Start with the Mache Salad, grab a glass of the Syrah/Grenache blend and do not, I repeat, do not leave the building without ordering the Mint Chocolate ChipIce Cream Sandwich.
Dinner here was very much...mediocre. Farro salad was ok. Lamb meatballs weren't anything special. Potatoes were pretty good. Ill have to try brunch here since this is what they seem to specialize in.
BYOT. The three small wedges of heirloom tomato were ridiculous for the price and for a plate meant to share. Other than that we loved everything else about this place.
The Eveleigh embraces the original identity of the historic structure it inhabits: an intimate and unpretentious residence built upon an orchard in 1923.