See all
41 photos

Cosimo's

Italian Restaurant$$$$

Poughkeepsie

Save

Cosimo's

7.8^/10

ratings

"flat bread pizza to die for!"(5 Tips)
"Their menu is unique and their desserts are wonderful."(2 Tips)
"Try the pasta fagiole soup 🍜 and Chicken francaise!"(2 Tips)
"their flatbread brickoven pizza"(2 Tips)

19 Tips and reviews

Filter:

good for dates
desserts
chicken francaise
polenta
bread pudding
dinner
bar
meats
rice balls
lunch
(5 more)

Sort:

Popular
Recent

Carol EganDecember 23, 2014
Gluten free pizza crust is one of the best ever and we are from Brooklyn, the land of gluten free. Restaurant is absolutely beautiful and staff is great. We will be back again and again and again...
Upvoted Dec 18, 2024
JT TeranMarch 15, 2016
Cosimo's is known for their flatbread brickoven pizza which is out of this world. Their bar is pretty big and all the staff is very friendly. Definitely worth checking out.
Megan LandeApril 20, 2021
Been here 5+ times
Everything! From the amazing rice balls to that melt in your melt sea bass to all their desserts! And their drinks are my favorite!! I absolutely love this place!
LmtMay 13, 2018
Respectful of allergies. Wood fired red snapper very tasty... Brussels sprouts very soft/ overcooked. They also take away plates before all are finished & leave messy table between courses
Joe ConteJanuary 29, 2016
there's nothing on this menu that you wont like. try the polenta, or the calamari, and the nonna meatballs are killer!!!
Angela M. KancelerApril 27, 2013
Never had a bad meal there. Friendly staff makes you feel like family. Their menu is unique and their desserts are wonderful.
Jim TurnerMay 10, 2022
Been here 10+ times
Try the pasta fagiole soup 🍜 and Chicken francaise! Excellent 👍🏾👍🏾
Jason SifreJune 15, 2011
Cosimo's is bomb! You can't go wrong with just about anything on the menu. Free app with a check-in with 3 friends!
Rachel BindelApril 20, 2016
Food was good. A little pricy but the portions were huge
Deanna Magnani MoriartyMarch 12, 2015
Love it here! Great food and drinks!
Shana SandroffMay 23, 2012
Great food always...especially the bread pudding...mmmm!
Em MarshJuly 27, 2014
They've changed the formula for the broccoli rabe w/sausage. Now, it tastes like chode and canned sausage. Sat us directly under air conditioner in near empty restaurant. Ugh.
Em MarshJuly 27, 2014
Two flies are mating on my table, as I type this. Classy.
Amy ParkerOctober 28, 2013
Friendly atmosphere - closes at 11, which is late for this area. Red pasta sauce is VERY salty. Food is mediocre for being all "fresh" and "made in-house." Way too expensive for what you're getting.
Dianna JohnsonJuly 7, 2015
The food isn't bad, but it used to be better. I've had just about everything on the menu.
Rachel MarabellJanuary 4, 2014
Pizza is amazing!
JimmyApril 6, 2014
Food was amazing
barbara annunziataMarch 25, 2011
Been here 50+ times
flat bread pizza to die for!
Mary RitterAugust 14, 2010
Specialty Pizza at the bar never disappoints

41 Photos

Cosimo's

Related Searches

You might also like

Places people like to go after Cosimo's

Appears on 16 lists

Is this your business? Claim it now.