Cafe Fiesta

(Now Closed)

Mexican Restaurant$$$$

Highland Mills

Save

Cafe Fiesta

12 Tips and reviews

Sort:

Jason HeydApril 25, 2015
Best Mexican I've had in a LONG time. Awesome food all around for a party of six, huge portions, and my daughter ordered a second round of tacos. Definitely coming back.
Susan RannestadMarch 4, 2015
Been here 10+ times
Best Mexican in area. Even makes my non Mexican eating husband up something off menu!!!
LexusJune 13, 2011
Been here 10+ times
Best. Food. Ever. Nothing has ever been bad. Amazing local place. The orange sauce that is on quesadillas & burritos is the best ever.
Katie LeonickMarch 15, 2016
Enchiladas in the red sauce are the way to go!
Lorraine LoeningJune 23, 2013
Been here 50+ times
Ask for jalapeños with everything. Yummer
Karen HilbergOctober 27, 2017
Burrito dinner and iced tea was great!
Julian NealJune 16, 2012
Been here 10+ times
Plates are HOT! Beware, my Mexican cuisine eating compadres!
Marghi QuigleyMarch 3, 2013
Love the steak ranchero!
Yesenia KoppermanJuly 5, 2014
Best salsa
Sarah EllenMarch 15, 2012
Best salsa n chips everrrrr!
Cristo LeonSeptember 11, 2015
Tacos en su maxima expresion. Tip los lunes son $1 x taco wow! Ademas la salsa estilo Guadalajara no tiene perdon
Marghi QuigleyMay 5, 2013
Happy Cinco de Mayo!!!

20 Photos

Cafe Fiesta

547 State Route 32
Highland Mills, NY 10930
United States

Welcome to Cafe Fiesta, the family-friendly home of incredibly delicious Mexican food in Highland Mills, New York!

Permanently closed (Show more)

(845) 928-2151

Features

Credit Cards

Yes

Outdoor Seating

Food & Drink

Menus

Brunch, Happy Hour

United States » New York » Orange County » Highland Mills »

Make sure your information is up to date. Plus use our free tools to find new customers.