See all
318 photos

Redeye Grill

American Restaurant, Steakhouse, and Seafood Restaurant$$$$

Theater District, New York

Save

Redeye Grill

8.0^/10

320

ratings

Ranked #9 for American restaurants in the Theater District
"This place is overpriced but the banana cream pie is amazing."(3 Tips)
"Food was 3 out of 5. Convenient location for Carnegie Hall."(2 Tips)
"Also the lobster Mac and cheese is amazeballs."(3 Tips)
"No lobster roll Guacamole not too good"(8 Tips)

See what your friends are saying about Redeye Grill.

By creating an account you are able to follow friends and experts you trust and see the places they’ve recommended.

orSign up with email

76 Tips and reviews

Filter:

seafood
good for groups
live music
carnegie hall
healthy food
banana cream pie
good for dates
great value
trendy
desserts
bar
biscuits
hot dogs
dancing
dinner
lunch
soup
good for business meetings
crowded
good for special occasions
(15 more)

Sort:

Popular
Recent

Annie MFebruary 7, 2017
Sushi burger!!!!!!! Not on the menu, you have to ask. Also the lobster Mac and cheese is amazeballs. Waitstaff (Alton) and host make you feel like VIP, and there is life music all night.
Upvote7Downvote
Ryan Van DykeSeptember 17, 2014
The raised bar is an excellent vantage point for the rest of the restaurant. Especially, if you are rolling solo. And they have oysters on ice which makes for a nice visual.
Upvote3Downvote
Trae FOctober 15, 2016
Great calamari and sushi. The service is very friendly and attentive. Perfect for dinner before a show.
Upvote2Downvote
Raphael LangenscheidtOctober 22, 2015
Amazing people-watching when the midtown c-suite comes for lunch. Huge burger, but even better Cobb salad. Old school feel.
Upvote1Downvote
Susan LohMay 27, 2015
the open-faced lobster pot pie is bananatown! an entire lobster on a bed of veggies with just the right amount of lobster reduction sauce.
UpvoteDownvote
Felix VerranSeptember 21, 2013
This place is EPIC!!! My favorite meals in the big apple were here. The lamb, steak, lobster Mac, and sushi. I wish I lived in NY
UpvoteDownvote
The Negotiation Institute (TNI)May 1, 2012
Great (relatively quiet) midtown option for important meetings. Attire, menu, prices and atmosphere reflect sophisticated business clientele. Large area & well-spaced tables = conversation privacy.
UpvoteDownvote
Lauren RodasSeptember 4, 2013
Great for a group of ppl. They are great for vegans as they customize the menu. Food was great and the service was amazing!!
UpvoteDownvote
WP TheaterMarch 19, 2013
Good thing Redeye Grill is so close to New York City Center because at least once while JACKIE runs we WILL try this lobster roll everyone is talking about.
UpvoteDownvote
Mike ChapmanJuly 29, 2017
Been here 10+ times
Good food, good drinks, good service. Prices to match but worth it for a splurge
UpvoteDownvote
eric bornemannApril 16, 2021
Nice for sitting outside on a warm spring night and soaking up mid-town vibes.
UpvoteDownvote
AmateurConciergeNovember 30, 2019
Nice old world NY decor. Simple American fare kinda menu. Fries were quite good.
UpvoteDownvote
George ZMarch 17, 2015
Live music and an excellent dirty martini. You get the leftover martini in the shaker as a refill, old school style
UpvoteDownvote
Homewood SuitesNovember 22, 2011
Redeye Grill is on the Macy's Thanksgiving Day Parade path! Tune in and catch the Lewis the Duck "On the Roll Again" parade float presented by Homewood Suites by Hilton.
UpvoteDownvote
Signs VisualJuly 27, 2015
This a neat place to go to after work for good lasagna, and live jazz music! Read more
UpvoteDownvote
YannettaJune 29, 2013
Very nice seafood restaurant. I liked avocado and crab salad a lot! Burata is not the one you expect to see. Looks like Viola more:(
Upvote1Downvote
Wilson ZhouOctober 21, 2015
2015-2016 Carnegie Hall Concert Season, one complimentary glass of Prosecco with purchase of entrée for members.
