Mr. Z's -Old Town
Pizzeria and American Restaurant$$$$
Key West
"Everything is amazing, Cheese Steak & Pizza are our favorites!"(22 Tips)
"welcome sight right off Duval Street late at night than this slice"(2 Tips)
"Slice here, Pie home!!!!"(2 Tips)
"Cheese fries are amazing!"(3 Tips)
56 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- cheesesteaks
- pizza
- cheese fries
- good for a late night
- great value
- (14 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Judy ChouOctober 11, 2012Call me a blasphemer, but I dare say that this Philly cheesesteak with prov is better than either Pat's or Geno's in Philly. This will definitely be our go-to place here.
Michael FennerJune 2, 2011Best cheesesteaks on the island. Try the cheesesteaks or pizzasteak. Everything here is amazing. Hit it up on your walk home from duval for even better results.
💫CocoApril 15, 2018Best pizza so far in key west! Quite a few people mentioned the cheese steak, however it didn't live up to the hype.
Sarah GillespieJuly 10, 2015The meatball pizza is the way to go! With mushrooms or broccoli rabe & extra garlic! Yummy!
B ReilNovember 2, 2013The Best....great food, great owner & great staff! Tell everybody who goes to Key West its a must stop......
- Brendan LewisJune 27, 2014There's no more welcome sight right off Duval Street late at night than this slice of cheesesteak heaven.
- Everything is amazing, Cheese Steak & Pizza are our favorites!
Kel E BeeMay 9, 2013We drove to Key West from Islamorada just for these Cheesesteaks - best cheesesteaks south of Philadelphia! Bet on it!
Chad HorrellFebruary 5, 2013Cheesesteak is awesome! Pizza is awesome! Beer is awesome! Service is awesome!
Marcel P.November 26, 2014Close to duval street. A big slice of pizza for 2,5 $, that's fair and it's tasty.
Annie NilandFebruary 17, 2013Order the Cheese Fries, you will not be disappointed!! And the pizza? Amazing!
Pesh AritoJanuary 2, 2013Try your Philly cheesesteak with the in house made, melted American cheese sauce.
It's the best cheesesteak you can get outside of Philly.
Raph SangiovanniJune 23, 2012It's good, cheap pizza that's available until 4 a.m. You can't go wrong with that.
paul mentaSeptember 3, 2011It's all real Philly Yo! I know I am from there bread and steaks from downtown Philly makersGo phils.....E A G L E S !
megan mcnamaraMay 31, 2011The owners a great Guy, best pork sandwich I've ever had. Place felt like I was home in Philadelphia!- ChelseaMarch 18, 2011Best cheesesteaks I've ever had - definitely plan on making this your last stop of the night!
If your getting a cheesesteak, the cheese fries are a must as well!!!
shawn LANEAugust 5, 2013When you order an American without, they have no idea what your talking about.
StephenJuly 6, 2013Horrible service, skip going. Instead try Pizza Joe's on Duval St. Only a few steps away, much better pizza, quick and friendly service.
Nathan JokersOctober 11, 2011Been drinking all night? Swing my Mr. Z's to prevent that inevitable hangover. Read more
61 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
We're a Key West staple for all things Philly inspired. If you haven't tried us out, that should be your next move!
Open until 4:00 AM (Show more)
- Mon–Sun
- 10:30 AM–4:00 AM
(305) 296-4445
Features
Reservations
No
Credit Cards
No
Outdoor Seating
Yes
Food & Drink
Menus
Dinner
Drinks
Beer
See More
You might also like
- 7.4
"Best Philly cheesesteak sandwich outside of Philly that you can get in my opinion - and I've have ones from Philly! Oh and the cheese fries are amaze balls"
Jennifer Russo - 6.1
"Expensive for pizza, but it's so worth it. Angelina's Pizza is amazing & delicious! Friendly staff is definitely a plus."
Amy Malespin - 6.3
"Medium Honolulu Hawaiian between three of us was perfect when we arrived at our resort. Soft drinks cups are huge!"
Clare McCahill
Places people like to go after Mr. Z's -Old Town
- 8.6
"AWESOME dive bar, good live music, cold beer that’s very affordable. More of a local hangout especially late night. No food, but they do have popcorn. If you like dive bars Green Parrot 🦜 is A MUST!!"
Brad Hager - 8.3
"Tasty food with live music. Especially sea food quiche!"
Hande Ardane - 8.1
"Really good strawberry daiquiri loved the drink!!"
Bhavishya Kadri
Appears on 33 lists
Top 10 favorites places in Key West, FL
Created by paul menta
10 items • 8 followers
Created by Rob V. Burr
12 items • 3 followersCreative Innovations Cause Related Advertising
Created by Steve Hulsey
194 items • 7 followers