See all
41 photos

Jimmy's Seafood Buffet

Seafood Restaurant and Buffet$$$$

Kitty Hawk

Save

5.1^/10

ratings

"Good food, great crab legs, but cramped."(10 Tips)
"$30 for all you can eat Alaskan, Canadian, and stone crab."(2 Tips)
"Atmosphere leaves some to be desired as it’s crowded."(3 Tips)
"They advertised pony rides but there was no pony."(2 Tips)

30 Tips and reviews

Filter:

cheesecake
staff
crowded
dinner
beach

Sort:

Popular
Recent

BrianJuly 15, 2014
Great selection of food. Exceeded my expectations. Come on Monday for the free lobster tail. Don't forget to ask your server for it. Also call ahead to get your name on the wait list.
Kevin MaloneJuly 25, 2013
Call ahead to get your name in the list. First time having crab legs and enjoyed them. Didn't try the "to order" steaks. Drinks strong and even with the souvenir cup expensive LIT & daq $24
C HJuly 9, 2018
TONS of crab leg choices. Food is good, more seafood choices than most seafood buffets. Atmosphere leaves some to be desired as it’s crowded.
Chuck BJuly 14, 2012
Food is delicious. Staff is very friendly and attentive. Every dish was fresh and the kitchen staff does an excellent job making sure it stays fresh.
Chris S. CornellAugust 7, 2011
Been here 10+ times
We come to Jimmy's at least once every time we're in the Outer Banks. Crab legs, crab legs and more crab legs. You don't come here for the ambiance.
Mariah NicoleJune 16, 2012
Place was great. Crowded and they don't take reservations but make sure you call 30 mins ahead and they will get you in quick.
Cindy UMay 28, 2011
The food was overpriced, and it was cramped in there, but the food was pretty good and the service was great. Everything we ate was fresh, crablegs were excellent.
Nick GavioJuly 14, 2011
Good food, great crab legs, but cramped. There's usually a long wait, but they have cornhole beanbags, mini golf, and pony rides to stay busy.
Doug MeekinsAugust 16, 2011
Best Buffet on the Beach along with the best staff. It all adds up to a good time.
Corey ClaytonJuly 12, 2011
If u just want crab legs, and lots of them, and can ignore the long wait, lawn chair furniture seats, cramped dining room, and sub-par buffet standards, then this is your place. Our server was 5-star!
Barbara PhillipsJuly 20, 2017
Snow crabs, Stoned Crabs were good
Terri BrionSeptember 11, 2011
Not the most modern of places & a bit pricey...but good food, good atmosphere & a very hot waiter !
JayhawkAugust 1, 2011
They no longer are able to carry king crab legs. They were good last time we were here! Plenty of other crabs to try.
VictorOctober 8, 2017
It's all about the crab!
Daneel WatsonJuly 16, 2011
$30 for all you can eat Alaskan, Canadian, and stone crab. Not a bad deal considering what you pay per pound elsewhere. The rest of the buffet ain't that great. Go after 8:30 to skip the wait.
Ben HaubrichMay 25, 2012
Expensive, but good for the seafood, if that's what your here for. If you don't eat seafood though, you're out of luck baby.
Megan UncapherJuly 4, 2012
It's OKAY.. not the greatest. Service was good. But if you aren't a seafood person like I am.. I don't recommend it at all. It's a bit jammed too. Oh well..
Anthony L.June 15, 2011
Is overpriced but the food is good. Cheesecake is the best too
Heather GarrettSeptember 1, 2013
Come for the crab legs...nothing else
Kari BishopJune 13, 2012
Best seafood there is.
Jason H.July 12, 2012
This white gurl in a blue T-shirt that's a waitress PHAT as heck
Brian HarrJuly 22, 2010
Whoa, if you think the outside is bad wait until you get inside. An all you can eat crap buffet with customers that makes the people at Walmart at 10pm look sophisticated. KEEP DRIVING!
Rachel J.July 25, 2012
Not worth the $30 per adult. Great crab legs & decent buffet food, just not worth the price. Desserts were not good. Very crowded, long wait time
Dane FergusonAugust 20, 2012
Ehhh this place is half decent...probably could find a much better place in the area then again, could probably find worse. You be the judge.
Brian HarrJuly 21, 2010
They advertised pony rides but there was no pony. They advertised putt putt and there is only one hole. No balls...just rocks. Real classy.
Stephen NegrichJuly 4, 2012
Its ok at best, good service but the food leaves allot to be desired...
Keith GosnellSeptember 23, 2012
Horrible...food was cold..lettuce was brown...sliders like hockey pucks..way overpriced for the quality...avoid like the plague!
StefAugust 19, 2010
My family loves this place but I think it is overpriced and awful. Last time I was there, I was shoved in a back corner and couldn't even get up to get my food. Not recommended.
Tyler OberholzerJune 28, 2011
Food was marginal wait was extraordinarily long and 30$ per person wouldn't recommend
Alan LaytonJuly 12, 2011
Adults $30?!? And drinks not included. It's crazy, hot & not good. Skip it.

41 Photos

Jimmy's Seafood Buffet

Related Searches

You might also like

Places people like to go after Jimmy's Seafood Buffet

Appears on 2 lists

Is this your business? Claim it now.