Molly's Cupcakes
Cupcake Shop and Café$$$$
West Village, New York
The cupcakes at Molly's Cupcakes is a can't miss
"Creme Brulee cupcake, holy cow!! Amazing!"(13 Tips)
"Delicious creme brûlée, lemon meringue and peach cobbler."(23 Tips)
"You must try the Crème brûlée cupcake"(13 Tips)
"The cake batter cupcake is hands down the best cupcake in existence."(9 Tips)
249 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- cupcakes
- creme brûlée
- desserts
- peach cobbler
- cake
- (15 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
One of my top 5 favorite go-to cupcakes shop, this place offers moist cupcakes with cream-filling centers. Not overly sweetly but just right. The creme brulee cupcake is a must try!
Amy ThaiJuly 3, 2013felt like a little kid again looking at retro lunch boxes on the wall, eating cupcakes, and playing on a swing set. the cake batter aka birthday cake is their best seller.
Paige CJune 22, 2018I was so surprised how easy it was to place an order for such beautiful, extravagant cupcakes! They were not only gorgeous, but delicious! Highly recommend this bakery!
The Corcoran GroupAugust 9, 2013The cupcakes here are unbelievably amazing. Customize your own by choosing from a variety of cakes, fillings, frostings and toppings. Our favorite still remains the Cake Batter filled cupcakes.
Best cupcakes in New York! Airy, light frosting with a decadent cream filling over a perfectly cooked cake. Don’t miss the birthday cake, flourless chocolate or carrot cake w cream cheese frosting.
Andrea MansfieldApril 14, 2013Great job with 48 birthday cupcakes yesterday! Thank you to all at Molly's, the entire process from ordering through delivery went perfectly. The best part was the cupcakes were fresh and delicious!
Irina TDecember 20, 2019Popped in here after a show at Minetta. We had the salted caramel chocolate & raspberry chocolate - both were moist & very flavorful. Looking forward to coming back for more!
Nic GMarch 24, 2017coconut macadamia cupcake is outrageous. so is the butterscotch cupcake and the berry cupcake. i've never experienced such amazing cupcakes before.
Serious EatsApril 19, 2013The Crème Brûlée cupcake is a standout, outfitted with a glorious caramelized sugar top in place of frosting. Take that first bite and out oozes cool vanilla bean custard.
Alexandra TritzAugust 12, 2016I took a mini vanilla cupcake just to taste because I wasn't really hungry and it was delicious ! The vanilla cake was moist and the vanilla buttercream was airy and delicious !
Julia LuJune 3, 2021One of the best cupcakes ive had! So moist and sweet. I like the rasberry chocolate and strawberry shortcake
Brandon BrowneMay 5, 2014By far best cupcakes in the city. Cake Batter, Salted Caramel Chocolate, Creme Brûlée, Cookie Dough - so many must-try flavors
The Peach Cobbler is the best and the Cookie Monster is the second best
Alex CancelApril 20, 2013The chocolate rasberry and strawberry shortcake are amazing. The strawberry shortcake was so fresh and light, while the rasberry had a surprisingly strong flavor in the chocolate cupcake. Must haves!- Signs VisualJune 8, 2016Enjoy cupcakes such as the beloved classic chocolate or the peanut butter nutella—a peanut butter cake, nutella filling, nutella buttercream frosted, with a dusting of cocoa http://www.SignsVisual.com
Alice ChaoAugust 31, 2018The peach cobbler is my favorite cupcake. If you don't see it or others just ask they have them in the back
Tom FlemingAugust 13, 2014OMG!!! Lemon meringue cupcake is amazing!!! this place has the coolest staff all jamming to awesome music. And you can play connect 4 while chomping down deliciousness!
Sam McCrimsonJune 11, 2015Finally, delicious cupcakes where they put a flavorful ganache or purée in the center of the cupcake. It's prime real estate so it was bound to happen...- Stephanie SharplessJanuary 3, 2018Creme Brulee cupcake, holy cow!! Amazing! So far everything I've tried has been delicious
Get a few flavors and share with friends! I'd get Ron Bennington again and liked salted caramel butterscotch. Chocolate mousse wasn't that interesting
Village VoiceAugust 15, 2014Molly’s offers flavors from Peach Cobbler to Mint Velvet, including a few vegan options, all of which can be customized (think sprinkles) at the condiment bar. Read more
Berk KapiciogluOctober 21, 2015It's a cute, family and kid friendly cupcake store in the village. Once you enter it, you feel like you are in some sort of safe zone.
Jessica de OliveiraDecember 8, 2015Cupcakes are light and fluffy as air and so much fun sitting down and sifting through the selection of board games lined along the walls.
By far the best cupcakes I've ever tasted. They have a certain moistness other shops don't come close to. The Boston Creme is my favorite.
