See all
182 photos

Pisillo Italian Panini

Sandwich Spot and Italian Restaurant$$$$

Financial District, New York

Save

8.7^/10

437

ratings

Ranked #2 for Italian sandwiches in New York
"Best sandwich in NY.All fresh,all imported from italy...AMAZING"(6 Tips)
"peppers,arugula,balsamic dressing in semolina bread"(4 Tips)
"next sandwich...thanks"(3 Tips)
"Absolutely the best Italian sandwiches in the area!"(12 Tips)

94 Tips and reviews

Filter:

sandwiches
italy
authentic
paninis
casual
good for a quick meal
big portions
lively
great value
delis
bakeries
coffee
good for singles
roasted chicken
bread
prosciutto
mozzarella
porchetta
cash only
fresh food
(15 more)

Sort:

Popular
Recent

Indulgent EatsJune 13, 2016
Split one of their stellar Italian sandwiches and enjoy it in City Hall park for the power summer lunch with a friend. Try the namesake Pisillo with porchetta, prosciutto & buffala mozzarella.
KonstantinMay 10, 2017
Been here 25+ times
Consistently delicious.Definitely try to split one.My fav is the Napoli. Best panini place downtown if not in the city, hot peppers-amazing, too strong however, so getting then on the side is advised
Pedro Piñera BuendiaFebruary 4, 2018
This food is at a different level. The ingredients, the combination and the size of the sandwich is all you need for your tour around NY. The chefs are very nice and funny.
Jenna Odett LaskinJuly 25, 2016
Definitely best sandwiches in FiDi, easily split for 2 people, cash only. Authentic Italian lunch spot.
Cristina SánchezOctober 16, 2016
The Pisillo sandwich is perfect, I highly recommend it. Then we ordered the number 18, Catanzaro. I'm used to eating spicy, but this sandwich was so spicy that the flavor was completely ruined.
john scottAugust 21, 2015
THE BEST SANDWICH-PANINO IN NEW YORK...Amazing sandwich-panino,all the fresh stuff is SUPER FRESH,and all the aged stuff comes direct from italy.The sandwich-panino delicious and HUGEEE.I LOVE PISILLO
Marissa SutherlandMay 1, 2020
can never go wrong with the item named after the place. So delicious and splurge for the sfilatino bread 😍
mary cataplanoNovember 23, 2015
This is a damn good sandwich.Everything is authentic and fresh,great cold cuts,selection breads,large portion size,fast service and the staff very friendly.I love this place,I love Pisillo...
Sam GilJune 15, 2016
Been here 10+ times
number 3 I think is my fav. they are all great.
Avin NarasimhanAugust 28, 2016
Sandwiches are absolutely massive. Could make at least 2 meals out of one sub. Meats are high quality, everything is fresh. Not sure how people eat this for lunch on workday.
simon mc cainApril 18, 2016
Hands down the Best Sandwiches in New York.All meat and all products imported from italy,all fresh,Huge sandwiches...AMAZING I can't wait for next sandwich...thanks Pisillo
Michael FernandezJune 3, 2018
I heard lots of positive things about Pisillo's but never anything about the $. Because although it's a little on the expensive side it's absolutely worth it. Easily an entire days worth of sandwich.
frank collinsNovember 28, 2015
AMAZING SANDWICH...One of the best in all of NYC.Their ingredients are all quality and the mozzarella is imported from Italy.I can't wait for next sandwich...GOD BLESS PISILLO...
Barry HottJanuary 2, 2018
Get the incredible Pisillo! Prosciutto and porchetta in one massive sandwich!
kathleen tolentinoJuly 25, 2015
This would be what i consider the epitome of an Italian sandwich. Every ingredient is very fresh as you can taste it, the meats are superb and imported i asked =) and the owner is very friendly
michelle williamsNovember 22, 2015
STILL GOOD.This place is awesome,excellent authentic Italian sandwiches,with super fresh ingredient and great bread.All imported from Italy.My favorite sandwiches so far in NYC...
Jonathan BrandonOctober 12, 2015
I had the New York (roasted Chicken, mozzarella, hot peppers, arugula and lemon dressing) on a Cibatta. Big sandwich if you like hot peppers. Cash Only!
andrew marvillFebruary 4, 2016
Best sandwich.#31 Montesarchio panino.Parma Prosciutto,fresh mozzarella,roasted peppers,arugula,balsamic dressing in semolina bread AMAZING.Highly recommended this place.Thanks Pisillo see you soon
