Important Notice:We have made the tough decision to say goodbye to the Foursquare City Guide mobile app, effective December 15, 2024, with the web version to follow in early 2025. Visit our FAQ for more information or to download our Swarm app.Parm
Italian Restaurant and Sandwich Spot$$$$
NoLita, New York
Has a stamp of approval from Eater and Serious Eats
"GET THE SARATOGA CLUB SANDWICH, YOU WILL NOT REGRET IT."(25 Tips)
"Chicken parm is the best!! It’s better than the meatball parm"(32 Tips)
"Chicken parm sandwich will be the best decision you make all day."(33 Tips)
"S'mores ice cream cake is amazing!"(21 Tips)
489 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- chicken parmigiana
- sandwiches
- saratoga club
- ice cream cakes
- casual
- (15 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
order chicken parm on a roll. sit at the counter, relish the old school booths and salad bowls your italian family definitely owns. go for lunch on a friday or any day and smile at a tucked away gem
EaterJanuary 7, 2014The chicken parm, Italian combo, and Saratoga club are all strong choices, and you're going to want an order of the calamari and the Buffalo cucumbers too. [Eater 38 Member]Upvoted Aug 30
Order mozzarella sticks and the salami (ricotta) toast. Dip the sticks in the fresh ricotta. Then sit back and wait for the heart attack, so you can die a happy man. In memory of P-Hayes.
Chophel NamgyalJanuary 6, 2017Chicken parm hero is a 8.5/10. The seeded bread is perfect, the cheese is excellent, the cutlet was pretty good maybe a tad over done. I've had better and much hotter out of the oven. I'd come back!
Alex HennesseyAugust 27, 2015Chicken parm, obv. Mozzarella sticks are perfect, no frills, great crispy exterior. Great wine, too. Cool old-school red sauce vibe with classic rock (lots of Billy Joel) playing.
SuYeone JeonNovember 13, 2016LOVE this place!!! Everything is great. Garlic breads are often overlooked but definitely order them if mozzarella sticks are bit too filling. Rotini on the side of chicken parm is to die for!!
The New Plan: Bring a friend and go splitty-split on the mozz sticks (as an appetizer, obvs) and the Chicken Parm and Saratoga Club (chicken salad mixed w/ potato chips!). DO IT!
It's hard to pass up the famous chicken parm but the saratoga club is amazing too. You just have to get a side of house made mozzarella too if you go that way!
MeritSeptember 27, 2017Amazing amazing amazing 👌🏻👌🏻👌🏻 go for chicken parm - it's a chicken wrapped in mozzarella in a bun with some other amazing stuff! #nottobemissed
I know everyone goes for the chicken parm, but if you're not feeling something that heavy the Saratoga Club is excellent: chicken salad, lettuce, tomatoes, bacon, zesty mayor & potato chips.
Everything is delicious. Pay attention to the difference between the chicken parm and chicken cutlet sandwiches. My fave is the eggplant parm sandwich.
Lindsay BrookeJanuary 12, 2015Wow. Great spot. Get the garlic bread and chicken Parm in a hero. Meatball platter is also amazing. Tons of ricotta cheese with every dish!
Just one of the damned best places in NYC. The ricotta toast is magnificent (though ask for more toast if you are more than 2), Chicken Parm roll is sweet, and don't miss the ice cream cake.
John CusumanoJune 15, 2013The first thing you'll notice is how small this place is, even for NYC. Don't let the lack of space put you off-this place rocks. Great service. Veal parm is amazing, and the bolognese sauce is killer
Roberto BuaMarch 23, 2015Had the chicken parm hero (just perfect) and the Italian combo (packed with quality cold cuts, some crunch and the right amount of spice), both amazing and really filling.
Brittney PotterNovember 25, 2018Small menu but it won’t disappoint! We started off with the mozzarella sticks & I had the eggplant Parmesan sandwich on a roll! My entire family had meatball subs and enjoyed!
This old school, red-sauce italian sandwich spot is brought to you by 2 relative whippersnapper chefs in the NY restaurant scene, and they've done good. A favorite Foursquare lunch spot.- Ask if they have the Rock Shrimp Bruschetta - a special seasonal item. It's like the crazy delicious cousin to the lobster roll - the cousin you want to eat over and over and over again.
Jeffrey GlueckNovember 25, 2015They discontinued the mozzarella sticks!! Sacrilege! Best in nyc and dropped from the menu. Unfathomable.
Olof CarlsonDecember 9, 2015Chicken and meatball parm, both great. Go here for a quick filling meal but be aware: the pasts is surprisingly spicy and the music is so loud that you want to leave at first.
Leo SumulongJanuary 19, 2015The chicken parmigiana was everything I was hoping it would be and better. I'll hopefully be back to try all the parm varieties and the delicious I looking side dishes.- DoubleDeuceApril 29, 2015It's a very right squeeze in here, especially for the toilet. But if you can sit up front by the bar or are happy to be cozy in the back, then come and enjoy the great food!
Patrick ManusJune 4, 2014Clearly specialize in parm sandwiches, and they aren't kidding around. It's unbelievable. Place is pretty small but service is quick and to everyone's surprise they play some dope R&B to top it off
It's hard to believe a turkey sandwich can be this good. It's thick cut, roasted in some delicious spices, and finished off with a spicy mayo on top.
