roast beef with Swiss & Cheddar baked on a French bread with LTO and thousand island
Tuna Melt
9.95
Solid white albacore tuna salad-ized with Hellmann's mayo topped with Cheddar and baked on French bread
Ruebenesque
11.50
Our own home-cured & cooked corned beef brisket with sauerkraut, 1000 Island dressing, and Swiss cheese baked on rye
Chicken Caesar Florentine
9.75
Roasted chicken breast topped with spinach & mozzarella, baked on tomato focaccia with Caesar dressing
Hot Ham & Swiss
9.25
Kretschmar's hickory-smoked ham with Swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato, red onions, & Hellmann's Mayo on French bread
Build Your Own Grand Daddy
Regular Size: $8.50 / Deli Size: $10.50. Optional Daddy Pack: Add Potato Chips, Pickle & Reg. Fountain Drink +$2.76. Sandwiches made with Gluten-Free, bread are prepared in a Non Gluten-Free kitchen environment
Step 1 - Meats
choose one
Turkey
+$0.75
Corned Beef
+$2.25
Salami
Egg Salad
Chicken Breast
Roast Beef
+$0.75
Ham
Tuna Salad
+$0.75
Chicken Salad
Bacon
Step 2 - Bread
choose one
French
Hawaiian
Focaccia
+0.50
Rye
Multi-Grain
Gluten-Free
+$1.50
Step 3 - Veggies
Lettuce
Onion
Spinach
Pickles
Giardiniera
+$0.50
Tomato
Cucumbers
Green Peppers
Sauerkraut
Red Peppers
+$0.50
Step 4 - Dressing
Hellmann's Mayo
1000 Island
Hummus
Honey-Mustard
Yellow Mustard
Italian
Pesto Mayo
Horseradish Mayo
Dijon
Brown Mustard
Balsamic Vin.
Optional Cheese
+$0.75
American
Mozzarella
Provolone
Cheddar
Muenster
Swiss
Li'l Guys
Mini-sandwiches. 2-Pack $7.76. Cheese +$0.25 each Li'l Guy
Step 1 - Li'l Guys
Choose 2
Turkey
Tuna, RB or Turkey +$0.20 /sandwich, Corned Beef +$0.75 /sandwich
Corned Beef
Tuna, RB or Turkey +$0.20 /sandwich, Corned Beef +$0.75 /sandwich
Ham
Chicken Salad
Roast Beef
Tuna, RB or Turkey +$0.20 /sandwich, Corned Beef +$0.75 /sandwich
Salami
Tuna Salad
Egg Salad
Step 2 - Sides
+$1.35. Choose 1
Comes with Potato Chips
Upgrade to a Homemade Side Dish
Step 3 - Drink
Choose 1
Comes with a Regular Fountain Drink
Upgrade to a Real Fruit Smoothie
Li'l Guy Meats / Fillings
Turkey Breast
2.75
With homemade honey / dijon mustard. Grade A natural turkey breasts
Corned Beef
3.30
With Dijon. Cured in store for 7 days, slowly cooked for 12 hours
Ham
2.55
With Hellmann's mayo. Kretschmar's smoked
Egg Salad
2.55
Gently tossed so it's devilishly tasty
Roast Beef
2.75
With Dijon. Tender, homemade & slow-roasted choice flat bottom round
Salami
2.55
With Dijon. Genoa aged salami
Tuna Salad
2.75
Simple and superb, made with solid white albacore, the best! Tossed with Hellmann's Mayonnaise
Chicken Salad
2.55
Slow-roasted chicken breast with Granny Smith apples, nuts & mayo
Kids Stuff
Under ten
Kids Pb & J Li'l Guy
0.95
Kids Pop
1.41
Kids Toasted Cheese Li'l Guy
0.95
Milk Bottle
2.15
Side Dishes
Made from scratch!!
Traditional Potato Salad
2.85
Our special version of the classic made with Hellmann's mayo, Dijon mustard, fresh hard-boiled eggs & crisp celery
Pesto Penne
2.85
Our best seller! Penne pasta with fresh basil pesto, mozzarella, & sun-dried tomatoes
Pasta Salad
2.85
Tri-color rotini, aged balsamic vinaigrette, feta, kalamata olives, & red onions
Potato Chips
1.50
Sea Salt, BBQ, Jalapeno, Salt & Vinegar
Fresh Green Salads
Dressings: French, 1000 Island, Ranch, Creamy Garlic, Blue Cheese, Mandarin Orange Vinaigrette, Italian, Balsamic Vinaigrette, Lite Ranch. Extra Dressing $0.75. Extra Caesar Dressing $0.95
Dinner Salad
5.25
Combination of seasonal fresh greens topped with carrots, cucumbers, tomatoes, croutons, and your choice of dressing
Caesar Salad
7.95
Fresh greens with croutons and a traditional homemade Caesar dressing
Chefs Salad
9.95
Roasted turkey, Kretschmar's hickory smoked ham, cheddar cheese, cucumbers, tomatoes & hard-boiled eggs on a bed of lettuce with your choice of dressing
Mandarin Orange Salad
9.95
Fresh greens, Mandarin oranges, mushrooms, tomatoes, red onions, blue cheese & walnuts, served with our homemade Mandarin orange vinaigrette
Cobb Salad
9.95
