Close Icon
Gear IconImportant Reminder:The City Guide app will be sunsetting on December 15, 2024, with the web version to follow in early 2025. Please visit our FAQ to learn more or to download our Swarm app.
Learn more
My Indy Dining Favorites

My Indy Dining Favorites

Creator Avatar
Created by Joe Shoemaker • Updated On: November 11, 2021

This list is in no particular order of preference.

Milktooth is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

1. Milktooth

8.7
540 Virginia Ave, Indianapolis, IN
New American Restaurant · Fletcher Place · 54 tips and reviews

Joe S.Joe Shoemaker: Dutch Baby with Ham. Pour-over of the day. Read more.

Bluebeard is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

2. Bluebeard

9.1
653 Virginia Ave, Indianapolis, IN
New American Restaurant · Fletcher Place · 60 tips and reviews
Siam Square is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

3. Siam Square

8.5
936 Virginia Ave (btwn Grove Ave & Buchanan St), Indianapolis, IN
Thai Restaurant · Fountain Square · 78 tips and reviews
Thunderbird is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

4. Thunderbird

8.0
1127 Shelby St (Morris street), Indianapolis, IN
Cocktail Bar · Fountain Square · 25 tips and reviews
Pizzology Craft Pizza + Pub is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

5. Pizzology Craft Pizza + Pub

8.0
13190 Hazel Dell Pkwy (at Hazel Dell, behind Starbucks), Carmel, IN
Pizzeria · 59 tips and reviews

6. La Revolucion Cafe & Bar

7.9
1132 Prospect St, Indianapolis, IN
Bar · Fountain Square · 61 tips and reviews

Joe S.Joe Shoemaker: Fish Tacos and Pink Death.

Late Harvest Dinner is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

7. Late Harvest Dinner

8630 River Crossing, Indianapolis, IN
American Restaurant · Keystone at The Crossing · 4 tips and reviews
Goose The Market is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

8. Goose The Market

9.4
2503 N Delaware St (at E 25th St), Indianapolis, IN
Gourmet Store · Fall Creek Place · 74 tips and reviews
La Margarita is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

9. La Margarita

8.4
1043 Virginia Ave (Woodlawn Ave), Indianapolis, IN
Mexican Restaurant · Fountain Square · 60 tips and reviews
Sawasdee is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

10. Sawasdee

7.6
1222 W 86th St (Ditch), Indianapolis, IN
Thai Restaurant · St. Vincent - Greenbriar · 46 tips and reviews
Easy Riser Diner is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

11. Easy Riser Diner

8.3
1043 Virginia Ave (Virginia shelby), Indianapolis, IN
Sandwich Spot · Fountain Square · 56 tips and reviews
Ripple Bagel & Deli is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

12. Ripple Bagel & Deli

8.5
850 Broad Ripple Ave (at Guilford Ave.), Indianapolis, IN
Bagel Shop · Broad Ripple · 83 tips and reviews

13. Red Lion Grog House

8.6
1043 Virginia Ave (in the G. C. Murphy Building), Indianapolis, IN
Pub · Fountain Square · 63 tips and reviews

Megan B.Megan Bennett: Strong Bow on tap!

Black Market is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

14. Black Market

922 Massachusetts Ave (East End), Indianapolis, IN
Gastropub · Downtown Indianapolis · 28 tips and reviews
Cafe Korea is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

15. Cafe Korea

7.5
7262 116th St. (Allisonville), Fishers, IN
Korean Restaurant · Fishers Crossing · 10 tips and reviews
Tomo Japanese Steak House & Sushi Bar is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

16. Tomo Japanese Steak House & Sushi Bar

8.3
7411 N Keystone Ave, Indianapolis, IN
Japanese Restaurant · 36 tips and reviews
Taste Café & Marketplace is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

17. Taste Café & Marketplace

5164 N College Ave (at E 52nd St), Indianapolis, IN
Breakfast Spot · Meridian Kessler · 67 tips and reviews
Brugge Brasserie is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