Justin DickinsonDecember 17, 2016
Giant sandwiches you won't be able to finish in one sitting. The real deal for Italian sandwich cravings.
Sharonn ZhengNovember 11, 2016
Best Italian sandwich place in town. Super crowded during peak lunch times. Cash only. Order for pickup on Seamless!
Alex RavenelMay 17, 2016
Excellent Italian sandwiches on awesome bread. They are HUGE--know what you are getting into. The #1 and #8 are personal favorites.
Rebecca MazzaMarch 25, 2016
Been here 5+ times
One sandwich could easily make for 3 meals. Amazing prosciutto and bread. It is super Italian
Alex BosworthOctober 31, 2018
One sandwich is good for two people, get it on semolina bread
Lou CarulliJanuary 4, 2018
Been here 5+ times
Can’t say enough good times about this place. Huge sandwiches that are delish! I always recommend it
John PavlickAugust 12, 2016
Great ingredients and a ton of food for not very much money. A sandwich can easily feed two, maybe three, people
Pete JelliffeJanuary 7, 2016
Been here 25+ times
This is only half my sandwich. It's not a panini, it's a gigantic 2-pound hero with panini ingredients: smoked mozz, prosciutto, red peppers
Chris NatoliNovember 7, 2015
Awesome Italian sandwiches. Several vegetarian options. And the sandwiches are huge so they're actually pretty cheap since they're big enough for two meals
Amulanga ChinkushovaDecember 27, 2018
Super delicious sandwiches, very generous portions so be sure to split it with someone
Joey LacusJuly 2, 2019
Absolutely fantastic sandwiches. Great prices. As good as an Italian panini can get. A hidden gem.
Juan BuisMarch 8, 2016
One of the best sandwiches I've had in NYC. These things are enormous and easily shareable for two people.
Rich HauckAugust 21, 2018
Likely the best cold sandwich I’ve ever had in this city.
Jeff PetrielloFebruary 10, 2017
The vegetarian options are extremely simple, but don't worry...they're delicious.
Nicole MarieMay 29, 2018
Everything is delicious here. Seriously. Huge sandwiches. Worth the price. Cash only. Get semolina bread.
joseph bresciantJuly 18, 2015
O.M.G.This is the BEST sandwich I've had in my life.All ingredient imported from italy.AMAZING.THANKS PISILLO YOU ARE THE BEST
Helly SolomonDecember 17, 2021
This location was excellent. The sandwiches are huge. My mother and I each got a sandwich when we arrived. Because they are so large, I should have simply ordered one. They're full of flavour.
michael rossJuly 18, 2015
Hands Down Best Sandwich in New York.Huge and delicious,all fresh ingredient,amazing bread.HIGHLY RECCOMENDED
Kerryn UngerSeptember 8, 2016
The smoked mozarella and Artichoke on multigrain bread was delicious!
Acacia Graddy-GamelJanuary 29, 2016
These sandwiches are equally delicious and enormous. And they are absurdly delicious and enormous.
Joey LacusJuly 2, 2019
Cannoli are terrific. Coffees are great. One of the few places with pasticiotti.
Jacob RosenbergJanuary 24, 2016
Amazing Italian meats on panini. Everything they make is fantastic and huge.
Edmund BoeyMarch 14, 2017
Great sandwich, great value! Cash only!
Tim SheaFebruary 17, 2017
Been here 5+ times
Cash only; each sandwich could easily be two meals, if not three.
Mike DudasMarch 11, 2015
The largest and most amazing Italian panini in downtown NYC. A revelation.
Eugene KimbergJanuary 11, 2015
Been here 50+ times
Absolutely the best Italian sandwiches in the area! Everybody loves them. The only minor inconvenience is that this place is cash only.
Serious EatsFebruary 25, 2014
Great sandwiches big enough for two abound at this Financial District deli.
Jon PressmanMarch 10, 2019
New branch on 25 st is great
Bryant GarrettJuly 18, 2016
Amazing, authentic Italian sandwiches
Kyle LeBeauMarch 25, 2019
Some of the best sandwiches I’ve had
Rory ParnessFebruary 22, 2022
Sandwiches are huge! Get one to share or use for 2 meals
Bob TFebruary 3, 2017
Been here 5+ times
Everything is great here!!

1 2

182 Photos

Pisillo Italian Panini

Related Searches

You might also like

Places people like to go after Pisillo Italian Panini

Appears on 502 lists

Top places in the area

Is this your business? Claim it now.