Tomatoes, chicken breast, eggs, blue cheese, & bacon on bed of fresh greens with your choice of dressing
Real Fruit Smoothies
Our smoothies are fat-free and all-natural! Made from 100% real fruit and juice, no mixes or fillers. Try one, you'll love it!
Strawberry, Banana, & Juice
4.75
Your choice of orange, apple, or pineapple juice
Strawberry, Raspberry, Juice
5.25
Your choice of orange, apple, or pineapple juice
Peach, Banana, & Juice
4.75
Your choice of orange, apple, or pineapple juice
Make Your Own!
Pick 2 fruits & a juice
Strawberry, Blueberry, Juice
5.25
Your choice of orange, apple, or pineapple juice
Blueberry, Banana, & Juice
5.25
Your choice of orange, apple, or pineapple juice
Mango, Banana, & Juice
4.75
Your choice of orange, apple, or pineapple juice
Smoothie Add-Ons
Protein Shot
0.75
Ice Cream Or Frozen Yogurt
1.00
Beverages
Cans / Bottles
Coke
Sprite
Orange Dream
Black Cherry
San Pellegrino: Blood Oj & Grapefruit
Diet
Root Beer
Cream Soda
Ginger Ale
Juices: Apple & Pomegranate-Cherry
Buy It By the Pound!
Turkey Breast
15.95
Tender House-Cured Corned Beef
26.95
Genoa Salami
10.95
Egg Salad
6.95
Slow-Roasted Roast Beef
15.95
Kretschmer's Hickory Smoked Ham
10.50
Tuna Salad
11.95
Solid white albacore
Chicken Salad
9.95
Desserts
Always Homemade!
Cookies: Chocolate Chip Or Peanut Butter
1.95
Cheesecake
4.50
40 year old family recipe
Brownies
3.25
Chef Richie's Chocolate Insanity™
Chef Richie's Chocolate Insanity™
10.95
(Limited availability because it just takes so long to make!) Five different chocolate confections in one: Flourless chocolate cake with a, chocolate truffle filling, coated in a chocolate ganache, surrounded by a semi-sweet chocolate tower, and drizzled with white chocolate
Salads, Wiches & Stuff
Vegan Dressings: Mandarin Orange Vinaigrette, Italian, Balsamic Vinaigrette, & French
Vegan Garlic Bread
7.00
Baked with extra virgin olive oil, fresh garlic, and stuffed with vegan mozzarella cheese
Build Your Own Sandwich
See the build your own menu
Vegan Orange Salad
5.25
Fresh greens, Mandarin oranges, mushrooms, tomatoes, red onions, & walnuts, served with our homemade Mandarin orange vinaigrette
Vegan Delight Sandwich
8.50
Sriracha hummus, fresh mushrooms, cucumbers, spinach, carrots, tomato & red onion on 9-grain bread
Daddy Pack
Add Potato Chips, Pickle & Regular Fountain Drink +$2.76
Make Your Own Salad
5.95
Build it yourself at our salad bar
Vegan Pizza
Small - (serves 1-2); Medium - (serves 2-3); Large - (serves 4-5)
Vegan Spinach Special
20.50
Fresh Spinach, mushrooms, onions, & green peppers. (No substitutions, please!)
Make Your Own
14.50
Start with a vegan cheese pizza and add any additional vegan ingredients you'd like
Vegan Sausage Special
21.50
Vegan Sausage, fresh mushrooms, onions, & green peppers. (No substitutions, please!)
Additional Ingredient
1.95
Vegan Ingredients: Vegan Sausage (Charged as a premium ingredient) , Fresh Mushroom, Onion, Green Pepper, Giardiniera, Jalapeno, Garlic, Black Olive, Green Olive, Artichoke (Charged as a premium ingredient) , Fresh Spinach, Fresh Tomato, Pineapple, Extra Cheese; 1/2 Ingredient Charged as 75% of additional ingredient price
Build Your Own Vegan Sandwich
$8.50
Step 1: Bread
Choose one: French, Rye 9-Grain, Focaccia (+$0.50)
Step 3: Dressing
Hummus, Dijon, Italian, Brown Mustard, Yellow Mustard, Balsamic Vin, Sriracha Hummus
Step 2: Veggies
Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Cucumber, Spinach, Green pepper, Broccoli, Corn Mushroom, Sauerkraut, Carrot, Kalamata Olive, Black Olive, Bl. Bean, Hominy, Pickles, Sauerkraut, Giardiniera (+$0.50) , Red pepper (+$0.50) , Roasted Veggies, Pineapple
Optional Daddy Pack
Add Potato Chips, Pickle & Reg. Fountain Drink +$2.76
Li'l Guys
Li'l Guys are delicatessen mini-sandwich. They are served on our special roll. Figure 2-3 Li'l Guys per person depending on your catering needs
Turkey Breast
All natural turkey breast
Corned Beef
Cured on the premises for 7 days, slowly cooked for over 7 hours
Ham
Kretschmer's hickory smoked ham