18. Brugge Brasserie

1011A E Westfield Blvd (at Winthrop Av), Indianapolis, IN
Belgian Restaurant · Broad Ripple · 63 tips and reviews
Saigon Restaurant is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

19. Saigon Restaurant

8.8
4760 W 38th St, Indianapolis, IN
Vietnamese Restaurant · 35 tips and reviews
Eggshell Bistro is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

20. Eggshell Bistro

7.9
51 W City Center Dr (Range Line Rd & 126th St.), Carmel, IN
Breakfast Spot · 23 tips and reviews
Blu Moon Cafe is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

21. Blu Moon Cafe

200 S Rangeline Rd Ste 115, Carmel, IN
Café · 19 tips and reviews
Divvy is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

22. Divvy

7.9
71 City Center Dr, Carmel, IN
New American Restaurant · 24 tips and reviews
Amber Indian is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

23. Amber Indian

7.4
12510 N Meridian St (W Carmel Dr), Carmel, IN
Indian Restaurant · 23 tips and reviews
La Hacienda is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

24. La Hacienda

8.5
6825 Graham Rd (at Binford), Indianapolis, IN
Mexican Restaurant · 38 tips and reviews
La Hacienda is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

25. La Hacienda

8.1
5625 Lawton Loop East Dr, Indianapolis, IN
Mexican Restaurant · 15 tips and reviews
La Piedad is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

26. La Piedad

7.8
6524 Cornell Ave, Indianapolis, IN
Mexican Restaurant · Broad Ripple · 33 tips and reviews
Bee Coffee Roasters is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

27. Bee Coffee Roasters

7.7
5510 Lafayette Rd #140, Indianapolis, IN
Coffee Shop · Snacks - Guion Creek · 23 tips and reviews

28. Locally Grown Gardens

1050 E 54th St (btw Carvel & Monon), Indianapolis, IN
Farmers Market · Canterbury · 32 tips and reviews

Joe S.Joe Shoemaker: Sugar Cream Pie. As good as my grandmother's, and that's saying a lot.

The Smoking Goose Dorman Street Meatery is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

29. The Smoking Goose Dorman Street Meatery

8.1
407 Dorman St (Vermont), Indianapolis, IN
Restaurant · Near Eastside · 6 tips and reviews
Tulip Noir is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

30. Tulip Noir

1224 W 86th St, Indianapolis, IN
Café · St. Vincent - Greenbriar · 18 tips and reviews
Hubbard & Cravens Coffee and Tea is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

31. Hubbard & Cravens Coffee and Tea

8.7
4930 N Pennsylvania St (E 50th Street), Indianapolis, IN
Coffee Shop · Meridian Kessler · 30 tips and reviews
U-Relish Farms is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

32. U-Relish Farms

222 E Market St (at Alabama St), Indianapolis, IN
Soup Spot · Downtown Indianapolis · 7 tips and reviews
Fermenti Artisan Delicatessen is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

33. Fermenti Artisan Delicatessen

5.5
222 E Market St (at Alabama St), Indianapolis, IN
Deli · Downtown Indianapolis · 9 tips and reviews
Cafe Patachou is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

34. Cafe Patachou

9.2
4911 N Pennsylvania St (at 49th Street), Indianapolis, IN
American Restaurant · Meridian Kessler · 58 tips and reviews
Yats is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

35. Yats

8.9
5365 College Ave (at E 54th St), Indianapolis, IN
Cajun and Creole Restaurant · Meridian Kessler · 90 tips and reviews
Twenty Tap is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

36. Twenty Tap

8.9
5408 N College Ave (at E 55th St), Indianapolis, IN
Bar · Meridian Kessler · 76 tips and reviews
Ma Ma's Korean Restaurant is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

