Planning a trip to Boston?
Foursquare can help you find the best places to go to.
Island Creek Oyster Bar
(Now Closed)Seafood Restaurant$$$$
Kenmore, Boston
Has a stamp of approval from CNN and Serious Eats
294 Tips and reviews
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
TingJuly 21, 2015Very good chowder. Think the secret is in the bacon that enhances the clam flavour. The biscuits r great too.Go for the oysters only if you want to support MA sourced ones.Give the fluke crudo a miss.
Twinkle DenoyoAugust 31, 2017Excelent service,waitress knew a lot about their beer and oyster selection. We ordered the island creek oysters, bouillabaise and lobster roll, everything was amazing!
Jingshu HuangNovember 5, 2015Oyster! They're so so fresh. Shrimp cocktail is also one of my favorite. The lobster roll is aweson.They have some sort of lobster soup, but not every time. So don't miss when you see it on menu.
Taisiia I.May 27, 2015The island creek oysters are amazing. Liked them more than the other ones. Great ceviche and grilled halibut. I'll be back ;)
المهره الصعبه ماهي لأي خيالJune 12, 2017Great lively atmosphere, nice crowd, amazing oysters collection, and excellent chowder. Ask for the Perennial cocktail 👌🏻🍸
Carrie CollinsApril 10, 2016Get a dozen oysters from the raw bar, but FYI "just fuck my shit up" is not an acceptable order. Lobster bisque and oyster sliders are a must.
ClaudioApril 18, 2016One of my favorites in Boston. Fresh and local oysters; must try the clams with bacon, monkfish with black rice or the fish and chips. Friendly staff, great location and a little expensive.- Elaine CourtneyMarch 19, 2016Oysters, littleneck clams, and bomb-diggity lobster roe noodles - this restaurant has all my favorites! I always get the Moon Shoals - NE oysters are brinier to begin with but these are just perfect.
JuanitaJune 24, 2016Sat at the bar with no wait during peak hours and it was fine! The oysters were so fresh--Island Creek were by far my favorite
Isabel WilliamsJuly 12, 2017bouillabaisse & ambience were both amazing - the bouillabaisse was seriously one of the best meals i have ever had. 10/10, so good, especially the amazing saffron broth!!! plus a super cool vibe
Adam K.April 5, 2017Excellent experience in every respect. Phenomenal staff, phenomenal seafood. Striped bass was to die for. Definitely save room for dessert.
Brendan HasenstabMay 14, 2014The finest meal I ate in Boston, period. (And I did my research before I arrived.) Superb fish (red trout), BUTTERMILK BISCUIT, excellent cocktails, and fine atmosphere. Don't miss it!
Elaine ShinNovember 26, 2016I'm typically not Annie fan of oysters, by this place is a little different. Oysters are fresh, presentations on point and they have alternative main dishes like salmon sooo delicious
Todd HamiltonAugust 21, 2015Our fourth time here and it gets better every time. One of the best restaurants vibes anywhere. The lobster roe fetuchini is outstanding and I can't resist that biscuits with honey.
Jenna FriedmanApril 30, 2017Awesome seafood. Oyster selection is top notch. Lobster roll hold the bread for gluten free option was perfect. Waiter even suggested mashed potatoes instead of chips that share a fryer.
Occasionally they'll have fish tacos as a special…if you're lucky enough to see them on the menu, definitely get them!
Abi PanickerJanuary 12, 2015Oysters and drinks were really good, my party all enjoyed their food, I made a point to try everything, I really found mediocrity, service was great, atmosphere is excellent
Christine LeeApril 26, 2013Island Creek oysters are so delicious! Great service, ambience & wine selection. Get the oyster sliders for apps & roe noodles, monkfish, or casserole for entree. Dessert: Rhubarb strawberry turnover!
AmateurConciergeMarch 22, 2018Good, fresh sea food yes, but the 9.5 is aggressive. Vibe is like an upmarket big box chain with 4 Star hotel quality food. Not hating jus saying. Would return tho- Always get the oysters here — particularly the Island Creeks and Row 34s…along with anything else that sounds interesting
Anna TyzikAugust 7, 2014Great oysters (obviously) and great cocktails! The lobster roll was a little too mayo-y for my liking but packed full of meat and the side of homemade chips are great!
Serious EatsJune 4, 2014Renowned for its oyster raw bar and knowledgeable waiters who can talk you through any variety (and suggest an excellent wine pairing).
Kenneth TiongOctober 28, 2012Lobster roll 4.5/5. toasted brioche. Lobster filling is a nice lobster mayo salad. Kettle chips could be crisper. Island creeks are excellent, nausets saltiest, smoothest. Belon a sweet-sour enigma.
schneidermike schneidermikeMay 2, 2016Fabulous oyster selection and great cocktails. Reservations recommended on weekends and during Sox games.- Daily specials here include hidden gems like this smoked shrimp pimento with chips and pickled onion!
