Fifty Henry
(Now Closed)Wine Bar$$$$
Brooklyn Heights, Brooklyn
54 Tips and reviews
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
CompassApril 21, 2014Local restaurateurs Mark Lahm (who also owns Henry’s End) and James Montemarano (owner of Cranberry’s Deli) run a candlelit cafe that’s perfect for grabbing a bite on the way home.
Weekend brunch here is downright pleasant. The French toast is a particular favorite and the promenade is a short stroll away for a perfect Brooklyn Heights afternoon. Read more
Kathrine HartvigsenMarch 28, 2018Great local cafe/restaurant with Great food and service. We can really recommend the burger and the salmon/avocado BLT
Libor M.June 7, 2019Very respectful barman, I truly like this type of nice people, making the place so nice to be...
WilberDecember 23, 2013This place is amazing to go with your significant other. Great ambiance and delicious food.
Doctore AguacateJanuary 7, 2014check the reserve wine list. any bottle open for BTG. you are crazy if you dont think this place is a great wine bar.
Terence HsiehSeptember 1, 2013The Rioja is always nice. Air conditioned. They serve plain bacon too-- goes well with reds (apparently)
Best artisanal cocktails in Brooklyn Heights. Try the specials--there's always something tasty there.
Julien AleksandresJanuary 21, 2016Took 45 minutes for the food to arrive. I asked if I could at least get the salad component - after 1/2 an hour. Look at my photo and ask yourself - does this take 45 mins on a night with empty tables
Karen BowersMay 28, 2013A nice spot for a glass of rose in the afternoon. The one from Long Island is nice.
Lieke BossMay 11, 2010The wine here is great! And whatever you do, have some dessert! The food ain't great but the desserts are little pieces of heaven. (no that's not the wine talking)
Now that I know this place is owned by the folks at Henry's End, definitely coming back for more.
Jose SalasAugust 30, 2010Marc & Alex! Great chaps and fantastic martinis courtesy of Marc ! do try it if you visit
Justin TravisSeptember 29, 2013The service here is simply atrocious. The wine came out quick, but cheese and meats (!!) took ~40 minutes.
The jalepeno margarita and the sazerac are totally awesome.
Julia TApril 17, 2014horrible service - "small plates" more like non existent plates -- ordered the white bean crostini and literally was a teaspoon of the white bean & lemon dip.... waitress barely paid attention to us!
Tom AbrahamSeptember 1, 2010Bacon Marcona Almonds are a pleasant snack....then again what isn't with bacon in it?
ginny hAugust 28, 2012Mediocre food. Mediocre service. Tipped over to bad by a 30 min wait for a creme brûlée prepared in front of me after having waited 25 mins. Going on the not-good list
shaunaSeptember 29, 2013Very deceiving. An OK wine list and service took over an hour just to get your food delivered. People left AFTER being seated. Don't bother.
- TrevorAugust 13, 2012Tried this for Sunday brunch. Poor potatoes with the lobster poached eggs and 20% service charge added to the bill. Won't be back.
113 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Permanently closed (Show more)
- Mon–Thu
- Noon–11:00 PM
- Fri
- Noon–Midnight
- Sat
- 11:00 AM–Midnight
- Sun
- 11:00 AM–10:30 PM
(718) 855-5595
Features
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. American Express & MasterCard)
Wi-Fi
No
Outdoor Seating
No
Food & Drink
Drinks
Beer, Wine, Full Bar, Cocktails
See More
You might also like
- 8.7
"Trendy vibes, solid playlist, and great wine. What’s not to like?"
Michelle Wiles - 8.0
"They kept all the stuff you loved from the LES original — dollar oysters, great natural wines — but with a slightly more polished, spacious space and a cute backyard."
Cole Kennedy - 7.9
"Cozy spot, really friendly owner. They have a nice whiskey selection in addition to the wine. Also, try the hotdogs, especially BK heat!"
Demetri Karagas
Places people like to go after Fifty Henry
- 8.3
"Excellent service, penne lobster rich and creamy goodness, goat cheese salad delish, crab cakes amazing, and fried chicken has a hint of cinnamon- not my cup of tea but pretty good."
M T - 8.3
"My go to place for great Italian in BKHeights. Solid seafood and pasta options. Heads up - Closed on Mondays and cash only."
Basak
- 7.0
"Draft beer selection is surprisingly good. The menu seems to rotate almost weekly, and selections are always solid. Staff is knowledgeable and friendly - but Pete is by far the best!"
Emily Kolodner