ImSo_BrooklynAugust 10, 2014Love the place! The swing seats are beautiful and unique. Love the school like theme inside! And the cupcakes are delicious!
Yvette LiuSeptember 13, 2015Cream Brule cupcake is amazing! Love how they have all kinds of flavors ❤️❤️❤️
Christine YipJanuary 25, 2014Such a cute place! Swing seats and board games available for you to play with! First time here and I had a creme brulee cupcake. YUMMY!
Wejdan ✨February 21, 2017Nice cupcake shop. The chocolate filling was perfect, not heavy at all. The cake seems like it absorbed all the moisture from the filling, taking the liner off without messing the cake was a struggle
Sara MarcosNovember 27, 2017Vegan chocolate cupcake is the best !!! Cruelty free and delicious :) loved this place
Adam RedstoneDecember 6, 2016Nailed the classic cupcake. Chocolate cake with vanilla frosting (super classic) ftw 💯
Jaine Catalasan-MaglanqueJanuary 11, 2014Coconut Macadamia Cupcake. I like the cupcakes in Molly's more than Magnolia Bakery, Baked by Melissa or Buttercup. Just the right sweetness and texture
Joshua NessNovember 15, 2011Winner of Cupcake Wars for a reason. Best cupcakes in town. Also has coffee, espresso, and a sprinkles bar in case your chosen cake didn't come with enough. Good music and friendly staff.
Ina LiFebruary 12, 2015Try the Creme brûlée and blueberry cheese cake. Not so much a cupcake person but I fell for those!
Sarah AtwoodOctober 12, 2015The Pumpkin Spice Cupcake is a work of art. Best cupcake I've ever had by far!
For all you people who avoid cupcakes coz of the fattening icings. The Creme Brulee cupcake is just brilliant. I have had that atleast 50 times till now.
Lisa RodriguezJuly 6, 2018I’m not a fan of cupcakes, but I have to say that the peach cobbler cupcake is pretty good!
- Desiree GJune 6, 2015Delicious creme brûlée, lemon meringue and peach cobbler. Come early drink a chai latte and play connect four!
Heather PopilAugust 19, 2014One of my favorite spots in the west village. Adorable swings, kid games, amazing cupcakes and cappuccinos!
MandiNovember 23, 2013This place is delicious!! Cupcakes taste homemade...lots of great flavors (try the chocolate peanut butter). Good coffee too!!
honeywhatscooking.comJanuary 13, 2016Tried the Cookie Monster. Hmm.. it's really good, moist. Love the cookie dough filling inside. Pretty basic tho, I wasn't quite blown away.
- Susan J CampbellOctober 27, 2015The cake batter cupcake is hands down the best cupcake in existence. And I am an expert. And you can buy frosting shots!
Cynthia LinNovember 30, 2021Great flavors. Usually a chocolate peanut butter desserter but the apple cupcake was just too good
Dominik FJuly 3, 2015All the different cupcakes and cookies look sooooo good!!! The one I had was a Nutella cream cupcake... Delicious!!!
Omg people weren't exaggerating when they said the creme brûlée cupcake was a godsend. IT IS AMAZING! I devoured it before I could take a photo...
Amazing cupcakes in NYC. Pick a cupcake and add any amount of frosting. I add just a little.
1,055 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Open until 10:00 PM (Show more)
- Mon
- Noon–10:00 PM
- Tue–Thu
- 8:00 AM–10:00 PM
- Fri–Sat
- 8:00 AM–Midnight
- Sun
- 9:00 AM–10:00 PM
(212) 414-2253
Features
Reservations
No
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. American Express)
Wi-Fi
Yes
Outdoor Seating
No
See More
You might also like
- 7.7
"These cupcakes are amazing. Worth every penny!"
Steven Longobardi - 8.2
"I ordered a custom tiered banana cake with cream cheese frosting for birthday party and it was delicious!!! Staff are also very friendly and helpful."
Bron Holmes - 7.4
"All the pastries are so delicious. I'm going to gain weight working near such good bakeries. Bubble tea is expensive though $5"
Nessa Nguyen
Places people like to go after Molly's Cupcakes
- 9.5
"Always an amazing mix of people and entertainment. One of my fav spots to lay in summer."
Barton Smith - 9.1
"This theater screens some of the best in independent cinema. It also screens great anime from time to time, both new and classic. It's a great place to catch great films."
Chris Raghoobar - 9.0
"Has such a wide variety of beans. Can get beans for iced coffee and espresso. My favorite regular coffee beans are the Black & Tan and the Tanzanian Peaberry"
Gabriel Hayes
Appears on 785 lists
Created by Cupcakes Take The Cake
44 items • 106 followers
Created by Soundz Org
203 items • 77 followers
Created by Skye K.
200 items • 88 followers
