Barstool Pizza Reviews

1. La Sicilia

9.1

155 Washington Ave (Belleville Ave.), Belleville, NJ

Pizzeria · 16 tips and reviews

Luigi's Pizza is one of Barstool Pizza Reviews.

2. Luigi's Pizza

8.7

686 5th Ave (btw 20th & 21st St), Brooklyn, NY

Pizzeria · Greenwood Heights · 47 tips and reviews

The Brook Tap House is one of Barstool Pizza Reviews.

3. The Brook Tap House

7.5

811 Passaic Ave, West Caldwell, NJ

Bar · 2 tips and reviews

Bazzarelli is one of Barstool Pizza Reviews.

4. Bazzarelli

8.4

117 Moonachie Rd, Moonachie, NJ

Italian Restaurant · 5 tips and reviews

The Woodstock is one of Barstool Pizza Reviews.

5. The Woodstock

5.5

446 W 14th St, New York, NY

Bar · Meatpacking District · 13 tips and reviews

Simò Pizza is one of Barstool Pizza Reviews.

6. Simò Pizza

8.4

90 Gansevoort St, New York, NY

Pizzeria · West Village · 5 tips and reviews

Pepe Giallo is one of Barstool Pizza Reviews.

7. Pepe Giallo

8.6

195 10th Ave (btw 21st and 22nd), New York, NY

Italian Restaurant · Chelsea · 104 tips and reviews

Gotham West Market is one of Barstool Pizza Reviews.

8. Gotham West Market

600 11th Ave (btwn W 44th & W 45th St), New York, NY

Food Court · Hell's Kitchen · 205 tips and reviews

Zero Otto Nove is one of Barstool Pizza Reviews.

9. Zero Otto Nove

7.0

15 W 21st St (Between 5th and 6th), New York, NY

Italian Restaurant · Flatiron District · 57 tips and reviews

Ralph's Pizzeria & Ristorante is one of Barstool Pizza Reviews.

10. Ralph's Pizzeria & Ristorante

8.7

564 Franklin Ave (at E High St), Nutley, NJ

Pizzeria · 27 tips and reviews

11. Frank's Trattoria

7.9

371 1st Ave (btwn E 21st & E 22nd St), New York, NY

Pizzeria · Gramercy Park · 18 tips and reviews

Frankies Spuntino 570 is one of Barstool Pizza Reviews.

12. Frankies Spuntino 570

570 Hudson St (at W 11th St), New York, NY

Italian Restaurant · West Village · 142 tips and reviews

Madeleine Rowan: Great neighborhood joint. The meatball sandwich ought not be missed. Crostinis are tasty, as is the (chilled) house red. The pasta usually isn't fresh, so discerning Italian eater's should skip it.

Seamore's is one of Barstool Pizza Reviews.

13. Seamore's

6.6

66 Water St, Brooklyn, NY

Seafood Restaurant · DUMBO · 11 tips and reviews

James Kiernan: Overpriced and lackluster service.