The Best Mac and Cheese in NYC

The Best Mac and Cheese in NYC

Creator Avatar
Created by Village Voice • Updated On: December 14, 2015

From gourmet to classic, we scoured the city for the best Mac n Cheese.

Murray's Cheese Bar is one of The Best Mac and Cheese in NYC.

1. Murray's Cheese Bar

264 Bleecker St (at Cornelia St), New York, NY
Cheese Store · West Village · 119 tips and reviews

Village VoiceVillage Voice: Indulge in their creamy four cheese mac and cheese topped with crisp fried onions.

Milk Truck Grilled Cheese is one of The Best Mac and Cheese in NYC.

2. Milk Truck Grilled Cheese

11 Fulton St (at Front St), New York, NY
Food Truck · Financial District · 41 tips and reviews

Village VoiceVillage Voice: Voted the best mac & cheese in 2013, their ham mac & cheese is filled with four creamy cheeses and applewood smoked ham.

S'MAC is one of The Best Mac and Cheese in NYC.

3. S'MAC

7.8
197 1st Ave (at E 12th St), New York, NY
Mac and Cheese Joint · East Village · 283 tips and reviews

Village VoiceVillage Voice: Order the buffalo chicken mac and cheese for a spicy twist on a gooey dish.

Westville West is one of The Best Mac and Cheese in NYC.

4. Westville West

210 W 10th St (btwn Bleecker & W 4th St.), New York, NY
American Restaurant · West Village · 177 tips and reviews

Village VoiceVillage Voice: Make sure to add bacon to the top when you get the smoky gouda mac and cheese.

Mac Shack is one of The Best Mac and Cheese in NYC.

5. Mac Shack

7.4
901 Fulton St (Clinton Ave), Brooklyn, NY
Mac and Cheese Joint · Clinton Hill · 31 tips and reviews

Village VoiceVillage Voice: The daring combination of smoked duck leg in the mac and cheese is irresistible.

Elbow Room is one of The Best Mac and Cheese in NYC.

6. Elbow Room

41 Halsey St (Bleeker St), Newark, NJ
Mac and Cheese Joint · Newark Central Business District · 16 tips and reviews

Village VoiceVillage Voice: Get the margherita mac which is a combination of pizza and mac & cheese...the best of both worlds!

Queens Comfort is one of The Best Mac and Cheese in NYC.

7. Queens Comfort

4009 30th Ave (btwn 36th & 37th St.), Astoria, NY
American Restaurant · Astoria · 218 tips and reviews

Village VoiceVillage Voice: Make sure to order some ranch on the side with the Atomic Fire Balls which are spicy, crunchy, deep fried mac and cheese bites.

The Queens Kickshaw is one of The Best Mac and Cheese in NYC.

8. The Queens Kickshaw

4017 Broadway (at Steinway St), Astoria, NY
Café · 233 tips and reviews

Village VoiceVillage Voice: Dive into the three cheeses mac and cheese, which is topped with crunchy green beans and caramelized onions.