Egg Salad
Gently tossed so it's devilishly tasty
Roast Beef
Tender, homemade & slow-roasted
Salami
Genoa aged salami
Tuna Salad
Simple and superb, solid white albacore and Hellman's mayo, the best!
Chicken Salad
Slow-roasted chicken breast with Granny Smith apples, nuts & mayo
Catering Packs
Li'l guys come on their own disposable 18" black serving platter with color coded toothpicks. *Tuna, Roast Beef or Turkey +$0.20 extra/sandwich. Corned Beef +$0.75 extra/sandwich
The 30-Pack
105.95
30 Li'l Guy Sandwiches*, served on one platter, Choice of 2 sides (1 quart each) , 15 chocolate chip cookies
Do It Yourself Platter
68.75
25 platter (Choice of 25 Li'l Guy Sandwiches*, sauces on the side, & platter)
The Big 50
191.95
50 Li'l Guy Sandwiches*, served on two platters, Choice of 2 sides (2 quarts each) , 25 chocolate chip cookies
Lunch Boxes
Great for field trips. Comes with utensils, napkins & served in an individual lunch box. Minimum 10 lunch boxes. *Tuna, Roast Beef or Turkey +$0.20 extra/sandwich. Corned Beef +$0.75 extra/sandwich
2 Pack Lunch Box
9.85
Your choice of 2 Li'l Guys, your choice of a single serving side dish or chips chocolate chip cookie
3 Pack Lunch Box
12.45
Your choice of 3 Li'l Guys, your choice of a single serving side dish or chips, chocolate chip cookie
Side Dishes
That's right, we make 'em right here!
Traditional Potato Salad
5.70
Our special version of the mayo / mustard classic with eggs, celery, et al
Pesto Penne
5.70
Penne with pesto, mozzarella, & sun-dried tomatoes
Pasta Salad
5.70
Tri-color rotini, balsamic vinaigrette, feta, kalamata olives, & red onions
Salad Bowls
Feeds 10-15 people. For more options see our regular menu
Dinner Salad
31.95
Combination of seasonal fresh greens topped with carrots, cucumbers, tomatoes, croutons, and your choice of dressing
Caesar Salad
31.95
Fresh greens with croutons and a traditional homemade Caesar dressing
Chef's Salad
36.95
Fresh greens, Roasted turkey, Kretschmar's hickory smoked ham, cheddar cheese, cucumbers, tomatoes & hard-boiled eggs with your choice of dressing
Mandarin Orange Salad
36.95
Fresh greens, mandarin oranges, mushrooms, tomatoes, red onions, blue cheese & walnuts, served with our homemade mandarin orange vinaigrette
Cobb Salad
36.95
Tomatoes, chicken breast, eggs, blue cheese, & bacon on bed of fresh greens with your choice of dressing
Homemade Desserts
40 Fudgy Brownie Bites
32.50
20 Mini Chocolate Chip Cookies
19.50
10 Chocolate Chip Cookies
19.50
Salads & Stuff
Dressings: French, 1000 Island, Ranch, Creamy Garlic, Blue Cheese, Mandarin Orange Vinaigrette, Italian, Balsamic Vinaigrette, Lite Ranch. Extra Dressing $0.75; Caesar Dressing $0.95
My Pi Mozzarella Garlic Bread
6.25
Baked with creamy whipped butter, fresh garlic, and stuffed with mozzarella cheese
Dinner Salad
5.25
Combination of seasonal fresh greens topped with carrots, cucumbers, tomatoes, croutons, and your choice of dressing
Caesar Salad
7.95
Fresh greens with croutons and a traditional homemade Caesar dressing
Chef's Salad
9.95
Roasted turkey, Kretschmar's hickory smoked ham, cheddar cheese, cucumbers, tomatoes & hard-boiled eggs on a bed of lettuce with your choice of dressing
Spicy Garlic Bread
3.50
Our open-faced cheesy garlic bread with a spice to it!
Mandarin Orange Salad
9.95
Fresh greens, Mandarin oranges, mushrooms, tomatoes, red onions, blue cheese & walnuts, served with our homemade Mandarin orange vinaigrette
Cobb Salad
9.95
Tomatoes, chicken breast, eggs, blue cheese, & bacon on bed of fresh greens with your choice of dressing
Pizza
Ingredients: Sausage, Pepperoni, Canadian Bacon, Hamburger, Cheeseburger (Charged as a premium ingredient) (Cheddar & Hamburger), Chicken Breast (Charged as a premium ingredient), Ham, Roast Beef, Anchovy, Mushroom, Onion, Green Peppers, Giardiniera, Jalapenos, Garlic, Black Olive, Green Olive, Artichokes (Charged as a premium ingredient), Fresh Spinach, Fresh Tomato, Pineapple, Extra cheese
Deep Dish
unique pizza in the pan
Cheese
13.50
