Has a stamp of approval from Eater and The Corcoran Group
54 Tips and reviews
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
The Corcoran GroupOctober 9, 2013This new West Village gem is a solid option for delicious (and reasonably priced) homemade pasta. Start with the meatballs and split the pappardelle, garganelli and/or the chicken with a friend.
Lindsay CNovember 16, 2015There's something for everyone on Pagani's menu. Enjoy seafood, salad and pasta dishes - and don't forget to order a cocktail or glass of wine to wash it down.
EaterNovember 7, 2013The menu from Mark Barrett includes things like a poached farm egg with oyster mushrooms, rigatoni with braised rabbit, slow roasted veal shoulder with potato puree, and seared scallops with fennel.
Great new spot in the hood. Great playlist for the music lovers. Folded chicken, pistachio gelato and buffala app were all 👌. Solid red wines by the glass.
A FSeptember 20, 2013Great new local gem not to be missed! Get the buffala, poached egg and meatballs. Pastas are all homemade and superb! Great service and scene in general!
EvieAugust 19, 2015Everything is good here! Some notable faves--grilled watermelon, duck breast, and folded chicken. Great $5 - $7 happy hour specials as well from 4pm - 7pm.
Ashley KellamNovember 19, 2013Get a few things to share: duck confit appetizer and gnocchi were great! Atmosphere is super cute/romantic, and waitstaff are super friendly
CBS New YorkJuly 7, 2015They're serving a special cocktail with vodka, aperol, basil, lemon and tonic and baked veal meatballs during NYC Cocktail Week (July 13th through the 17th). Read more
Roula HannaSeptember 5, 2015Tried their linguini alla limone part of the Walks of NY food tour. It was delicious. This place feels more like a Tappas bar.
ChavelliJanuary 2, 2014Delicious and super friendly. Enzo is warm and welcoming! Men try The Gentleman cocktail. Get the poached egg and pistachio gelato!
Brian TothSeptember 13, 2014Great brunch- not crowded, eggs Benedict, steak and eggs, mimosas... Friendly servers, and feel-good 80s throwback music!
Dane FeldmanFebruary 26, 2016Great dishes and creative cocktails. A bit pricy but wonderful atmosphere and fantastic service. Would return.
ᴡᴡᴡ.Necede.nxwo.ru HJanuary 24, 2016Great brunch. Spinach Cup Baked Eggs were really good. Light taste but filling. $3 Bloody Mary and mimosas aren't bad either
Melissa RosenthalDecember 21, 2014Great Italian spot in the west village. Highly recommend the pasta dishes.
Stella FlameSeptember 25, 2013Get the zucchini salad the soft shell crab app and the folded chicken - bergamot dessert and Victrola cocktail - move over Aperol Spritz!!
Stephen LambethNovember 21, 2015If you like seafood, the octopus is delicious! You absolutely MUST try the meatballs appetizer! Amazeballs!!- DoubleDeuceMay 13, 2016It looks a little stuffy from the outside but once inside, it's courteous, great food and reasonable prices. Not stuffy at all.
Chloe BecquetJune 11, 2015Food is great! Cheese platter was excellent. A bit crammed in for dinner but super friendly staff
Jo RausenDecember 29, 2013Decent Italian - duck confit was the fave, followed by the homemade bolognese and poached egg. Artichoke salad is good, if you're into salads.
Fueled CollectiveSeptember 16, 2013What was once a music store is now are tasty Italian eatery with loads of vegetables! Simply delicious.
Meg FarmerNovember 22, 2014Scallops were delicious, but let down by everything else we tried. At the end of the day there are better spots.- CBS New YorkApril 26, 2016They're serving a Victory Prima Pils and an Baked Veal Meatballs for Ale's N Apps Week (May 9-13)
Amanda KellyFebruary 20, 2015Great vibes and ambiance! Check out the virtual tour before you go! Read more
Serious EatsFebruary 22, 2014Thoughtful Italian cooking shows promise with tender octopus, but some of the food needs work.
98 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Permanently closed (Show more)
- Mon
- 11:30 AM–11:00 PM
- Tue–Fri
- 11:30 AM–1:00 AM
- Sat
- 11:00 AM–1:00 AM
- Sun
- 11:00 AM–11:00 PM
(212) 488-5800
Features
Reservations
Yes
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. Discover & Visa)
Outdoor Seating
No
Wheelchair Accessible
Yes
Music
Yes
Parking
Street
Restroom
Yes
Food & Drink
Menus
Lunch, Happy Hour
Drinks
Beer, Wine, Full Bar, Cocktails
See More
You might also like
- 8.9
"Delicious Italian food paired with an old time interior and friendly service make for a place you’ll want to keep coming back to."
Brian Pinard - 8.9
"Really classy ambiance. Enjoyed the bread w aubergine, steak for 2, spinach ravioli (although a bit eatery), and pecan pie. 18 santa barbara chardonnay and rum, pineapple cocktail"
Elizabeth Burstein - 9.2
"Faves: hams and zeppoli, fennel & grapefruit, clam toast, tortellini, pasta in pink clam sauce, duck, and “affogato” decomposed dessert. Perfect martini was perfect. Good vibes, almost over the top."
Noah Weiss
Places people like to go after Pagani
- 7.7
"SmLl cocktail bar above five guys. Great ambiance and drinks. Order their special five Guys burger and fries!"
No Leftovers Jackie Gebel - 8.7
"Great beer selection - a must if you enjoy beer!"
Nathan Halberstater - 8.2
"Phenomenal cannolis and pistachio cookies. Plus they have homemade tarallis! Franco is such a nice old Italian man :)"
Nikki 🌺
Appears on 188 lists
Created by Rana Rouhana
166 items • 518 followers
Created by Ashley Gildin
173 items • 38 followers
Created by CBS New York
82 items • 110 followers
