See all
36 photos

AJ's NY Pizzeria

Pizzeria$$$$

Downtown Manhattan, Manhattan

Save

AJ's NY Pizzeria

7.1^/10

ratings

Ranked #4 for pizzerias in Manhattan
"quality toppings make this the best pizza in town!"(2 Tips)
"Great pizza, try the AJ's grilled cheese."(3 Tips)
"My margarita pizza barely had any cheese"(2 Tips)
"Try Monday's, they have 50 cent beers!"(3 Tips)

27 Tips and reviews

Filter:

pizza
grilled cheese sandwiches
great value
cheese pies
good service
casual
beer
handmade
brick oven
garlic knots
lunch
dough
dinner
parking
(9 more)

Sort:

Popular
Recent

Nicole GomezSeptember 17, 2012
Been here 10+ times
Fresh handmade dough (not the frozen crap that most restaurants use) cooked in their brick oven, great sauce, fresh veggies, and quality toppings make this the best pizza in town!
Shawn LaneAugust 7, 2014
Been here 10+ times
The Manhattan Margherita is my go-to here almost every time.
Brandi BruceNovember 5, 2017
Been here 10+ times
Salads are huge but delicious
robin taylorApril 14, 2012
Great pizza, try the AJ's grilled cheese. Just stay out bathrooms...they stink
John NeillJune 30, 2014
I love this place and come all the time. If you like good service this is not the place for you. They forget your order, bring you the wrong thing-if they bring anything at all. And they never listen
Brenda MayberryOctober 7, 2020
Been here 10+ times
Large portions so come hungry!
dele deleJune 22, 2011
The 18th and 8th is probably the best pie on the menu.
Marilina GustafsonJuly 17, 2017
Been here 5+ times
My margarita pizza barely had any cheese
Paula MendezJanuary 13, 2016
The pastas are delicious
Matthew NelsonSeptember 17, 2020
Been here 10+ times
Best Pizza in the Little Apple!
Eustace DaugerApril 30, 2013
Been here 50+ times
Biggest freshest garlic knots in human history.
Erica HopwoodApril 2, 2013
Been here 100+ times
When they ask if you want dipping sauce, get garlic butter, not ranch. Trust me.
TainaAugust 13, 2012
Def not a NY style place. Tried it twice and tried various items each time. Certainly nothing to write home about. I'll go to old Chicago across the street.
Ben B.April 14, 2011
Its no NY pizza but prob the best in the area since Gumbys closed. Grilled cheese pizza is win
Curtis McClainOctober 25, 2011
Try Monday's, they have 50 cent beers! U can't beat that!
Terence DeeseSeptember 20, 2020
Been here 10+ times
Hi dominick
Matthew NelsonJune 24, 2018
Been here 10+ times
Solid wings.
Eustace DaugerFebruary 8, 2013
Been here 50+ times
Finally got the fifth avenue sign
Dominick DeeseSeptember 20, 2020
Pizza is hella good
Jordan MizellDecember 28, 2010
50cent beer draws on Monday's that's super cheap beer.
Kyle SeiwertJanuary 4, 2011
Get the number 10 Meatball Parmesan pizza.
Miss JessicaJuly 10, 2016
Pizza was good, but not good enough to make up for their lack of customer service skills.
Ninja JeffMay 29, 2012
Get the AJ's Grilled Cheese Pie
Anthony MJanuary 19, 2011
Nothing has disappointed me yet that I've ordered. Best pizza I've had in years.
Elly GoldsteinSeptember 28, 2010
McSorleys black lager on tap...awesome!
Nate DillonApril 23, 2010
Been here 25+ times
Best pizza in town.
Mark ReidyDecember 2, 2011
Been here 5+ times
Pizza is excellent....service is terrible especially if you have to deal with a worker named Josh...rude.

36 Photos

AJ's NY Pizzeria

Related Searches

You might also like

Places people like to go after AJ's NY Pizzeria

Appears on 8 lists

Is this your business? Claim it now.