Any Additional Ingredient
2.15
1/2 Ingredient Charged as 75% of additional ingredient price
Thin Crust
Cracker thin!
Cheese
12.50
Any Additional Ingredient
1.95
1/2 Ingredient Charged as 75% of additional ingredient price
Specialty Pizza
My Pi Special
18.50
Sausage or Pepperoni or Spinach with mushrooms, onions, & green peppers. No substitutions, Please!
Chicken Pesto Pizza
17.25
Slow-roasted all-natural chicken breast chunks, fresh baby spinach, My Pi's signature tomato sauce, mozzarella, grated Romano, & fresh, homemade basil pesto drizzled on top
Hawaiian Pizza
16.40
A classic combination! Kretchmar's hickory smoked ham and pineapple with My Pi's signature tomato sauce, mozzarella, & grated Romano cheese
Stuffed Spinach Souffle
19.95
Fresh chopped baby spinach & mozzarella filling stuffed between two crusts, with twice the cheese of our deep dish pizza!
White Pizza
Four-Cheese
14.75
Mozzarella, provolone, bleu cheese, & Romano with a basil-pesto sauce brushed over our crispy thin crust
Sun-Dried Tomato
16.25
Sun-dried tomatoes, mozzarella, provolone, & Romano cheese with our basil-pesto sauce brushed over our crispy thin crust
Modern Art Pizza
17.95
Artichokes, fresh tomato, garlic & mozzarella with our basil-pesto sauce brushed over our crispy thin crust
Pizza Slices
Cheese
3.50
Pepperoni
3.95
Sausage
3.95
Deep Dish Slice of the Day
$4.50
Monday - Onion & Green Pepper
Wednesday - Mushroom
Friday - Mushroom
Sunday - Chef's Special
Tuesday - Spinach
Thursday - Spinach
Saturday - Spinach
Soup
Always Homemade! Call to ask which 2 soups are available. We serve only 2 soups daily. These soups are served in the following order:
Shrimp & Sweet Potato Chowder
3.95
Every Friday! An original! Classic shrimp chowder with real chunks of shrimp in a creamy broth with sweet potatoes & cayenne pepper to give it a sweet spiciness, finished with a touch of bacon & sherry
Tomato-Basil
3.45
Made from fresh tomatoes & basil
New England Clam Chowder
3.45
The creamy one
Baked Potato Soup
3.45
Baking the potatoes brings out their rich flavor. Indulge yourself
Cream of Mushroom
3.45
A 40 year old family recipe
Broccoli
3.45
Fresh broccoli in a French veloute
Chicken Noodle
3.45
Made from a homemade chicken stock
Portabella Posole
3.45
Another Li'l Guys original! A vegetable chili broth with portabella mushrooms, hominy, corn, & black beans. Such spicy flavor & healthy for you, too!
French Onion
3.45
Onions are slowly simmered for hours
Chili
3.95
Beefy version with beans
Minestrone
3.45
Classic Italian soup
Corn Chowder
3.45
A light chowder with sparkling corn flavor
Real Fruit Smoothies
Our smoothies are fat-free and all-natural! Made from 100 % real fruit and juice, no mixes or fillers. Try one, you'll love it! Smoothie Add-Ons: Protein shot add $0.75, With Ice cream or frozen yogurt add $1
Strawberry, Banana, & Juice
4.75
Your choice of orange, apple, or pineapple juice
Strawberry, Raspberry, & Juice
5.25
Your choice of orange, apple, or pineapple juice
Peach, Banana, & Juice
4.75
Your choice of orange, apple, or pineapple juice
Make Your Own!
Pick 2 fruits & a juice
Strawberry, Blueberry, & Juice
5.25
Your choice of orange, apple, or pineapple juice
Blueberry, Banana, & Juice
5.25
Your choice of orange, apple, or pineapple juice
Mango, Banana, & Juice
4.75
Your choice of orange, apple, or pineapple juice
Beverages
Available in Cans / Bottles
Coke
Sprite
Orange Dream
Black Cherry
San Pellegrino
Blood OJ & Grapefruit
Diet
Root Beer
Cream Soda
Ginger Ale
Juices
Apple & Pomegranate-Cherry
Desserts
Always Homemade!
Chocolate Chip Cookies
1.95
Brownies
3.25
Chef Richie's Chocolate Insanity
10.95
Limited availability because it just takes so long to make! Five different Chocolate Confections in one: Flourless chocolate cake with a chocolate truffle filling, coated in a chocolate ganache, surrounded by a semi-sweet chocolate tower, and drizzled with white chocolate
Peanut Butter Cookies
1.95
Cheesecake
4.50
30 year old family recipe
The logo for our menu provider

