Angelo's Pizza
Pizzeria and Italian Restaurant$$$$
Theater District, New York
"Pizza is the best coal oven pizza."(3 Tips)
"Great place for pizza in Midtown"(2 Tips)
"Favorite pizza in NYC! Also try the arugula salad yum"(2 Tips)
"Really good margherita pizza."(4 Tips)
See what your friends are saying about Angelo's Pizza.
By creating an account you are able to follow friends and experts you trust and see the places they’ve recommended.
orSign up with email
82 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- pizza
- healthy food
- casual
- arugula salad
- great value
- (15 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Jochen G. WeberOctober 17, 2014Angelos is absolutely fant-wait for it-tastic! Delicious. I'm from Germany, lived in Italy, but nevertheless they serve the worlds best pizza here.Upvote10DownvoteUpvoted Feb 23
Neal HillSeptember 24, 2013Pricey ($25 for two drinks and a 17 inch pie half sausage) but the best pizza in midtown... a purist? Go with the traditional margherita. The sausage is delicious too.Upvote8Downvote
Jonathan PayneJanuary 11, 2019Absolutely dynamite pizza. Coal-fired, crunchy pizza packed with flavor. Service is incredibly fast. Top pizza recommendation!Upvote1Downvote
Will SigmonDecember 5, 2014I'm a pizza fanatic, and I eat it usually at least once a week. This was in the top 3 I've ever had in my life!UpvoteDownvote
Oren FarageDecember 28, 2014True Italian place in the city. Pizza and pasta that will make you feel you are in Rome. If you want Italian- great place.UpvoteDownvote
Brian DOctober 2, 2018Food is excellent! Service needed to better. Had to wait a while for our server to initially greet us and get drink orders. Then throughout our meal we sat with empty drinks trying to get refills.UpvoteDownvote
This restaurant is worth a visit. The pizza and pasta are perfect and arw the reasons why I stop in every time I'm in NYC.Upvote8Downvote
David WhiteJanuary 5, 2018Pizza is great, lightly charred-black around the outer edge of the crust and fresh mozz with sauce drizzled haphazard around...UpvoteDownvote
ZoozJanuary 21, 2020You will not regret coming here ... Very warm and friendly ... Baked Zitti and their pies are specialUpvoteDownvote
ℳansour αℓтαууαrMarch 12, 2018The pizza is delicious, well-done and very tasty. Staff are nice and around all the time.UpvoteDownvote
Garrett GarberDecember 21, 2012Good service/ atmosphere & warm bread. I got the Sicilian salad- good but a bit salty and heavy on the olive oil. Id suggest getting some medium bodied red with itUpvoteDownvote
Wejdan ✨December 28, 2014Pizza is the besttt. Ravioli with pistachio sauce worth the try.
UpvoteDownvote- Fried Zucchini and Eggplant is a great way to start. FYI: the small pizza can feed 2 people (it's a very generous portion). I love this place.UpvoteDownvote
Great coal oven pizza. Pasta, salad, wine, beer, attentive service.UpvoteDownvote- Haley BisseggerApril 13, 2015Really good margherita pizza. Friendly staff and reasonably priced for a sit down pizza restaurant!UpvoteDownvote
The taste and the look of the mozzarella cheese melting on top of their pizza make you cry every time you leave the place 😭Upvote2Downvote
Lotfi BashirDecember 14, 2015Authentic Italian food, great chicken piccata with spinach. Spinach never tasted better with the piccata sauce.UpvoteDownvote
Steven YApril 4, 2014If you're ordering takeout, make sure you go to the right location LOL - they have two locations near each other in Midtown WestUpvoteDownvote
Kara LFebruary 16, 2013Best pizza I've ever had. Make sure you get a piece with basil on it. Really adds an extra somethingUpvote2Downvote
Brian StortsDecember 8, 2019The white our with arugula, garlic, prosciutto and sun dried tomatoes was perfection.UpvoteDownvote
Leo WakaAugust 21, 2014Pretty good pizzas... Cozy place... Excellent attendants... I had a great dinner there :)UpvoteDownvote
Margaret PorterApril 10, 2015Awesome pizza for a great value- would come back when we visit NYC againUpvoteDownvote
Serious EatsNovember 4, 2013More-than-decent coal-fired brick-oven pies with fresh mozzarella.Upvote1Downvote- David WhiteJanuary 5, 2018Rigatoni Campagnola is awesome and loaded with great veg and Italian sausage in a light sauce.UpvoteDownvote
Robert BachmanJuly 7, 2013Salad was super and the pizza was out of this world coal fired. Waitress was very friendly 😃😃😃😃😃UpvoteDownvote
Huldah SchuttMay 4, 2014My all time favorite restaurant. Try the fetuccine, its to die for.UpvoteDownvote
I love it and everytime in New York I go there....UpvoteDownvote- Scott SpauldingAugust 21, 2011Great place for pizza in Midtown, just south of Central Park, stop in every time we are in Manhattan!UpvoteDownvote
Jean AndreacciAugust 9, 2013Great pizza! More of a tomato pie like Maruca's in Seaside Hts.UpvoteDownvote
Addison SammetApril 11, 2016Good pizza, but not the authentic New York pizza you're looking for.UpvoteDownvote
Sonia DerryberryMay 15, 2014Order the Pepperoni, garlic and onion pizza with a side of broccoliUpvoteDownvote
Blue Man City ManDecember 29, 2014I would rather take pizza to go at this place. But if your starving, have a sit down!UpvoteDownvote
186 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Closed until 11:30 AM (Show more)
- Mon–Sun
- 11:30 AM–9:30 PM
(212) 333-4333
Features
Reservations
Yes
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. Discover & Visa)
Outdoor Seating
No
Restroom
Yes
Food & Drink
Menus
Lunch, Dinner
Drinks
Beer, Wine, Full Bar
See More
You might also like
Places people like to go after Angelo's Pizza
- 9.7
"Beautiful park. Clean and well groomed. Loved all those squirrels! Just lovely!"
Esra PRG - 8.4
"Always my favourite place to be when I am in NY. Love the dynamic."
Atika Al-Bimani - 9.3
"Weill Hall is a smaller, more intimate venue with great acoustics. It was perfect for a piano recital by Hyeyoung Song that I just enjoyed there."
Mike Chung
Appears on 164 lists
Created by naveen
7 items • 33 followersCreated by Mike Knight
102 items • 9 followers
