Norman's Cay
(Now Closed)Caribbean Restaurant and Bar$$$$
Lower East Side, New York
18 Tips and reviews
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Sebastian BlandNovember 19, 2013Go with 4 or 5 friends, order the entire menu and feast! Fish tacos, ceviches conch fritters, it's all good, you absolutely cannot go wrong with any one thing on the menu, drinks included.
MatherDecember 10, 2015The pork buns are to die! And I highly rec the chicken wings and tacos, too. And don't forget to put their housemade hot sauce into a Red Stripe!!
Lene Krogh JeppesenOctober 2, 2014Nice food, excellent service, and you can get the hot sauce to go ($5).
An OccesSeptember 25, 2014The decor is on point. But the portion sizes for food are a tad bit ridiculous. Each meal smaller than the next and pricy. You are better off going to Negril Village or Footprints and be satisfied.
madison masseyDecember 1, 2014Mmm the spicy fries are good. But don't underestimate the hot sauce, spicy!
Nandi AndersonOctober 12, 2015Good food. But when it gets busy the staff can't adjust. We waited an hour and a half for our entrees.
Amanda KellyFebruary 20, 2015Nantucket feel for sure! Check out the virtual tour before going. Read more
35 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Permanently closed (Show more)
- Mon–Thu
- 5:00 PM–Midnight
- Fri–Sat
- 5:00 PM–3:00 AM
- Sun
- Noon–Midnight
(646) 481-1229
Features
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. American Express)
Outdoor Seating
No
Food & Drink
Menus
Brunch
Drinks
Full Bar, Cocktails
See More
You might also like
- 7.0
"Don't look for beef patties and jerk. These folks are Haitian and Creole is what they do. The poisson is light and crispy. Picklese will have you crying for water. Opt for whatever is on the stove."
Harlem Ambassador - 8.6
"I usually get the 'exact' same thing every time I go here b/c I'm pescetarian-vegetarian. The curry tilapia w/ rice n' peas, cabbage, mac n' cheese, plantains, candy yams, and sometimes the red cake:)"
Janae PIerre - 7.3
"2nd time here. I always go for the baked chicken with Mac n cheese n sweet potato yams!!!! Yummy!!"
Rachel Letch
Places people like to go after Norman's Cay
- 7.0
"New England-style raw bar. Seafood privately sourced from Maine. Fresh oysters. Expect live-edge Saxelby cheese boards. Potato-bunned cheeseburgers.Twelve taps and a grip of bottles."
7th.List - 7.4
"The food and drinks are pricy but worth it. Get the Ten Dollar Pretzel....and their French toast dessert!"
Bonnie Carpenter
Appears on 66 lists
Created by Yaw E
22 items • 12 followers
Created by Patrice C
63 items • 8 followers
Created by Rana Rouhana
166 items • 518 followers