Serious EatsMarch 29, 2013A throwback Italian-American sandwich shop from the serious chefs who brought you Torrisi Italian Specialties. The meatball parm and chicken parm are standouts.
JeffreyJuly 13, 2014House-pulled “mozz,” in balls or sticks; the vinegary iceberg “Sunday” salad, which becomes a “Holiday” salad with some salami and cheese; and the eponymous sandwiches—eggplant, chicken, and meatball
Katy ZackAugust 6, 2014Great hearty Italian sandwiches. While you can never go wrong with chicken and eggplant parms, turkey is the jam. Add a side seasonal veggies and thank me later.
Alexis ConventoFebruary 12, 2016Consistently the best chicken parm sandwich - just the right about of crispiness, clean tomato sauce and the sesame seed bun 😋
Melissa RogersJanuary 26, 2014From Eater: a casual Italian-American bar and sandwich shop - the second restaurant from Mario Carbone and Rich Torrisi. Order the chicken parm, Italian combo, or Saratoga Club, plus the calamari.
Jenna DrapkinJune 23, 2013believe the hype. chicken parm, fried calamari, and ice cream cake were all great! the price is right - and vegetarians can choose from options galore. waiter gave a ton of freebies also!
Don't miss the potato and egg platter. Omelette-esque, red peppers, side of ziti. Breakfast for dinner, and then use Cover to skip the bill.
The Corcoran GroupJuly 9, 2013The chicken parmesan - in platter or sandwich form - is to die for. Finish it off with a slice of the ice cream cake for a truly indulgent meal.
the Saratoga Club gets lost in the shuffle but is my sleeper choice for best sandwich. and despite everyone raving about the buffalo cucumbers, the broccoli rabe is far superior.- Listen, the chicken parm & mozz sticks will blow your mind, but if you're feeling a little #FatDenny the chopped salad (with chicken) is a real sleeper hit. Do it!
JoleneFebruary 14, 2012Total Italian comfort food. Can't go wrong with a Parm sandwich but if you want something really memorable, get the spicy yet delicious Saratoga Club. Recommend the calamari and brussel sprouts too!
Welcome to one of my favorite places to eat. You seriously can't go wrong with anything on this menu but I suggest: turkey on a roll, chicken parm platter, Saratoga Club, and the ice cream cake!
Great food, perfect cocktail. ( Russian mule) happy employees. Mgr. checked in with us to make sure we were all Ok. Nice location. I’ll be back !
Elizabeth BursteinMarch 10, 2018The mozzarella sticks and meatball hero are amazing! The chicken parm is good but go with the meatball!
- Come for a late lunch on Saturday after the rush. Sit at the bar, order any Hero sandwich, relax and watch some English Premier League action.
Steven LambiaseOctober 9, 2014The chicken parm is easily best I've ever had. Flavorful tomato sauce, little basil, perfectly cooked chicken breast, amazing sesame roll. None like it.
Don't let the Mozzarella Stick Mafia strong-arm you: Get the garlic bread deluxe (garlic bread + ricotta + marinara) and never look back.
Loved the mozzarella sticks, baked ziti & eggplant roll. Also, the spicy rigatoni that comes with the platter!
Be careful when you try the eggplant parm. It's so good that you'll never be able to order eggplant parm from any other place. This is the price of perfection.
Halstead PropertyOctober 8, 2013What else to order other than a meatball parm from a place called Parm? The melted mozzarella in the toasted hero is mouthwatering with the juicy meatballs and fresh tomato sauce.
Claire J SongJune 1, 2015Patty Melt, $25 The beef they use for this patty melt goes where no patty-melt beef has gone before: into a LaFrieda meat locker, where it’s aged for 60 days. Plus great smashed potatoes on the side.
eggplant parm sandwich is the best I've ever had. Perfectly cooked tender eggplant, great tomato sauce, loaded with fresh basil, on fantastic semolina bread. The eggplant sandwich to die for!- In a neighborhood filled with excellent restaurants, Parm is probably my favorite. I always get my sandwiches on a roll because the bread tastes better than the hero. Plus it saves you room for cake!
Nina NFebruary 3, 2016This shop only makes Parmigiana'ed things and they are all delicious. Special shout out to the meatball parmigiana on a roll. Also, cocktails!- In my experience, the meatball parm (more like a patty) comes out much quicker than the chicken. So if you are here for a quick bite, get the meatball (both are equally delicious though)
888 Photos
Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Open until 9:00 PM (Show more)
- Mon–Sun
- 11:00 AM–9:00 PM
(212) 993-7189
Features
Reservations
No
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. American Express & MasterCard)
Wi-Fi
Free
Outdoor Seating
No
Food & Drink
Menus
Brunch, Lunch, Dinner, Dessert
Drinks
Beer, Wine, Full Bar, Cocktails
See More
You might also like
Appears on 2,287 lists
Created by naveen
49 items • 274 followers
15 Bucket List Sandwiches in NYC
Created by Foursquare City Guide
15 items • 287 followers
