Shelter Island

1. Vine Street Cafe

8.8

41 S Ferry Rd (at Cartwright Rd.), Shelter Island, NY

American Restaurant · 25 tips and reviews

2. Salt

7.8

63 South Menantic Road, Shelter Island, NY

New American Restaurant · 37 tips and reviews

3. Islander

7.4

63 N Ferry Rd, Shelter Island, NY

Breakfast Spot · 9 tips and reviews

Ram's Head Inn is one of Shelter Island.

4. Ram's Head Inn

8.4

108 Ram Island Drive, Shelter Island, NY

American Restaurant · 6 tips and reviews

Claudio's Restaurant is one of Shelter Island.

5. Claudio's Restaurant

6.3

111 Main St, Greenport, NY

Seafood Restaurant · 36 tips and reviews

6. Greenport Harbor Brewing Company

8.9

234 Carpenter St. (at Bay Ave.), Greenport, NY

Brewery · 41 tips and reviews

7. Aldo's

7.9

105 Front St (at 1st St), Greenport, NY

Café · 56 tips and reviews

8. Butta Cakes

119 Main St (Front St), Greenport, NY

Cupcake Shop · 3 tips and reviews

The North Fork Oyster Company is one of Shelter Island.

9. The North Fork Oyster Company

300 Main St (Stirling Square), Greenport, NY

Seafood Restaurant · 5 tips and reviews

Love Lane Kitchen is one of Shelter Island.

10. Love Lane Kitchen

8.5

240 Love Ln (btw Sound Ave. & Pike St.), Mattituck, NY

American Restaurant · 90 tips and reviews

North Fork Table & Inn is one of Shelter Island.

11. North Fork Table & Inn

9.0

57225 Route 25, Southold, NY

American Restaurant · 47 tips and reviews

Oz Lubling: amazing food! one of the best meals you'll have in the NoFo and probably all of long island. The scallops are incredible and if they have a pea soup on the menu, order it! a brilliant experience.

Catapano Farms is one of Shelter Island.

12. Catapano Farms

8.0

Southold, NY

Cheese Store · 4 tips and reviews

Shelter Island North Ferry - Greenport Terminal is one of Shelter Island.

13. Shelter Island North Ferry - Greenport Terminal

3rd St, Greenport, NY

Marine Terminal · 16 tips and reviews

Hallock's Cider Mill is one of Shelter Island.

14. Hallock's Cider Mill

6.9

1960 Main Rd, Laurel, NY

Food and Beverage Retail · 6 tips and reviews

15. Scrimshaw

102 Main St, Greenport, NY

Asian Restaurant · 11 tips and reviews