37. Ma Ma's Korean Restaurant

8.7
8867 Pendleton Pike (38th and Pendleton), Indianapolis, IN
Korean Restaurant · 21 tips and reviews
Hubbard & Cravens Restaurant is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

38. Hubbard & Cravens Restaurant

703 Veterans Way, Carmel, IN
American Restaurant · 8 tips and reviews
Tortas Guicho Dominguez y El Cubanito is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

39. Tortas Guicho Dominguez y El Cubanito

8.4
641 Virginia Ave (Virginia at College), Indianapolis, IN
Sandwich Spot · Fletcher Place · 29 tips and reviews
Ball & Biscuit is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

40. Ball & Biscuit

8.8
331 Massachusetts Ave (at E New York St.), Indianapolis, IN
Cocktail Bar · Downtown Indianapolis · 77 tips and reviews
Bazbeaux Pizza is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

41. Bazbeaux Pizza

8.9
329 Massachusetts Ave (at E New York St), Indianapolis, IN
Pizzeria · Downtown Indianapolis · 101 tips and reviews
Maxine's Chicken & Waffles is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

42. Maxine's Chicken & Waffles

8.0
132 N East St (at E Wabash St), Indianapolis, IN
Southern Food Restaurant · Downtown Indianapolis · 85 tips and reviews
Pogue's Run Grocer is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

43. Pogue's Run Grocer

2828 E 10th St (at N Oxford St), Indianapolis, IN
Grocery Store · Near Eastside · 20 tips and reviews
Bru Burger Bar is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

44. Bru Burger Bar

9.0
410 Massachusetts Ave, Indianapolis, IN
Burger Joint · Downtown Indianapolis · 152 tips and reviews
Ralph's Great Divide is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

45. Ralph's Great Divide

8.1
743 E New York St (bt Fulton & N Davidson Sts), Indianapolis, IN
American Restaurant · Downtown Indianapolis · 25 tips and reviews
Cafe Patachou is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

46. Cafe Patachou

8.8
225 W Washington St (at Capital), Indianapolis, IN
Café · Downtown Indianapolis · 125 tips and reviews
Eat + Drink is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

47. Eat + Drink

5.9
5168 N College Ave (52nd & College), Indianapolis, IN
Cocktail Bar · Meridian Kessler · 11 tips and reviews
The Brass Ring is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

48. The Brass Ring

8.0
1245 Shelby St (at Sanders St), Indianapolis, IN
Bar · Fountain Square · 38 tips and reviews
Chatham Tap is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

49. Chatham Tap

8.4
719 Massachusetts Ave (at N Park Ave), Indianapolis, IN
Pub · Chatham Arch · 98 tips and reviews
Napolese is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

50. Napolese

8.2
8702 Keystone Xing, Indianapolis, IN
Italian Restaurant · Keystone at The Crossing · 26 tips and reviews
Napolese Artisanal Pizzeria- 49th and Pennsylvania is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

51. Napolese Artisanal Pizzeria- 49th and Pennsylvania

7.7
114 E 49th St (Pennsylvania), Indianapolis, IN
Pizzeria · Meridian Kessler · 33 tips and reviews
MacDuff Realty Group is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

52. MacDuff Realty Group

719 Virginia Ave (McCarty), Indianapolis, IN
Real Estate Agency · Fletcher Place · 1 tip
Kuma's Corner is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

53. Kuma's Corner

8.8
1127 Prospect St (Morris), Indianapolis, IN
Burger Joint · Fountain Square · 24 tips and reviews
Bosphorus Istanbul Cafe is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

54. Bosphorus Istanbul Cafe

9.0
935 S East St (at Buchanan St), Indianapolis, IN
Middle Eastern Restaurant · Fletcher Place · 32 tips and reviews
Yolk. is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

55. Yolk.

9.0
220 E South St (Alabama), Indianapolis, IN
Breakfast Spot · Downtown Indianapolis · 26 tips and reviews
General American Donut Company is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

