Gatsby's On The Bay

Gatsby's On The Bay

(Now Closed)
New American Restaurant$$$$
Stapleton, Staten Island
Save
Share
Gatsby's On The Bay
Photos73 Photos
MenuMenu
Menu 4
S T a R T E R S
“The only time to eat diet food is while you’re waiting for the steak to cook” ~ Julia Child
Tartar
14
Spicy tuna, salmon, guacamole
Gatsby Tower
12
Sliced tomatos, fresh mozzarella, prosciutto, roasted peppers
Caesar Salad
9
Crisp romaine, croutons, parmesan, creamy garlic dressing
Gatsby Salad
9
Garden greens, crispy fried goat cheese, beets, candied walnuts
Mezze
12
Smoked eggplant puree, humus, herbed ricotta, pickled veggies, grilled flatbread
Soup of the Day
9
Seasonal, Chef's choice
Mussels
10
Chorizo, garlic & fresh herbs in white wine sauce
Mushroom Tart
10
Wild mushrooms, ricotta, truffle oil
Buratta
11
Pumpkin, tomato, beet, aged balsamic
Calamari
11
Fresh sliced rings & tentacles, fried hot cherry peppers
Lobster Meatball
12
Maine lobster, angus beef + bisque
Truffle Mac&Cheese
11
Elbow macaroni, three different cheeses
Main Dishes
"One can not think well, love well, sleep well, if one has not dined well" Virginia Woolf
Orrechhiette
19
Little ears, ground pork, broccoli rabe pesto
Ahi Tuna
29
Sesame crusted fresh tuna w/ market vegetables
Half Chicken
21
Semi-boneless all natural chicken+honey dijon
Pork Chops
28
Two 8oz pork chops, pear & fig in sangria wine sauce
Ribeye Steak
31
18oz boneless premium beef, sangria butter
Vegetable Tart
19
Market Vegetables, goat cheese, smoked tomato vinaigrette - Vegetarian
Surf & Turf
54
18oz Ribeye + 6oz lobster tail
Penne Pasta
17
Tomato, basil, parmesan
Spaghetti
24
Maine lobster, shrimps, mussels + arrabbiata
Atlantic Salmon
23
With salsa verde
Short Rib
28
Award winning! Angus beef with red wine jus
Whole Fish
26
Daily fresh fish with fennel & citrus
Eggplant Bowl
19
Fresh market vegetables with eggplant & herbs - Vegetarian
Beef Stroganoff
22
With wild mushroom sauce
Lamb Chops
26
Grilled to perfection with pomegranate sauce
S P E C I a L S
Mushroom Soup
9
Pilmeni
12
Chicken Kiev
21
Chaqapuli - Lamb Stew
24
Organic, grass-fed lamb slow cooked with tarragon, mint, scallions, parsley, cilantro & white wine, served with bread
Lobiani
13
Fresh closed faced dough stuffed with beans & herbs, baked in owen
Phkhali Assortment
13
Eggplant, spinach, bell pepper with ground walnuts, fresh herbs & Georgian spices, garnished with pomegranate seeds
Chqmeruli
21
Organic grass-fed Cornish hen oven roasted with a garlic & thyme pan sauce, served with bread
Perogi
11
Fresh Water Trout
24
Lamb Chops
26
Grilled to perfection with pomegranate sauce
Elarji Balls
11
Stone ground corn (Georgian grits) mixed with 2 types of cheeses, served with almond sauce
Khachapuri
13
Fresh closed faced dough stuffed with 3 kind of cheeses, baked in owen
Satsivi
21
Organic, grass-fed chicken cooked in walnut sauce & Georgian spices (Served cold) with Elarji Balls (served hot)
The logo for our menu provider

Disclaimer: Always check with the business for pricing and availability of menu items. Wix Restaurants is not responsible for menu or pricing changes, but the information is believed to be accurate when posted. Listing of a menu does not mean that there is any affiliation, endorsement or sponsorship between Wix Restaurants and the listed business.

Problem with this menu?

Related Searches

  • gatsby's on the bay staten island •
  • gatsby's on the bay staten island photos •
  • gatsby's on the bay staten island location •
  • gatsby's on the bay staten island address •
  • gatsby's on the bay staten island •
  • gatsby s on the bay staten island •
  • gatsby's on the bay staten island •
  • gatsbys on the bay staten island •
  • gatsby's on the bay stapleton staten island

Foursquare © 2025  Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA

Compass icon
Gatsby's On The Bay
695 Bay St
Staten Island, NY 10304
United States
Get directions
Clock icon
Permanently closed (Show more)
  • Tue–Thu, Sun
    • Noon–10:00 PM
  • Sat
    • 3:00 PM–Midnight
Phone icon
(718) 442-8729
World Wide Web icon
Facebook icon
gatsbys.onthebay
Features
Reservations
Yes
Wi-Fi
Free
Outdoor Seating
Yes
Wheelchair Accessible
Yes
Music
Live Music
Parking
Street, Private Lot, Valet
Restroom
Yes
Food & Drink
Menus
Brunch
Drinks
Full Bar, Cocktails
See More

You might also like

Appears on 17 lists

See all
United States » New York » Staten Island » Staten Island » Stapleton

Is this your business? Claim it now.

Make sure your information is up to date. Plus use our free tools to find new customers.