Disclaimer: Always check with the business for pricing and availability of menu items. SinglePlatform is not responsible for menu or pricing changes, but the information is believed to be accurate when posted. Listing of a menu does not mean that there is any affiliation, endorsement or sponsorship between SinglePlatform and the listed business.

Problem with this menu?

Related Searches

  • my pie pizza & li'l guys sandwiches chicago •
  • my pie pizza & li'l guys sandwiches chicago photos •
  • my pie pizza & li'l guys sandwiches chicago location •
  • my pie pizza & li'l guys sandwiches chicago address •
  • my pie pizza & li'l guys sandwiches chicago •
  • li'l guys chicago •
  • lil guys chicago •
  • my pie pizza & li'l guys sandwiches chicago •
  • my pie pizza & lil guys sandwiches chicago •
  • my pie pizza and li'l guys sandwiches chicago •
  • my pie pizzeria chicago •
  • my pie pizzeria-bucktown chicago •
  • my pie pizzeriabucktown chicago •
  • my pie pizza & li'l guys sandwiches bucktown chicago

Foursquare © 2025  Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA

Compass icon
My Pie Pizza & Li'l Guys Sandwiches
2010 N Damen Ave (at Armitage Ave.)
Chicago, IL 60647
United States
Get directions
Information icon
Deep Dish Pizza
Clock icon
Open until 9:00 PM (Show more)
  • Mon–Sun
    • 11:00 AM–9:00 PM
Phone icon
(773) 394-6900
World Wide Web icon
Facebook icon
MyPiPizzaChicago
Twitter icon
@mypipizzachi
Venue icon
Order from delivery.com
Features
Reservations
No
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. Discover & Visa)
Outdoor Seating
Yes
See More

You might also like

Places people like to go after My Pie Pizza & Li'l Guys Sandwiches

Appears on 83 lists

See all

Top places in the area

United States » Illinois » Cook County » Chicago » Bucktown

Is this your business? Claim it now.

Make sure your information is up to date. Plus use our free tools to find new customers.