John's Pizzeria
Pizzeria and Italian Restaurant$$$$
Theater District, New York
The experts at The Corcoran Group and New York Habitat recommend this place
"Actually the best pizza in NYC."(10 Tips)
"Great atmosphere and wonderful NY style pizza."(4 Tips)
"Try the Traditional Pizza - Some of the best pizza I've had."(5 Tips)
"Half Margherita, half Traditional pie-- the best!!!"(13 Tips)
315 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- pizza
- good for groups
- casual
- good for dates
- calzones
- (15 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
IOANNA SOULAHAKIApril 8, 2016The food is ok, mostly the pizza since the pasta was not impressive. The important thing is that the stuff is rude without paying attention to customers...
Jo GrazideMay 31, 2013The waiter we had had no finesse. he asked my husband's order first then reached a across us w.o. excusing himself. Other than that the food is so good u put up w NYC rudeness right?
Elliott C.April 8, 2011Lunch for two is no prob getting seated. Billy the bartender is the friendliest guy in this joint.
30 Minutes Or LessJuly 1, 2011This pizza parlor serves the whole pie, so #DontBlowIt by asking for just a slice.
marjolijn kamphuisMarch 21, 2011Enjoying that delicious pizza? Check your food in on Foodzy.com to stay fit!
Gregory VillanoNovember 11, 2013Wow. This used to be a church... Guess I'm breaking bread again today
Aki TykkiSeptember 11, 2012Pizzas not as good as expected, but they're okay. Prosciutto chunks were extremely salty, should've taken some pineapple with them. Nice atmosphere though.
Alexis RollinJuly 13, 2011Arrived at 8:40. Waiting time : less than 10mn. Just avoid peak hours before theater !
Doe ZagatMarch 18, 2010This place had great food. The pizza by the pie and not by the slice. Grab a salad also.
Vicki GambleDecember 28, 2010The place reminds me of the Spaghetti Factory except that SF has good food.
Marisa GreenMarch 11, 2010The "default" pizzas are very low on cheese - you might want to ask for extra as a topping, if you like a positive ration of cheese to sauce.- AdaMarcomDecember 18, 2009Their pizzas are one of the best in Manhattan; love the restaurant atmosphere
Bobby HarrisJune 1, 2011Just learned if u sit in the lobby.. All the folks leaving for shows give u food!!
Mandy VDecember 17, 2012Ridiculous that they can't seat us when 8 out of 9 of us are here during lunch!
Erika GravatoDecember 2, 2010They absolutely do accept credit cards. I was there a few weeks ago and paid with Visa.
Faith KastenAugust 9, 2011They do not service Pizza by the slice. The Pizza was good. Disappointed that they do not have garlic powder. The atmosphere was nice and it is a renovated church.
Good pies, but over priced and they rush you to turn tables!
Kristina SJanuary 12, 2020Good pizza! Service was lacking and pizza honestly took forever to come. :/
1,147 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Open until 11:30 PM (Show more)
- Mon–Sun
- 11:30 AM–11:30 PM
(212) 391-7560
View menu on https://www.johnspizzerianyc.com/menu
Features
Reservations
Groups Only
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. American Express)
Outdoor Seating
Yes
Food & Drink
Menus
Brunch, Lunch, Dinner, Happy Hour
Drinks
Beer, Wine, Full Bar, Cocktails
See More
You might also like
- 8.7
"Excellent pizza. Great for sitting down and sharing a whole pie or ordering a single slice from their to-go window."
Jon hoffman - 8.9
"Our favorite spot for a slice. Coal-fired-brick-oven-cheese-&-sausage-light-sauce. Yum!! Line out the door moves quickly, so get in it."
Renee T - 8.2
"Great atmosphere. Try the meatballs and a pizza -- the imported mozzarella is delicious."
Amber R.
Places people like to go after John's Pizzeria
Appears on 782 lists
Created by New York Habitat
76 items • 735 followers
101 places to see in Manhattan before you die
Created by Victor Garrido
101 items • 947 followers
Created by D
161 items • 213 followers