56. General American Donut Company

8.0
827 S East St, Indianapolis, IN
Bakery · Fletcher Place · 14 tips and reviews
Tex-Mex Supermarket is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

57. Tex-Mex Supermarket

8.0
1104 S East St (Prospect), Indianapolis, IN
Mexican Restaurant · Near Southside · 19 tips and reviews
Bakersfield Mass Ave is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

58. Bakersfield Mass Ave

9.0
334 Massachusetts Ave, Indianapolis, IN
Mexican Restaurant · Downtown Indianapolis · 107 tips and reviews
City Market is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

59. City Market

8.3
222 E Market St (btwn N Delaware & N Alabama St), Indianapolis, IN
Food Court · Downtown Indianapolis · 69 tips and reviews
Punch Burger is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

60. Punch Burger

8.3
137 E Ohio St (Pennsylvania and Delaware), Indianapolis, IN
Burger Joint · Downtown Indianapolis · 65 tips and reviews
St Elmo Steak House is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

61. St Elmo Steak House

9.0
127 S Illinois St (btw Maryland St. & Georgia St.), Indianapolis, IN
Steakhouse · Downtown Indianapolis · 197 tips and reviews
Napolese Artisanal Pizzeria is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

62. Napolese Artisanal Pizzeria

30 S Meridian St (at W Maryland St), Indianapolis, IN
Pizzeria · Downtown Indianapolis · 19 tips and reviews
Mesh is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

63. Mesh

7.9
725 Massachusetts Ave (N Park), Indianapolis, IN
American Restaurant · Chatham Arch · 60 tips and reviews
The Capital Grille is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

64. The Capital Grille

9.0
40 W Washington St, Indianapolis, IN
American Restaurant · Downtown Indianapolis · 42 tips and reviews
India Garden is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

65. India Garden

8.5
207 N Delaware St (bt E Ohio & Miami Sts), Indianapolis, IN
Indian Restaurant · Downtown Indianapolis · 15 tips and reviews
Market Table is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

66. Market Table

7.6
333 S Delaware St (East South Street), Indianapolis, IN
Breakfast Spot · Downtown Indianapolis · 6 tips and reviews
Forty Five Degrees is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

67. Forty Five Degrees

8.1
765 Massachusetts Ave (at N College Av), Indianapolis, IN
Sushi Restaurant · Chatham Arch · 69 tips and reviews
Mo's... A Place for Steaks is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

68. Mo's... A Place for Steaks

15 E Maryland St (Corner of Penn & Maryland Street), Indianapolis, IN
Steakhouse · Downtown Indianapolis · 19 tips and reviews
Three Carrots is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

69. Three Carrots

222 E Market St, Indianapolis, IN
Vegan and Vegetarian Restaurant · Downtown Indianapolis · 13 tips and reviews
Bangkok Restaurant & Jazz Bar is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

70. Bangkok Restaurant & Jazz Bar

225 E Ohio St (at Delaware St), Indianapolis, IN
Thai Restaurant · Downtown Indianapolis · 12 tips and reviews
Spoke & Steele is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

71. Spoke & Steele

7.9
123 S Illinois St, Indianapolis, IN
American Restaurant · Downtown Indianapolis · 9 tips and reviews
Union 50 is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

72. Union 50

8.8
620 N East St, Indianapolis, IN
Gastropub · Downtown Indianapolis · 31 tips and reviews
The Flying Cupcake is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

73. The Flying Cupcake

8.6
423 Massachusetts Ave, Indianapolis, IN
Cupcake Shop · Chatham Arch · 28 tips and reviews
Morton's The Steakhouse is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

74. Morton's The Steakhouse

41 E Washington St (at Pennsylvania St.), Indianapolis, IN
Steakhouse · Downtown Indianapolis · 22 tips and reviews
Yats is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

75. Yats

8.6
885 Massachusetts Ave (Btwn St Clair St & 10th St), Indianapolis, IN
Cajun and Creole Restaurant · Downtown Indianapolis · 26 tips and reviews
Mimi Blue Meatballs is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