Evelyn LingNovember 5, 2016this is one of my favorite restaurants ever. island creek oysters, clam chowder and roe noodles are mind blowing 😱
Sugair AlSugairJanuary 11, 2015The helpful and great staff make you chose the best Oysters in house. Don't miss the lobster roll. Bar, one of the best bars I've ever been to.
Jose JassoAugust 6, 2016Best Oyster Bar in Boston. Get a dozen of any oysters you like and a lobster roll.- On rare occasion you may find Lobster Mac & Cheese on the menu here…when you do, be sure to get it!
Erin YoungDecember 6, 2012If you walk in without a reservation, they can sometimes seat you at the dining bar. Excellent place to sit. The Island Creek oysters are the local, cheapest on the menu and huge. Well worth it!
Gozde ErsahinAugust 13, 2017Everything is delicious here! I tried oyster and seafood noodles, hmm yummy! A bit pricy though
Vanessa GatlinFebruary 17, 2014(Best of Boston 2013-SEAFOOD) Improper Bostonian says, "Bivalves are only the beginning. Whether it's pearlescent crudo, an inspired halibut with mushroom broth/ the gastronomic epiphany of trout..."
Veronica HAugust 13, 2013Worth the wait. Get the lobster roe noodles, rock harbor oysters, the biscuit, and the oyster sliders. Truly new Bostonian gourmet fish creations
Ha DiemAugust 30, 2014The fried oyster sliders were amazing! Raw oysters were super fresh. Seafood casserole had huge chunks of seafood. Definite must for oyster fans.- Meg BermanNovember 9, 2018This spot serves up fresh oysters, plucked from the sea every day. Experience Island Creek Oyster Bar for brunch or dinner. Reservations recommended.
Grace LeeOctober 7, 2016Good cocktails and a large variety of fresh oysters. Try at least 5 different kinds because they are distinct from each other!
EmilyDecember 20, 2016If you love oysters, obviously this is the place to go. Other favs: oyster sliders, lobster roe and short rib pasta
The stars align at the bar. Don't be afraid to ask for advice on a new favorite based on your old ones. Some of the best cocktails and seafood in the city are served here.
Mark CoffeyJanuary 29, 2013The One and only Crispy IC Oyster Slider appetizer never disappoints. One of the best appetizers in Boston
Renaissance HotelsFebruary 11, 2013ICOB’s lobster roll – fresh Maine lobster mixed with crème fraîche instead of mayo and pickles on delicious rosemary bread – is a game-changer. For more, follow us on 4sq or at
Natalie S.November 11, 2011The biscuit is to die for. Have with dinner or even dessert. Also recommend doing a sampling of oysters so you can taste the subtle flavors. They prepare them beautifully.
Tasting TableMay 4, 2012The oysters aren't the only draw here--try the lobster roll fashioned from a family recipe that has been passed down through generations. A delicious contender in our 2012 Lobster Roll Rumble: Read more
Flawless execution on oysters, lobster and fresh-caught fish in an urban-chic space. Creative cocktail list is a knock out!
1,524 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Island Creek Oyster Bar
500 Commonwealth Ave (at Kenmore St)
Boston, MA 02215
United States
Boston, MA 02215
United States
We opened the Island Creek Oyster Bar to bring the restaurant to the farmer. It's a collaboration joining farmer, chef, and diner in one space. We welcome guests to get to know their oyster grower, harvester, winemaker, distiller, brewer, and fisherman. One meal at a time.
Permanently closed (Show more)
- Mon–Sat
- 4:00 PM–1:00 AM
- Sun
- 10:30 AM–1:00 AM
(617) 532-5300
Features
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. Discover & Visa)
Wi-Fi
Yes
Outdoor Seating
No
Food & Drink
Menus
Brunch, Dinner
Drinks
Beer, Wine, Full Bar, Cocktails
See More
You might also like
- 8.2
"You can't go wrong with any of the seafood, but starting with the clam chowder is a must."
Steve Herrera - 8.2
"Incredible lobster soup (bit salty). Loved the miso salmon and lobsters. Truffle corn :)"
Elizabeth Burstein - 9.0
"The lobster rolls here are the best I've had. Very lightly dressed and incredibly fresh. Good prices to boot."
Annmarie
Places people like to go after Island Creek Oyster Bar
- 9.2
"Went during the offseason and the tour was still great. The tour guides are awesome."
Nicholas Kirsch - 8.7
"I love the atmosphere here, great music & great times!"
Nikole Lambert - 7.3
"Great service, very reasonably prices drinks...buffalo tenders are amazing. Highly recommended if you're in the BU area!"
Joe Gall
Appears on 1,345 lists
Created by DigBoston
200 items • 234 followers
Ultimate Summertime Lobster Rolls
Created by Foursquare Swarm
89 items • 248 followers
Created by Jessica Haider
166 items • 219 followers