Jimmy's Island Grill & Iguana Bar
Caribbean Restaurant, Hotel Bar, and American Restaurant$$$$
Wauwatosa
"Comfy chairs and loved the newbie special!!"(2 Tips)
"Try the Key Lime Martini with graham cracker rimmed glass."(2 Tips)
"Great drinks & lovely outdoor patio with REAL sand."(3 Tips)
"The Jerk Chicken sandwich is amazing here!"(3 Tips)
44 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- good for groups
- outdoor seating
- casual
- great value
- comfortable seats
- (14 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Haven't had a bad thing on the menu. Service and hospitality has always been 1st rate as well. Glad to call this place my spot!!
Tyler BargMay 6, 2018Solid atmosphere with the right amount of noise, rock solid burgers and enjoyable drinks. Outdoor patio is glorious in the summer!- Kathryn HallMay 18, 2014Very cool place. Makes you feel like you're in Key West! Great drinks & lovely outdoor patio with REAL sand. :)
My crew always stops in here for dinner at least a couple of times while we are in town. Our last visit, the waitresses seemed as though they were rushing to get us out. Service wasn't as good.
Ambience rules! There's even a beach and fire pit outside.
Dan MatthiasJanuary 21, 2013Try the iguana caca shot-- not on the menu but Rhonda will hook you up. It's lizardlicious
Natalee DAugust 13, 2015Pretty much everything I have had is delicious! Feel free to be adventurous!
Need to have a last minute party? Sunday nights here are awesome for large parties
MyCommunityNOWApril 5, 2013
Allison and Jamie are always cheerful with a smile in the morning.
Our hosted kaitlyn was a sweetheart we asked to move twice and it was no problem.,,. Nice intro to the grill
Jonathan RSeptember 3, 2012Dont know what everyone else is complaining about. Service was great and the pizza was even better.
Katrina ScalesJanuary 13, 2012This was a great place, we enjoyed ourselves and the staff was great!!
- Great specials during the Packer game! $2 tap domestics, 25% off apps, 50% off pizzas!!
Nancy M.December 29, 2011Jimmy's Buffalo Shrimp was delish. However Angry is not too spicy, more buffaloish
Chris AbbeyMay 7, 2012The breakfast tickets from the hotel are a mixed blessing: you get a better menu, but worse service. They seem to not really care when they have a guaranteed tip from the hotel.
- Try the Key Lime Martini with graham cracker rimmed glass. Yum!
Christine PlatzerJuly 5, 2015The bartender and the drink she made is THE ONLY good thing about this place. Food was a disgrace to anything edible. Decor is awesome.
Gwynne C.September 14, 2012Meh. Walked in; no employee in sight. The woman who sat us was borderline rude, abrupt-not welcoming at all. Our server was nice & helpful. Food was nothing special. As a former server, not impressed.
RobDecember 9, 2011My service was terrific! The food on the other hand left something to be desired. Oysters were a bit frozen, The Cuban was bad, the fries were sub par, and the coleslaw was tasteless.
Nathan VehslageJune 2, 2013Worth the free beer special. Otherwise food was mediocre at best and the service was terrible. Grab the free drink and go somewhere else.
118 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Jimmy's Island Grill & Iguana Bar
2303 N Mayfair Rd
Wauwatosa, WI 53226
United States
Wauwatosa, WI 53226
United States
You'll love the laid back island atmosphere, food, and drink at Jimmy’s. Across from Mayfair. Breakfast, lunch and dinner.
Open until 11:00 PM (Show more)
- Mon
- 5:00 PM–11:00 PM
- Tue–Sat
- 11:00 AM–11:00 PM
(414) 837-2121
Features
Reservations
Yes
Wi-Fi
Yes
Outdoor Seating
Yes
Music
Live Music
TouchTunes Jukebox
Yes
Food & Drink
Menus
Brunch, Dinner, Happy Hour
Drinks
Beer, Full Bar, Cocktails
See More
You might also like
- 7.8
"Great beer selection; from the popular 'big box brands' to local micro brews. Something for every taste."
Kristine S - 8.6
"Tuesday wing night.... Medium sauce with Leinie's Sunset Wheat is my perfect flavor combo. 😋"
André Beaudot - 6.6
"Nice clean restaurant, modern decor, easy to get to and park, and good food (for fast food)."
Diane Kennedy
Places people like to go after Jimmy's Island Grill & Iguana Bar
- 7.1
"Mad Chicken! It’s absolutely worth the small wait! The wings are great and cooked perfectly! Portion sizes are fantastic!"
M Frejnik - 6.2
"Nick who loves Coffee was a great server. Very kind and made things better after getting food I didn't like. Highly recommended."
Shawn S - 8.7
"Wow, fish was very good and the Key Lime Cheesecake was amazing. Cheesecake will never be the same."
Sean Mondt