UpvoteDownvote
Sinem SaniyeFebruary 9, 2020
Delicious menu. The deserts are HUGE!!
UpvoteDownvote
Wayne BennettSeptember 17, 2014
Any place that has the kahones to charge $27 for a Big City Hot Dog, my hat goes off to them. Anyone willing to pay it, should have their head examined
UpvoteDownvote
Karon WOctober 20, 2014
This place is overpriced but the banana cream pie is amazing. Doesn't really make up for paying a fortune for the entree.
UpvoteDownvote
Roger SchonfeldMarch 26, 2017
Great fish and seafood selections
UpvoteDownvote
Vanity FairDecember 10, 2012
Televangelist Joel Osteen indulges in the organic chicken at this American Fusion favorite.
UpvoteDownvote
Sheila MahoutchianJune 12, 2014
Stuffy and overpriced. Good cheesecake. Didn't love the cod. Good guacamole, good bread.
UpvoteDownvote
Justin ErenkrantzApril 22, 2017
Been here 10+ times
Crab legs are fantastic!
UpvoteDownvote
Linda MiklowitzMarch 2, 2013
The height of their fusion cuisine is matzoh balls in miso soup b
UpvoteDownvote
Dalah DPJune 24, 2010
Amazing honey biscuits!! Just one of the free treats the chef sends out to diners in baking trays straight from the oven!
UpvoteDownvote
Linda MiklowitzJune 7, 2013
Their fusion dishes include matzoh ball & miso soup.
UpvoteDownvote
Donna GowApril 24, 2014
If you don't like salt remember to ask your steak without.
UpvoteDownvote
Kurt GAugust 10, 2014
This place is epic!!! Prime Filet Mignon rules!!!
UpvoteDownvote
Linda MiklowitzMarch 2, 2013
Lovely new wooden ceiling. Miss the plane and aviation theme. Why call it Red Eye?
UpvoteDownvote
Estelle StravatoSeptember 26, 2022
All food Desserts
UpvoteDownvote
Ravi MexicoSeptember 5, 2013
A good place to come after closing a mortgage. Or two years later
UpvoteDownvote
Alice Villar 🌻❤ NYCOctober 26, 2013
Service was great and food was delish!
Upvote1Downvote
Charlie BahrFebruary 24, 2013
The standing ovation cocktail is fabulous.
UpvoteDownvote
Adam PylesApril 6, 2013
Very nice place. Bartenders were top shelf.
UpvoteDownvote
Benjamin AdlerSeptember 12, 2021
had a nice lunch here on a Sunday afternoon
UpvoteDownvote
Noel HeaneySeptember 19, 2012
Ask for a Hendricks and Tonic with cucumber. Waiter went to check if they had and and came back with chopped cucumber asking if that was ok. Um, NO
Upvote1Downvote
Nanna Kirstine Magdalene BluhmeAugust 4, 2016
The music is a little loud, but food was allright.
UpvoteDownvote
SherrySeptember 3, 2016
Top notch service.
UpvoteDownvote
Michael SchouDecember 13, 2012
Great bread, classy atmosphere
Upvote1Downvote
Hilton Grand VacationsJuly 29, 2011
Staying at West 57th St by Hilton Club? You can get room service from Redeye Grill and have it charged to your hotel bill.
Upvote3Downvote
Kate W.May 9, 2010
So much nicer than the name suggests. Excellent brunch and great for a big group.
UpvoteDownvote
Dominic ForteNovember 1, 2015
Great live music
UpvoteDownvote
Michael KauffmanJanuary 12, 2013
Been here 10+ times
Try the English Fish And Chips
UpvoteDownvote
Greg DePalmaFebruary 21, 2016
Excellent. As always.
UpvoteDownvote
Steven BirkelandJune 16, 2012
Try the Oysters - Ram Island, Naked Cowgirl.....
UpvoteDownvote
Brian ScottJanuary 14, 2013
Been here 5+ times
Why hello Artezin by the glass. So nice to have you with my steak!
UpvoteDownvote
Samantha BailyeOctober 12, 2011
The banana cream pie is ridiculously amazing.
UpvoteDownvote
James John (Jay) Cudney IVDecember 14, 2016
Good steak!
UpvoteDownvote
Roseann Schindler WexlerOctober 1, 2013
No lobster roll Guacamole not too good
UpvoteDownvote

1 2

318 Photos

Redeye Grill

See what your friends are saying about Redeye Grill.

Related Searches

Places inside Redeye Grill

You might also like

Places people like to go after Redeye Grill

Appears on 143 lists

Top places in the area

Is this your business? Claim it now.