Close Icon
Gear IconImportant Reminder:The City Guide app will be sunsetting on December 15, 2024, with the web version to follow in early 2025. Please visit our FAQ to learn more or to download our Swarm app.
Learn more
Irish pubs on Long Island
Buckley's Inn Between is one of Irish pubs on Long Island.

1. Buckley's Inn Between

7.8
139 W Montauk Hwy, Hampton Bays, NY
Restaurant · 21 tips and reviews

NewsdayNewsday: It has a house-like structure that features a bar area on one side, as well as an adjacent longer room with a stage section and space for events. They even feature live music.

Buckley's Irish Pub is one of Irish pubs on Long Island.

2. Buckley's Irish Pub

7.3
386 Main St, Center Moriches, NY
Irish Pub · 11 tips and reviews

NewsdayNewsday: This Irish bar and grill offers a menu of appetizers, salads and entrées, with a number of items borne of Irish cuisine.

Declan Quinns is one of Irish pubs on Long Island.

3. Declan Quinns

227 4th Ave, Bay Shore, NY
Bar · 13 tips and reviews

NewsdayNewsday: Wood floors and simple white tablecloths belie the Irish theme at Declan Quinn's, but with odd wall art and rustic lightbulbs hanging overhead, this casual pub and restaurant has a bit of quirk to it

Finnegan's is one of Irish pubs on Long Island.

4. Finnegan's

7.0
5 Wall Street, Huntington, NY
Bar · 23 tips and reviews

NewsdayNewsday: Over the years, this 100-year-old pub has changed in appearance, size and ownership, but nostalgia remains, evident in wall hangings dating to its 1912 beginnings.

Hunter's Pub is one of Irish pubs on Long Island.

5. Hunter's Pub

470 Westbury Ave, Carle Place, NY
Bar · 6 tips and reviews

NewsdayNewsday: With Irish-oriented regalia behind the liquor racks and a lounge area in the front, this often-unmentioned watering hole may just be worth a good look.

Irish Coffee Pub is one of Irish pubs on Long Island.

6. Irish Coffee Pub

8.4
131 Carleton Ave (btw Stewart & Wall), East Islip, NY
Restaurant · 15 tips and reviews

NewsdayNewsday: This elegant and fancy eatery serves a wide variety of meals, with an emphasis on steaks and seafood and Irish cuisine.

The Irish Times Pub is one of Irish pubs on Long Island.

7. The Irish Times Pub

7.2
975 Main St, Holbrook, NY
Irish Pub · 17 tips and reviews

NewsdayNewsday: With 20 beers on tap and seating for up to 70 diners, you can have a good time at the Irish Times Pub. It's family friendly, with a heated patio, and a late-night scene.

Jackie Reilly's is one of Irish pubs on Long Island.

8. Jackie Reilly's

7.4
3964 Hempstead Tpke, Bethpage, NY
Sports Bar · 16 tips and reviews

NewsdayNewsday: Plenty of live music here on weekends with smaller acts and cover bands. Expect lots of volume: Even when it's just the jukebox -- it's always pretty darn loud here. Read more.

Johnny McGorey's Pub is one of Irish pubs on Long Island.

9. Johnny McGorey's Pub

6.6
131 Front St (7th Ave), Massapequa Park, NY
Irish Pub · 19 tips and reviews

NewsdayNewsday: Neighborhood establishment that generally serves a crowd of locals.

10. Mary Dowling's

6.6
528 Main St, Islip, NY
Pub · 11 tips and reviews

NewsdayNewsday: This pub serves burgers, steaks and other pub grub, along with specialty Irish dishes like shepherd's pie. Food aside, Lily’s is an extremely popular place for nightlife. Read more.

Lily Flanagan's Pub is one of Irish pubs on Long Island.

11. Lily Flanagan's Pub

7.6
345 Deer Park Ave (Park Ave), Babylon, NY
Pub · 18 tips and reviews

NewsdayNewsday: Even on the less-busier weekdays, there's always a steady crowd who enjoy the laid-back atmosphere of Lily Flanagan's.

McCann's Pub is one of Irish pubs on Long Island.

12. McCann's Pub

5590 Merrick Rd (at Carmen Mill Rd), Massapequa, NY
Pub · 22 tips and reviews

NewsdayNewsday: Sports rules the day here. -- Be it Ultimate Fighting Championship, Major League Baseball or National Football League, you can easily catch the action from the bar or in the comfy lounge area. Read more.

Napper Tandy's Irish Pub is one of Irish pubs on Long Island.

13. Napper Tandy's Irish Pub

6.1
15 E Main St (Lawrence Ave.), Smithtown, NY
Irish Pub · 15 tips and reviews

NewsdayNewsday: With a crawl of bars nearby along Main Street, the bustling sidewalk patio is a beacon to all comers that something fun happens here.

The Nutty Irishman is one of Irish pubs on Long Island.

14. The Nutty Irishman

7.6
323 Main St, Farmingdale, NY
Irish Pub · 35 tips and reviews

NewsdayNewsday: The Nutty Irishman offers various food and drink specials nightly, along with live music and DJ events, sports packages for game viewing, plus karaoke on Wednesdays. Read more.

The Nutty Irishman of Bay Shore is one of Irish pubs on Long Island.

15. The Nutty Irishman of Bay Shore

60 E Main St, Bay Shore, NY
Bar · 22 tips and reviews

NewsdayNewsday: There are evenings where a long line of energetic people seems to keep refreshing itself as barhoppers arrive to party. Read more.

16. The Republic Pub

8.2
217 Main St (Conklin St), Farmingdale, NY
Pub · 29 tips and reviews

NewsdayNewsday: This Irish pub has a solid bar scene, but what makes it stand out is its menu of items large and small that recall the hearty cuisine of the Emerald Isle. Read more.

17. Shandon Court

7.7
115 E Main St (Greenwood Avenue), East Islip, NY
American Restaurant · 10 tips and reviews

NewsdayNewsday: Warm and old-fashioned with domed lights hanging above the wooden floors while old-world drawings and photos hang around the room set the scene for its Irish-inspired items. Read more.

18. The Twisted Kilt Tavern

4777 Sunrise Hwy, Bohemia, NY
Burger Joint · 7 tips and reviews

NewsdayNewsday: This restaurant and bar serves grill items for meals, while featuring a late night scene and occasionally hosting live music. Read more.