76. Mimi Blue Meatballs

7.9
874 Massachusetts Ave, Indianapolis, IN
New American Restaurant · Downtown Indianapolis · 20 tips and reviews
Delicia is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

77. Delicia

8.7
5215 N College Ave, Indianapolis, IN
Latin American Restaurant · Meridian Kessler · 24 tips and reviews
The Eagle is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

78. The Eagle

9.2
310 Massachusetts Ave, Indianapolis, IN
Southern Food Restaurant · Downtown Indianapolis · 36 tips and reviews
Good Morning Mama's Cafe is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

79. Good Morning Mama's Cafe

8.8
1001 E 54th St (at Winthrop), Indianapolis, IN
Breakfast Spot · Meridian Kessler · 68 tips and reviews
Rook is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

80. Rook

7.7
501 Virginia Ave, Indianapolis, IN
Asian Restaurant · Fletcher Place · 31 tips and reviews
Calvin Fletcher's Coffee Company is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

81. Calvin Fletcher's Coffee Company

8.5
647 Virginia Ave (at College Ave), Indianapolis, IN
Coffee Shop · Fletcher Place · 85 tips and reviews
Wildwood Market is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

82. Wildwood Market

8.5
1015 Virginia Ave, Indianapolis, IN
Organic Grocery · Fountain Square · 5 tips and reviews
Vida is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

83. Vida

8.2
601 E New York St, Indianapolis, IN
New American Restaurant · Downtown Indianapolis · 8 tips and reviews
Henry's Coffee Bistro is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

84. Henry's Coffee Bistro

7.6
627 N East St, Indianapolis, IN
Coffee Shop · Chatham Arch · 42 tips and reviews
Kizuki Ramen & Izakaya is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

85. Kizuki Ramen & Izakaya

7.9
2450 E 146th St, Carmel, IN
Ramen Restaurant · 7 tips and reviews
Szechwan Garden is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

86. Szechwan Garden

3649 Lafayette Rd, Indianapolis, IN
Chinese Restaurant · Eagledale · 21 tips and reviews
The Sinking Ship is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

87. The Sinking Ship

4923 N College Ave (at E 49th St.), Indianapolis, IN
Pub · Meridian Kessler · 97 tips and reviews
Ezra's Enlightened Cafe is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

88. Ezra's Enlightened Cafe

8.5
6516 Ferguson St, Indianapolis, IN
Vegan and Vegetarian Restaurant · Broad Ripple · 7 tips and reviews
Jockamo Upper Crust Pizza is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

89. Jockamo Upper Crust Pizza

9.1
5646 E Washington St (at N Audubon Rd), Indianapolis, IN
Pizzeria · Irvington · 112 tips and reviews
Bazbeaux Pizza is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

90. Bazbeaux Pizza

9.0
811 E Westfield Blvd (bt Central Canal Tr & Guilford Av), Indianapolis, IN
Pizzeria · Broad Ripple · 44 tips and reviews
Arni's Restaurant is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

91. Arni's Restaurant

8.6
4705 E 96th St (at Brandt Rd), Indianapolis, IN
Pizzeria · Keystone at The Crossing · 42 tips and reviews
Some Guys Pizza is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

92. Some Guys Pizza

9.3
6235 Allisonville Rd, Indianapolis, IN
Italian Restaurant · Eastwood · 28 tips and reviews
Puccini's Pizza Pasta is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

93. Puccini's Pizza Pasta

8.1
1508 W 86th St (Ditch Rd), Indianapolis, IN
Pizzeria · North Willow Farms · 16 tips and reviews
Puccini's Pizza Pasta is one of My Indy Dining Favorites.

94. Puccini's Pizza Pasta

8.3
3944 E 82nd St, Indianapolis, IN
Pizzeria · Castleton · 11 tips and reviews